What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

panthers v mexicans team

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
13,878
This weekend against the Storm will probably be a good indication of whether we will be serious contenders for the top eight.

The Storm will be smarting after last week's loss and I would have much preferred to be meeting them had they have won last week.

While they may not be firing on all cylinders they will be very tough to beat and I suspect we will have to put in our best showing of the season to get close to them.

If we are fortunate enough to win it will surely be a close contest, but I suspect if the Storm win it will be by a margin of greater than 13.
 

Sleep

Juniors
Messages
2,377
More than anything I just want us to put up a good fight. We've got the forwards to give ourselves the advantage. The team as a whole might not yet be firing but I don't think you can fault the boys up front. They've been great for us so far this year.

The boys should go into Melbourne full of confidence. The Storm are really misfiring at the moment and are experimenting with Cameron Smith at five-eighth. Inglis is really out of form too. If we can limit Slater like the Titans did last week, though not necessarily using the same tatic it'll put us in a good position.

I'm not going into this game just hoping we don't lose by alot. I honestly think we can win.
 

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
13,878
It is such an even competition all teams are beatable including the Storm at there home ground fortress.

I was there a season to two back and the crowd factor is a major factor. They will get penalties on the back of the home ground support which is very vocal. To beat the Storm on there home turf means everything has to go our way from the match officials, to our on goal defence to our offence. We will have to be at our absolute best and that will mean at least a 50% improvement on anything we have produced thus far.Anything less and we will be on the receiving end.
 

murraymob

Coach
Messages
10,338
http://www.news.com.au/dailytelegraph/sport/nrl/story/0,26799,25322229-5006066,00.html


NRL
Article from:
Elliott furious with referees



0,,6575032,00.jpg
Having a blue ... a fight erupts between Storm and Penrith players with Greg Inglis in the middle. Photograph: Colleen Petch / The Sunday Telegraph


MELBOURNE STORM 16 PENRITH PANTHERS 14


FURIOUS Penrith coach Matt Elliott has blamed referees Tony Archer and Chris James as his team were denied a shock away victory against Melbourne. In a heavyweight slugfest, the Panthers took everything the Storm could throw at them and came up agonisingly short.
Diminutive fullback Lachlan Coote was in the firing line throughout, involved in a fight with Greg Inglis in the first half and then slammed into the ground by Will Chambers in the second.
Chambers was put on report for the hit which forced Coote to leave the field for a time before returning late in the match.

Elliott said he would front referees boss Robert Finch after the Panthers were denied what would have been a match-winning try in the 70th minute. Luke Lewis was ruled to have thrown a forward pass before Shane Elford crossed in the corner.
Elliott spent 30 minutes consoling his men in the dressing rooms before teeing off in a bitter post-match press conference.
"I am peeved, absolutely,'' Elliott said. "I felt they deserved that win. I don't think they fell down. For the second time this year, a result of our game was decided by decision out of our control.
"That is twice this year. There was three penalties given away right in front of the posts, I don't know if any of you noticed that. There was a decision not to award a try and there were three penalties awarded in front of the sticks. It will be scrutinised, that is for sure.''
Only a 60th minute Cameron Smith penalty goal separated the sides as the Panthers again proved they are no easybeats.
"I have got players in that dressing room who tried their hearts out and I have to ask questions on their behalf,'' Elliott said. "Again, there were decisions made that were the difference in the result between two very committed teams.
"My responsibility is to make sure they were the right decisions and to make sure we are not disappointed again. It cost us the game against the Bulldogs (in round two) - there were two mistakes they admitted.
"The referees are big blokes and don't shy away from their mistakes. I will be very interested to see what they will say. There are a few things I will need clarification on.''
Elliott was also critical of the Chambers tackle on Coote, with the NRl sure to investigate what was reported as a dangerous throw. "He got dropped on his head basically,'' Elliott said.
Melbourne coach Craig Bellamy, who was an animated figure in the coaching box throughout the match, conceded his halves combination was in need of a major overhaul. They went within just two points of rare back-to-back defeats at Olympic Park.
In fact, the last time that happened was in 2005. The NSW Origin coach confirmed the club would look at bringing in dumped Eels playmaker Brett Finch in the wake of the narrow win.
"I don't know if I have thought about it too much,'' Bellamy said. "I will have a look at it on Monday. It is about whether he wants to play in the NRL or go to England.''



Fulltime
MELBOURNE 16 (A Quinn B Slater tries C Smith 4 goals) bt PENRITH 14 (L Lewis B Tighe tries M Gordon 3 goals) at Olympic Park. Referee: T Archer, Chris James. Crowd: 10,110.
 
Last edited:

Fibroman

First Grade
Messages
8,216
Did anyone notice at the 15 minute mark, Cameron Smith was clearly held for what seemed like half a minute before slipping a ball out the back giving the storm a repeat set which ultimately led to Slater's try.
 

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
13,878
Did anyone notice at the 15 minute mark, Cameron Smith was clearly held for what seemed like half a minute before slipping a ball out the back giving the storm a repeat set which ultimately led to Slater's try.

The on field referees obviously didn't.
 

Caged Panther

First Grade
Messages
5,181
Did anyone notice at the 15 minute mark, Cameron Smith was clearly held for what seemed like half a minute before slipping a ball out the back giving the storm a repeat set which ultimately led to Slater's try.

I was blowing up about that at the time. Glad to know I wasn't the only one.
 

Fibroman

First Grade
Messages
8,216
Obviously when Sammut slipped over the line against the doggies after being held for 2 seconds, the refs were using a different chronometer that the 9 seconds that Smith was held with no forward momentum and not called held.
 

Latest posts

Top