Players most overrated by their own fans

[umina panther]

No one really from the Raiders. Besides one or two players, most are plodders.

Croker is a turnstile in defence but you guys rate him as "the best young centre in the game"

 

[andrew057]

Every young Raider player.

 

[Sea_Eagles_Rock]

Darren Lockyer - Glass jaw (Eye socket too), played through the backend of the golden era of Broncos success behind far better players and captained them through their worst seasons until retirement. Pure luck again at State of Origin level playing along with far better players made him look far better than he was. Shifted to 5/8 to hide his defensive weaknesses. Would have been in NSW cup for any NSW NRL side.

 

[woodyk2]

Imagine if Shane Watson was a league player.

 

[Usain Bolt]

Daly Cherry Evans, absolutely useless at rep level. Probably something to do with his giraffe neck

 

[Bulldog Force]

Bulldogs - Brett Morris

:lol:

 

[God-King Dean]

Imagine if Shane Watson was a league player.

 

[woodyk2]

Nailed it.

 

[natheel]

Tim Mannah

i don't think Eels fans over rate Mannah. I actually think a heap of Eels fans are quite hard on him the half think he's a solid player and there are a minority who think he should be playing for NSW

I honestly don't think anyone in our current squad is over rated in eels fans minds to be honest

Tigers- Luke Brooks, Robbie Farah
Broncos - Milford (the new Barba)
Dogs - Reynolds

 

[Phil McGrawhan]

Hayne .eels fans had him as walking on water .

 

[Vic Mackey]

Dogs - Jackson
Sharks - ?
Raiders - Crocker, Wighton
Tigers - Brooks, Moses
Eagles - Buhrer
Souths - Johnstone, Reynolds, Clarke
Dragons - nightingale, de belin
Eels - Morgan, mannah
Knights - McManus, rochow, snowden
Panthers - mansour, Cartwright, Taylor
Roosters - Cordner
Broncos - whoever they've signed for the next season
Storm - ?
Cowboys - cooper
Warriors - Manu, Tompkins
Titans - ?

 

[kbw]

Which players do you think are the most overrated by their own fans?

There's a reason Brett has only played 1 test. Slater, Hayne and even Hunt were simply much better players.

Your turn...

I agree that Slater and Hayne were better but Hunt only played rep football because 1000 fullbacks where injured. Hunt was way more overrated than Stewart.

Saying that $outh$ have to win hands down with both Merritt and especially Sutton

 

[Kiwi]

Darren Lockyer - Glass jaw (Eye socket too), played through the backend of the golden era of Broncos success behind far better players and captained them through their worst seasons until retirement. Pure luck again at State of Origin level playing along with far better players made him look far better than he was. Shifted to 5/8 to hide his defensive weaknesses. Would have been in NSW cup for any NSW NRL side.

Nice troll

 

[Franko]

Shannon Hegarty was an all time fav in this category.

 

[Franko]

Dogs - Jackson
Sharks - ?
Raiders - Crocker, Wighton
Tigers - Brooks, Moses
Eagles - Buhrer
Souths - Johnstone, Reynolds, Clarke
Dragons - nightingale, de belin
Eels - Morgan, mannah
Knights - McManus, rochow, snowden
Panthers - mansour, Cartwright, Taylor
Roosters - Cordner
Broncos - whoever they've signed for the next season
Storm - ?
Cowboys - cooper
Warriors - Manu, Tompkins
Titans - ?

Souths - Johnstone you are kidding aren't you. He had an outstanding first year.

 

[Vic Mackey]

I enjoyed the way he caught the ball and fell over the line 14 times

 

[Son of Minto]

Hes the new Merritt. All he has to do is fall down on to the try line.

 

[Mr Angry]

Darius Boyd, the fan, Wayne Bennett.

 

[Franko]

I enjoyed the way he caught the ball and fell over the line 14 times

You missed 7 he scored 21 tries and plenty of them weren't just falling over the line.

 

[Sea_Eagles_Rock]

Nice troll

The whole thread is a troll.