What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

NZ v Cook Islands cancelled

NRL-TGG

Guest Moderator
Messages
1,354
This sucks for Rugby League in the Cook Islands but the decision is a good one, if you can't ensure the NZ team will be of test quality then there is no use playing the game. The NZRL also do a lot of international football in the pacific islands. In the last few years they have played unprecedented matches against the likes of Tonga and Samoa. Hopefully the Cook Islands will get a game next year which will hopefully develop into more matches for the area into the future - likes those end of year matches between PNG and Fiji.
 

Coastbloke

Bench
Messages
4,174
Yeh, I was going to say it would be too easy to organise a NZ PMXIII to play PNG a week or two after the Oz PMXIII...

International RL doesn't do easy...
 

druzik

Juniors
Messages
1,804
Why not have a NZ PM XIII team based around the Domestic players play this game?

I mean the NZ domestic players have effectively zero to look forward to after a long hard season, and something like this where they can still get to rep their country may be a good one.

The ARL does something like this with all the other states. Each year there is an Australian Affiliates States team that tours the pacific... maybe its time for the AAS and NZ domestic side and some of the PI nations to have a 3/4 nations each year, base them on dpmestic players... gives them all incentives to keep playing.
 

nadera78

Juniors
Messages
2,233
The Cook Islands government has spent tens of thousands of dollars on the pitch, stadium, etc to meet the demands of the NZRL. Money they don't find easy to come by. And then the NZRL do this to them? Pretty rank for my money. At least send somebody over, don't just throw your hands up in the air and cancel it at the last minute. Poor effort from the NZRL.
 

kuwaiti kev

Juniors
Messages
339
I'm a big supporter of NZ rugby league, but this is poor.
OK so it wouldn't be anywhere near a test strength team, but it's a big deal for the Cooks. Send a team with a few top graders and fill out the rest with promising juniors or NSW/Qld Cup players or even some of the top domestic players.

*Shakes Head* big opportunity missed
 

hitman82

Bench
Messages
4,937
That's pretty disrespectful, and stupid IMHO.

We can easily name a strong team of NRL players:

1. Jason Nightingale
2. Kalifa Faifailoa
3. Gerard Beale
4. Junior Sau
5. Sam Perret
6. Benji Marshall
7. Nathan Fien
8. Jesse Bromwich
9. Issac Luke
10. Fuifui Moimoi
11. Adam Blair
12. Kevin Proctor
13. Jeremy Smith

14. Mose Masoe
15. Jared Waerea-Hargreaves
16. Sam McKendry
17. Sika Manu

...All we are really missing is a winger, a prop or two, our number 6 and a centre.
 

bazza

Immortal
Messages
31,110
Why not have a NZ PM XIII team based around the Domestic players play this game?

I mean the NZ domestic players have effectively zero to look forward to after a long hard season, and something like this where they can still get to rep their country may be a good one.

The ARL does something like this with all the other states. Each year there is an Australian Affiliates States team that tours the pacific... maybe its time for the AAS and NZ domestic side and some of the PI nations to have a 3/4 nations each year, base them on dpmestic players... gives them all incentives to keep playing.

Yep PM XIII or NZ 'A' - could easily have a mix of available NRL players and younger/domestic players
 

dimitri

First Grade
Messages
7,980
Yep PM XIII or NZ 'A' - could easily have a mix of available NRL players and younger/domestic players

nations in all sports have players injured or unavailable all the time!

just call them kiwis

either way - surely would have been good for those kiwis who havent played in a few weeks to get a game under their belts
 

Bluebags1908

Juniors
Messages
1,258
The NZRL should compensate cook Islands the $40,000 lost. I like the quotes in red :D


http://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/league/5705997/Cook-Islands-to-lose-400-000-on-cancelled-test
Cook Islands to lose $40,000 on cancelled test



JUSTIN LATIF


Last updated 15:20 29/09/2011


The Cook Island Rugby League Federation is set to lose $40,000 after the New Zealand Rugby League's about turn on playing a one-off test in Rarotonga on October 6.

NZRL CEO Jim Doyle announced that 29 Kiwi players are unavailable due to injuries and other reasons which has forced the cancellation of what would have been the first ever test match between the two nations.
Federation president Charles Carlson says most of his squad has already assembled in the Cook Islands with all their flights and accomodation being covered by his organisation.

"We've invested a lot into this and the cancellation will have a big impact. It's costing us roughly $40,0000 and basically we've got no chance of getting that back," he said.

"We were quite shocked when we heard that a nation who has first pick of a lot of the NRL's best players couldn't come up with a team."

Mr Carlson cites NRL stars Alex Glenn, Zeb Taia as just two current players with Cook Island heritage who his selectors can't pick because they've been selected for the Kiwis.

"I can understand it from their point of view, we've got a strong side and it's the first time we've managed to get all our NRL players together so they don't want to lose to the Cook Islands for the first time."

The NZRL have promised to still send an eight or nine players for promotional duties and Mr Carlson says a visit from Benji Marshall would be ideal.

"I still haven't heard who will be coming, but Benji Marshall is a big star, and if they sent him just by himself it would almost make up for it.

"This event has created huge interest here. Rugby league has overtaken rugby in the last few years as one of the most popular sports."

Mr Carlson points out that his federation also have a few involved in the NRL grand finals day, including Auckland Vulcan's halfback Issac John - but arrangement have been made to ensure they could make the test fixture.

"Our coach David Fairleigh is one of the coaching staff for the NZ Warriors and he is flying straight here after the game plus any of the Cook Islands players involved in the finals."

Cook Islands: Tinirau Arona (Sydney Roosters), Neccrom Areaiti (North Sydney), Sam Brunton (Sydney Roosters), Jonathan Ford (Sydney Roosters), Byron Ford (Newtown), Anthony Gelling (Auckland Vulcans), Isaac John (Warriors), Drury Low (Canberra), Lulia Lulia (Shellharbour), Sam Mataora (Canberra), Dylan Napa (Sydney Roosters), Leon Panapa (Easts, Brisbane), Dominique Peryoux (Tweed Heads), Nathaniel Peteru (Warriors), Tupou Sopoaga (Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs), Brad Takairangi (Sydney Roosters), Karl Temata (Harlequins, London), Zane Tetevano (Newcastle). Coach: David Fairleigh (Warriors)
Ad Feedback
1x1.gif

- Stuff
 

franklin2323

Immortal
Messages
33,546
That's pretty disrespectful, and stupid IMHO.

We can easily name a strong team of NRL players:

1. Jason Nightingale
2. Kalifa Faifailoa
3. Gerard Beale
4. Junior Sau
5. Sam Perret
6. Benji Marshall
7. Nathan Fien
8. Jesse Bromwich
9. Issac Luke
10. Fuifui Moimoi
11. Adam Blair
12. Kevin Proctor
13. Jeremy Smith

14. Mose Masoe
15. Jared Waerea-Hargreaves
16. Sam McKendry
17. Sika Manu

...All we are really missing is a winger, a prop or two, our number 6 and a centre.

Even if only 1/2 can play. put NYC players in and call it PMXIII or something. Very poor
 

ozenzud

Juniors
Messages
696
Sorry, I can't believe all those players were unavailable. This is the first real stuff up under Jim Doyle's rein. He has been brilliant to date, but this harks back to the bad old days, the disorganisation and self serving leadership of the past.

Cook Islands must be compensated for this.

There has to be regular tests made available to the PI nations. Surely there has got to be some sponsors and opportunites to develop PI rugby league?
 

kiwileaguefan

Juniors
Messages
2,426
Though i am pissed off they called the game off, they did say from the outset that It will be a Kiwis test match but it will only be for the players who don't take part in the NRL finals.

Add to this the NZ Domestic season is still going, i can see why they cant field a team. Our only 4 halfs are in the finals for NRL or Super League. I guess this is the downside for having 3 kiwi sides in the final this weekend.
 
Top