To me , while Pete might not be this seasons ' star ' of the NYC, his talent and potential above anyone else in that team still stands out like dogs balls - in form or not.
Defensively he is a tough bastard and well advanced for his age. And in attack he shows strength levels way beyond that befitting of a guy his size. His fend is a stand out.
I look beyond his personal form. How are the NYC playing as a team? What style of football are they playing? Does their style of football show off the talents of Pete and give him the opportunity to stand out?
Is he getting quality ball from his halves? ( who are to be honest very good ball hogs )
The style of football the Knights have been playing in NYC has often been based right up the middle. The fullback featuring around the rucks.
But the fullback is 2010's new ball hog, and while he looks great in NYC, he is as far away from being picked for first grade as it gets.
All of this affects the chances of Pete being a superstar at NYC level.
Based on his skills and talent, he is by far and away the most NRL ready of the bunch.
That Josh Alomai lazy bugger ain't even close to the NRL until his own attitude changes on the field. But as you pointed out, Josh has plenty of quality players preventing him from playing 1sts.
Pete Mata Utia has Wes Naiqama.
It's time to give the kid a go.