What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Parramatta Leagues Club board sacked, administrator appointed

Messages
17,650
I don't believe that this comment from the magistrate is historically correct. Sharp took over from Spags and then promoted Seward from within after like 2 months. So past deals of wicked dodginess are from the Spags era. These cash payments and fake invoices were borne from player managers demanding payment for past deals. Am I wrong ?

“Those board members had, prior to the offender’s engagement as CEO, created the circumstance that they then pressured the offender to resolve, and in his seeking to do so, the offence before the court was committed."

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/spo...s/news-story/6a627783b48c13c1de1464a3f7c7db99

Still Shifting the blame?! Lol

This all happened under the plumbers regime. If not, what's your proof?
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,719
Still Shifting the blame?! Lol

This all happened under the plumbers regime. If not, what's your proof?

You're missing my point entirely as usual amigo. If your boss instructed you to commit a crime, he goes down with you. Where are the charges ? He either went rogue or he did what he was told. You cant have both.

AND if there is evidence that Seward just continued the Spags rorts then someone should be charged from that era too.

So until such time that other charges are laid, it seems to me that it was Seward along with Jason Irvine who colluded to cut corners rather than arranging legit TPA introductions or shedding players.

Perhaps someone who has followed this more closely than I could help - was there any evidence uncovered from Board minutes that actually discussed and instructed Seward and Irvine to do what they did ?
 

T.S Quint

Coach
Messages
14,600
You're missing my point entirely as usual amigo. If your boss instructed you to commit a crime, he goes down with you. Where are the charges ? He either went rogue or he did what he was told. You cant have both.

AND if there is evidence that Seward just continued the Spags rorts then someone should be charged from that era too.

So until such time that other charges are laid, it seems to me that it was Seward along with Jason Irvine who colluded to cut corners rather than arranging legit TPA introductions or shedding players.

Perhaps someone who has followed this more closely than I could help - was there any evidence uncovered from Board minutes that actually discussed and instructed Seward and Irvine to do what they did ?

From what I have seen, Seward was only told to "Fix the problem". He seems to be the one who decided to fix it by creating dodgy invoices. I'm still trying to understand how he escaped a conviction for this.
Being told by your boss to do something illegal does not absolve you from doing it. It just means they are also complicit. I don't give a f**k if you are afraid of losing your job, if I was asked to perform an illegal activity by my boss, you better believe I'd straight up resign right there on the spot.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,719
The scaredy cat judge needs to name names

Seems to me that the prosecution didn't try real hard to test what Seward had to say.

His lawyer's position was that he was just a silly billy trying to do the right thing by a demanding board who pressured him into committing a crime. Poor guy had enough and became whistle-blower.

Some might say that he became do-gooder whistle-blower after he was sacked after the way he handled the Hopoate Foran etc etc deals and maybe when the Board uncovered his mess.

A tearful Mr Seward met with the board on June 11. Sources say the board was split with some wanting the CEO to be publicly sacked. In the end, he was allowed to resign citing "family reasons".

LINK

Parramatta Eels CEO Scott Seward resigns in the wake of a tumultuous period for the club

LINK
 

Chipmunk

Coach
Messages
17,375
Seems to me that the prosecution didn't try real hard to test what Seward had to say.

His lawyer's position was that he was just a silly billy trying to do the right thing by a demanding board who pressured him into committing a crime. Poor guy had enough and became whistle-blower.

Some might say that he became do-gooder whistle-blower after he was sacked after the way he handled the Hopoate Foran etc etc deals and maybe when the Board uncovered his mess.

A tearful Mr Seward met with the board on June 11. Sources say the board was split with some wanting the CEO to be publicly sacked. In the end, he was allowed to resign citing "family reasons".

LINK

Parramatta Eels CEO Scott Seward resigns in the wake of a tumultuous period for the club

LINK

Lets be honest here, if this wasn't such a public case I doubt they would've even bothered prosecuting it. Also, he only really committed a crime due to a rather unfortunate technicality. The Leagues Club essentially owned and operated the Football Team. So if the Leagues Club and the NRL Team at the time were the one organisation, instead of two organisations with the same people on each board, then there would've been no crime, because the organisation who benefitted would've been the same organisation who was the victim. If Sharp and co were still in charge Seward would never have even been investigated, which is a little ironic considering it all.
 
Messages
17,650
You're missing my point entirely as usual amigo. If your boss instructed you to commit a crime, he goes down with you. Where are the charges ? He either went rogue or he did what he was told. You cant have both.

AND if there is evidence that Seward just continued the Spags rorts then someone should be charged from that era too.

So until such time that other charges are laid, it seems to me that it was Seward along with Jason Irvine who colluded to cut corners rather than arranging legit TPA introductions or shedding players.

Perhaps someone who has followed this more closely than I could help - was there any evidence uncovered from Board minutes that actually discussed and instructed Seward and Irvine to do what they did ?

I clearly recall the recorded board room tapes where the plumber and his fellow idiots were recorded talking about doing dodgey invoicing and then a fellow idiot board member sayings "that's illegal"
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,719
I clearly recall the recorded board room tapes where the plumber and his fellow idiots were recorded talking about doing dodgey invoicing and then a fellow idiot board member sayings "that's illegal"
http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...p/news-story/58142984fbfc7f07f1a69582febecd4a
The problem with reporting like above is that the Telecrap were purposely vaugue.

Was the board discussing the Seward rorts or the Spags rorts before them or were they planning rorts ?
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,719
Scott Seward says sorry to fans, saying he can now hold his head high

Former Parramatta Eels CEO Scott Seward leaves the Downing Centre Court on Thursday.
  • The Australian

Former Parramatta chief executive Scott Seward has made an unreserved apology to Eels members and fans for his conduct at the helm of the western Sydney club now that his fraud case has been settled in court.

Seward on Thursday received a two-year good behaviour bond for fraudulently obtaining $220,000 from the Parramatta Leagues Club to top up illegal player payments. He was CEO for two years, resigning in June 2015. In May last year, the NRL accused the Eels of systematically cheating the salary cap to the tune of $3 million over four years. The club was stripped of 12 competition points and fined $750,000.

Now that his case is over, Seward can finally speak freely after 18 months of silence.

“To the members and fans I offer my unreserved apology for the role that I played in this sorry chapter,” Seward told The Weekend Australian. “It was not my intention to bring shame to Parramatta, but to rebuild a club that you could be proud of, and I’m sorry I didn’t deliver this.

“You deserved better from the administration that I was part of.

“I take full responsibility and blame nobody but myself for the position that I found myself in. I could have, and should have, refused to do what I was instructed to do. I let myself down, my family and friends down, but also by tainting its reputation I let the club and members down.”

Seward, 41, pleaded guilty last month in the Downing Centre Local Court to arranging and authorising false invoices between November 2014 and mid-June 2015. He was interviewed at length last year by the NRL’s Integrity Unit to help the league unravel what had been going on at Parramatta. NSW Police’s Strike Force Rhodium continues to investigate the Eels’ salary cap scandal and frauds committed against the Parramatta Leagues Club.

“I hope that by volunteering information and assisting with the respective investigations, that I played a role in providing the club with an opportunity to make change for long-term benefit,” Seward said yesterday. “I walked out of the courtroom on Thursday with a massive sense of relief and a feeling of justification, knowing I did the right thing in coming forward. I can now walk the streets without having to hide, but being able to look people in the eye and not worry about what they think of me. It was an incredibly tough decision to come forward and do what I did, but the decision (on Thursday) justifies trying to right the wrongs.”

There has also been a personal toll, not only for Seward but his family. “My wife, children, parents, sister, family and friends have been through hell, and I couldn’t have got through this without them. They stood next to me and supported me, they never gave me anything but support, never questioned my integrity,” he said. “I’ve worked in sports administration for almost 20 years, and have worked hard to get the opportunities I’ve received. I made some mistakes and I’m accountable for that and I understand it leaves a black mark. I don’t know if the future for me is in sport and right now that’s not my focus. My family is.”

In handing down his judgment, Deputy Chief Magistrate Chris O’Brien said Seward’s criminality in the fraud charges was at “the lower end of objective seriousness for offences of this type”.

“The offender’s motive was not one of personal gain,” O’Brien said on Thursday. “Rather, (it was) to fix up what was a diabolical mess he had inherited from others.”



http://www.theaustralian.com.au/spo...h/news-story/5e95fa225f08787ee4f02a091dcc0a3e
 

Latest posts

Top