Player votes vs. Bunnies

[Timbo]

Votes are now open.

 

[Timbo]

1. CLINTON SCHIFCOFSKE
2. PHIL GRAHAM
3. CRAIG FRAWLEY
4. ADAM MOGG
5. DAVID HOWELL
6. JASON SMITH
7. LINCOLN WITHERS
8. RYAN O’HARA
9. SIMON WOOLFORD
10. TROY THOMPSON
11. MATT ADAMSON
12. KRIS KAHLER
13. JASON CROKER

14. MICHAEL WEYMAN
15. MICHAEL HODGSON
16. ALAN TONGUE
17. MATT GAFA

 

[Timbo]

3-Jason Smith. Short balls were magic and his kicking game was good.
2-Clinton Schifcofske. Was everywhere, back to his best.
1-Lincoln Withers. Showed heart back after his broken nose, kicked well and defended brilliantly.

 

[Mal Meninga]

3 - Kahler
2 - The halves(does that count meaning Smith and Withers get 1 each?)
1 - Choc

 

[centralcoastbrad]

3 kahler
2 smith
1 mogg

 

[DJ Raida]

thompson
smith
kahler

 

[brenno]

Thompson? Didn't see the whole game only highlights but, how did thommo have a better game than Smith, Schif or Withers? I think it's about time that Thommo goes back to the bench actually. He's really been the least impressive foward for the Raiders in their games so far.

 

[Raider_69]

Brenno, cheak out his stats
he carved it up this week
;-)

and im one of if not his biggest critics

 

[Timbo]

Thommo is REALLY being shown up this season. Last year (and years prior) he played second fiddle to Rhino and Statue and his 30 odd mins on the field saw us through.

But now he's being shown as thouroughly average, I still wish we'd kept Rutcho over him.

I'd go

8-O'Hara
10-Weyman
14-Cross/Miller

 

[Raider_69]

from NRL.com
Thompson's Stats:

28 tackles, 2 offloads, 21 hitups, 156metres, 7.43m Per Hitup, 0 errors, 1 mistackle
He was our leading metre getter in the forward, 2nd top tackler.

I dont rate him but credit where its due, he played well IMO

 

[Kris_man]

this Thompson bashing is ludicrous. he was one of our best.

 

[Raider_69]

this Thompson bashing is ludicrous. he was one of our best.

totally agree
and as said im one of his biggest critics

 

[reptar]

My votes:

3. Smith (of the Jason variety)
2. Kahler
1. Withers

 

[Raider Azz]

3 - Smith
2 - Khaler
1 - Croker

 

[mike83au]

3 pts: J.Smith
2pts: Schifcofske
1 pt: Hodgson

 

[thickos]

3 - Jason Smith
2 - Croker
1 - Kahler

 

[Chachi]

this Thompson bashing is ludicrous. he was one of our best.

Totally agree - 35 tackles last week with no misses as well. I'll take that any day thanks.

 

[FullySick]

3: Kahler
2: Smithy
1: Withers

honourable mention : Hodgo

 

[argy-bargy]

3- smith
2- wither me timbers
1- mogg

(what is howell doing in the side, diddly squat. maybe elliot promised him a few games as a sweetner to the signing)

 

[woodgers]

3. Jason Smith - "your supposed to be too old"
2. Kris Kahler - I was very pleased with him. When the going got tough, he got going
1. Jason Croker - Can someone tell me the last decade that this bloke missed a tackle?

0. David Howell - Run forward son.