What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Our Situation as a Club is beyond bad or tragic, it's disturbing.

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,835
No I would like to make the semis every year. I'm just putting it out there - did we really have a losing culture ?

since 08, yeah I think we did...

I remember just before the incredible run in 09 and the ex and i were on our wat to NY and I said the timing was perfect as i couldn't bare watch them at the moment, I think it was just before the necastle game at home.
 

IFR33K

Coach
Messages
17,043
I'm happy we are fixing our losing culture. Will it be fixed once Burt and Hindmarsh are gone?
Maybe next year is our year.

Mate, we are in a world of shit ATM. The only way out, is if we appoint the appropriate men, in the appropriate roles. And that's starting from the top.

I don't think we will turn the corner before 2014.

In regard to Burt and Hindy being part of the problem and being called losers, that's an absolute disgrace. The ones calling for Hindys head, are the same ones saying we could of won, or our defense could of been better against the warriors had he played.

Yeah, I really looking forward to Lassalo and Horo replacing Hindy and Smith. That should make us winners, and toughen up.

The other argument I like is b smith is shit, should retire, weak ect, now we are getting flogged and the same people are saying we miss b smiths defense.

Ps, if we do turn it around this year, maroubra eel will walk to a home game naked...... backwards.
 
Last edited:

IFR33K

Coach
Messages
17,043
you're taking the piss right??....there are people that want to string him up by the nuts publically at the town hall on church street and beat him with a stick..

from what I remember there's only 1 coach who was publically bagged more than SK and that's Hages..

I dont recall the team getting booed off during 09 or 10, like last week.

DA will always be a hero in my eyes, for punting that nuffie Finch.:lol::lol:
 

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,835
I dont recall the team getting booed off during 09 or 10, like last week.

DA will always be a hero in my eyes, for punting that nuffie Finch.:lol::lol:

well the extent of booing doesn't necesarily give you a guage on what time was worse...I remember people streaming out at half time after a bad first half.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
154,715
No I would like to make the semis every year. I'm just putting it out there - did we really have a losing culture ?
Yes, look at the major SF loss to the Cowboys in 05, never have i felt worse after watching a game of Footy. The 01 GF was bad enough but at least the players came back in that game. And i have completely blanked out that 98 Semi against the Dirty Dogs :crazy:.


But that 05 game summed up the clubs losing culture to a tee, Dragons were in the same boat and went out and got the best in the buisness but he had a massive head start on SK because he already went to a club that strong enough to contend for a title and he didn't have to make to many hard decisions. Hard decisions must be made for the club to move forward but look at the outcry and abuse Kearney copped for dropping a club favourite in Burt????? He's got no hope changing the club culture when he gets bagged for dropping someone that would barely make first grade and many other clubs.........
 

Maroubra Eel

Coach
Messages
19,044
If I remember correctly we had a heap of forwards out injured for the 2005 Cowboys SF game.
I think we played with only 1 recognized prop.
 

cv8z

Juniors
Messages
1,712
If I remember correctly we had a heap of forwards out injured for the 2005 Cowboys SF game.
I think we played with only 1 recognized prop.

I think hindmarsh was rested for the GF
So he could watch it on tv with no injuries:D
 

Wise Old Eel

Juniors
Messages
448
Casper, I've heard about enough. I need to repond. Anderson admitted himself, he had no answer for the sides good form in 2009. Hayne put in some of the best individual performances EVER. In 2010 it went backwards.
Anderson rode Haynes freakishness. There was no long term solution by Anderson. Kearney at least is showing some long term solution. the team he inherited last year was a rabble. He's had one season of recruitment, last 2 performances have been woeful.

You still don't see it?? On your first point, Anderson was being modest. He was giving the players the credit for turning it around. Anderson was the one who saw Hayne for what he was - a freak. He put him in at 6 very early on but Hayne was not ready. But what it did do, was allow Hayne to realise his abilities. When he moved back to fullback, he was a completely different player. As for "riding Hayne's freakishness", well what other choice did he have at the time. People seem to gloss over the fact that Anderson took a team that most predicted would get the wooden spoon, that most coaches would have gotten very little out of, to the GRAND FINAL. And it was no fluke. Check out his coaching record. The bloke has made something like 5 GF's in 10 years of coaching at the top level. How many other coaches can boast that record?

As has been stated many times - and the proof is out there if you just care to do your research - this administration did not want any ties back to the previous one. This included Anderson who was hired by Fitzgerald. They wanted him out from day one but his contract had just started. Had we not been so successful in 2009, he would have been punted then. Mate the bloke got some great results considering he was kept out of things like recruitment and given nothing like the free ride Kearney has gotten. Again, for those who want to argue the recruitment point, the proof is out there for all to see. He was also instructed to pick players like Daniel Mortimer & to build the team around him. Do you think it a just a coincidence that when Mortimer was dropped (oops, sorry, "rested") that the knives immediately came out for Anderson and Osborne then flew to Melbourne to sign Kearney? Anderson had had enough & his credibility was on the line as a coach. I believe at that point he told them to shove it, that he was the coach & he would coach the team the way he saw fit. The Eels picked but left themselves too much to do to make the 8 again.

As for "Kearney at least showing a long term solution", what BS. You don't think Anderson really had no plan do you?? Are you that naive?? The current "winners" running our club got taken it hook, line & sinker by propagana inflating Kearney's ability as a coach. As I have said previously, Kearney is living proof that lack of talent or experience will never stand in the way of getting you what you want if you have friends in the right places.

We are going down the gurgle folks. There is no sugar coating it. There is no "light" being held by Mr Kearney at the end of the tunnel. It is all a total balls up. People should be held accountable. Let's just hope that someone worthy decides to run against these current morons at the next election or our future is bleak at best.

WOE
 

SDM

First Grade
Messages
7,600
It is too boring for me, that bloke has made the same post about 200 times over.
 
Messages
13,876
We don't have a losing culture, it's more of a soft belly like Gus Gould always says about us. We are not mentally tough enough that when the game gets tight and tough of we have a lead we can't seem to win those games as often as we should.
Look at last year, how many times did we lead leading into the last 20mins and lose? even the last 10mins?
Thats a mental thing for mine and it is the culture of club and has been for many years. 2001 GF is a example of that, Knights came at us from the opening whistle and we could handle it we froze like statues on our goal line and let them run through us.
Thats all mental. These blokes all have the skill, we are a top 8 team on paper.
 

Springs

First Grade
Messages
5,682
I agree with the soft underbelly, not with the 'losing culture'.

I don't see how a losing culture gets us to the finals 9 times, Grand Final twice and two minor premierships, more than what a lot of clubs have achieved in that time. If there was a losing culture we would never have gotten near there.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
154,715
I agree with the soft underbelly, not with the 'losing culture'.

I don't see how a losing culture gets us to the finals 9 times, Grand Final twice and two minor premierships, more than what a lot of clubs have achieved in that time. If there was a losing culture we would never have gotten near there.
And what do we have to show for it???? Nothing, we lost the unloseable GF in 01 and we were unbackable favourites against the Cowboys in 05 and didn't show up. How many games over the years have we meant to win easy and lost???? Why is it always after a good season when we are expected to do well and go close do we play like Shit????? 02,06,08 and of course that absolutely outstanding season in 2010 :crazy: That is more than a soft underbelly that is a losing culture to a tee.......
 
Top