What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Ponting dropped from ODI squad

IanG

Coach
Messages
17,807
ESPNCricInfo.com said:
Ponting dropped from ODI squad

Ricky Ponting, the former Australia captain, has been dropped from the ODI squad for the remainder of the triangular series following the worst batting slump of his limited-overs career.

Scores of 2, 1, 6, 2 and 7 have drawn the curtain on Ponting's time as an ODI batsman, despite the fact that he served as stand-in captain for the injured Michael Clarke in the last two of those matches. In a 375-game one-day international career, never before had Ponting made five single-figure scores in a row. John Inverarity, the national selector, said Ponting would be missed, but the time had come to move on in the 50-over format.

"The team will not seem the same without him, but moving on from the omission of players who have been outstanding over a long period of time is the nature of elite sport," Inverarity said. "Ricky's record speaks for itself. He is one of the truly great performers in the history of Australian ODI cricket, with his reputation enhanced further by him captaining Australia to two World Cup victories.

"Ricky's contribution goes far beyond his batting statistics and his brilliant fielding. The example he sets in every respect and his extraordinarily positive influence in the dressing-room is acknowledged by all. He is held in the highest possible regard by his team-mates and there is no higher accolade than this. Ricky being prepared to take over the captaincy in Michael Clarke's recent absence for the sake of the team is yet another example of his selfless attitude and team-first focus."

Like Mark Taylor and Steve Waugh before him, Ponting was not given the chance to choose when he would end his ODI career. As late as Sunday night in Brisbane following Australia's win in Brisbane, Ponting said he had no intention of stepping aside, and had left his future in the hands of the selectors. Inverarity countered suggestions that Ponting might have been given a farewell match with the stark realities of professional sport.

"Ricky Ponting has been dropped from the ODI side and the national selection panel has spoken about moving towards the 2015 World Cup," he said. "The door is never closed on anybody, but it's a strong indication there. We were very keen for Ricky to play in these games because we intended to blend in some younger players, and his influence for them has been remarkable. But we need to at some stage move on.

"We're not ruling him out because one never knows what's around the corner … but we've certainly got 2015 in mind, and we knew at the beginning of the series when we wanted those young players to be blended in, in the presence of Ricky.

"In elite sport there's no place for sentiment. There are always the two schools of thought, going out on your own terms and that, and the members of the national selection panel were unanimous in their view. It was discussed by email last night, a few calls last night and was confirmed this morning. That's the decision and that's elite sport."

Ponting has been replaced in the squad by the allrounder and vice-captain Shane Watson, who proved his fitness after a stubborn calf injury by playing for New South Wales in a Sheffield Shield match against Western Australia in Perth. Inverarity announced one other change to the squad, recalling Ryan Harris in place of Mitchell Starc. He also confirmed that Matthew Wade had now usurped Brad Haddin as the No. 1 wicketkeeper in limited-overs matches, and that the panel intened to take both glovemen to the West Indies.

"Ryan Harris has been re-included in the squad with Mitchell Starc making way for his return. Mitchell will benefit greatly from the Tests and the ODIs he has played," Inverarity said. "His development as a player of the future is most encouraging. Shane Watson also comes back into the squad. He is an all-rounder of proven class and the NSP is keen to have him re-join the squad.

"The NSP made the decision that Matthew Wade is now the preferred ODI wicket-keeper for the Australian ODI team. The intention at this stage is to have both Matthew and Brad Haddin in the West Indies together for the duration of the tour."

Australian Squad:Michael Clarke (capt), Shane Watson (vc), Dan Christian, Xavier Doherty, Peter Forrest, Ryan Harris, Ben Hilfenhaus, David Hussey, Michael Hussey, Brett Lee, Clint McKay, Matthew Wade, David Warner

Sauce
 

aqua_duck

Coach
Messages
18,640
The selectors weren't left with much of a choice really, Ponting has been Darsh like this series, and its not even when he gets out, he's just never looked comfortable. I think he's a great fighter and has tonnes of heart, and thats reflected in his test performances this summer, but the brilliance just isn't there anymore and unfortunately in one day cricket you can't afford to see off the first 20 or 30 deliveries to get your eye in
 

JW

Coach
Messages
12,657
I have mixed feelings about him being darshed mid-series.

But as long as they still don't have a certain spud of batsman in mind to replace him long-term, then fair enough I spose.
 

aussies1st

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
28,154
Great to see the hard calls being made. And no silly "rested" excuse this time, flat out dropped.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
154,309
They had no other choice, if he continues to bat like this in the West Indies he shoudl be gone from the test team as well. If he won't retire he has to cop whatever the selectors choose.
 

IanG

Coach
Messages
17,807
Means nothing once you get out to the centre.

As somebody who has played cricket you can have all the nets you want but it's not the same as being out in the middle.

Wonder if he'll now turn out for Tasmania in the Ryobi Cup final on Saturday
 

VictoryFC

Bench
Messages
3,786
The selectors weren't left with much of a choice really, Ponting has been Darsh like this series, and its not even when he gets out, he's just never looked comfortable. I think he's a great fighter and has tonnes of heart, and thats reflected in his test performances this summer, but the brilliance just isn't there anymore and unfortunately in one day cricket you can't afford to see off the first 20 or 30 deliveries to get your eye in

Agree mostly. Though I think you can afford to see of the first 20 deliveries, permitting that you stay in and make 30 at least. Playing 15 defensive blocks and then skying it to deep square for a catch on your first offensive stroke is too much though.

Ponting should just retire from ODI's. He can still keep going in Test arena. But you have to wonder whether CA want have too many players who are only playing 1 format. If you can't play ODI, your Test spot has gotta be in trouble as well. They've set a precedent now, so hes gonna have to have a good tour in the Windies, regardless of what he managed this summer. Its definitely gonna make dropping him from Test cricket easier.
 

Tom Shines

First Grade
Messages
9,854
Means nothing once you get out to the centre.

As somebody who has played cricket you can have all the nets you want but it's not the same as being out in the middle.

Wonder if he'll now turn out for Tasmania in the Ryobi Cup final on Saturday

The joke

535306-sachin-tendulkar-cricket.jpg


You ^
 

Hallatia

Referee
Messages
26,433
Clarke accepts role in axeing Ponting
Brydon Coverdale in Hobart
February 23, 2012

Michael Clarke is confident his role on the selection panel that dropped Ricky Ponting from the ODI side will not lead to tension between Ponting and himself. Clarke is a member of the five-man group headed by John Inverarity that ended Ponting's one-day international career earlier this week after deciding they needed to plan for the limited-overs team's future.

However, Clarke and Ponting will have to work closely together as the No. 4 and 5 batsmen during the Test tour of the West Indies in April after Ponting confirmed he wanted to play on in the longer format. Clarke did not shy away from his role on the panel and said Ponting, who had made five single-figure ODI scores in succession, understood that the decision was not personal.

"I'm 100% part of the selection panel," Clarke said. "That's part now of the captain's job. We've made this decision as a panel. It is tough not having the great Ricky Ponting out there playing for us but that's the decision we've made. Obviously the 2015 World Cup is something we've spoken about as a panel. I'm 100% a part of that.

"Ricky was captain of the team for a long time and although he wasn't a selector he played a big part in selecting the XI players that took the field. I remember getting dropped after the Test match in the West Indies and Punter was the one who came and told me I hadn't been selected. He knows it's certainly not personal. I'm very confident our friendship is a lot stronger than that."

Australia will play their first match in the post-Ponting ODI era against Sri Lanka in Hobart on Friday. That Tasmania is Ponting's home state has been cause for some debate over whether he should have been given a farewell match - the Sri Lanka captain Mahela Jaywardene said there was usually scope for farewell games in his country - but Clarke said there was no reason to think Ponting had played his last match for Australia on home soil.

"He's going to play a lot more Test cricket I hope," he said. "So there's going to be plenty of time for Ricky to play international cricket for Australia."

Although Clarke has played 38 one-day internationals without Ponting in the side the feeling will different this time, knowing that his absence is permanent in this format. Not only is Ponting Australia's most-capped and highest-scoring ODI player, he has offered much in the way of off-field support, both as a sounding board for the new captain Clarke and as a mentor for younger players.

Ponting even took on the captaincy in his final two matches when Clarke was injured, while many former leaders might have been reluctant to return to the job in similar circumstances. Clarke said it was odd to think of an Australian one-day dressing room without Ponting after his 17-year career in the format.

"It certainly is [strange]," he said. "He's certainly going to be missed. I've been great friends with Punter for a long time and that certainly won't change. But I've also played a lot of one-day cricket with him and it's going to feel really weird looking around the field and not seeing him there.

"I'll miss his guidance out on the field, his guidance off the field, his friendship, his experience around the group, his knowledge of this game. They're things that no matter much talent you have as a young player, the experience and knowledge of the game you need to learn."

Ponting's departure will also force a reworking of Australia's top order. The nature of the line-up will depend on whether Shane Watson is named to play in his first match back from injury, but it could be that Watson and David Warner open with Michael Clarke at No.3 and Matthew Wade slides down the order.
Sauce
 

Hallatia

Referee
Messages
26,433
Sacking Ponting was 'tough' - Clarke
23 February 2012

Australian captain Michael has said he was partly responsible for the sacking of former skipper Ricky Ponting from the one-day squad.

Clarke wrote about how difficult the decision had been in a newspaper column on Thursday, while adding that the 37-year-old Ponting remained a "huge part of our test team."

"I'm 100 per cent part of the selection panel - that's part now of the captain's job," he wrote in a New Ltd column. "We've made this decision as a panel.

"It is tough not having the great Ricky Ponting out there... playing one-day cricket for us but that's the decision we've made."

Clarke replaced Ponting as captain after England completed a 3-1 Ashes series win on Australian soil in January last year, becoming part of the national side's selection panel.

Ponting's axing from the one-day side earlier this week as Australia build for the 2015 World Cup triggered fierce debate in the country.

Without peer in the 50-overs game, Ponting has racked up 13 704 runs in 375 matches at an average of 42, also winning three World Cups in his 17-year career, two as skipper.

After accepting his one-day international career was over, Ponting said he would continue in test cricket and hoped to play in the 2013 Ashes.

His test place had also been under pressure at the end of last year but he responded with 544 runs at an average of 108 as hosts Australia whitewashed India 4-0.
Sauce
 

Horrie Is God

First Grade
Messages
8,073
As much as a Ponting fan as i am,once he relinquished the captaincy he became a normal player & thus susceptible to the axe if his form waned to an alarming degree..

It did..

And he was duly given the arse..

Ponting copped it on the chin..

Clarke & the rest of the selection panel made a tough call..But one that was necessary..

If anything the decision has heightened my opinion of Clarke's captaincy..

F&@k that hurt..:(
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
154,309
As much as a Ponting fan as i am,once he relinquished the captaincy he became a normal player & thus susceptible to the axe if his form waned to an alarming degree..

It did..

And he was duly given the arse..

Ponting copped it on the chin..

Clarke & the rest of the selection panel made a tough call..But one that was necessary..

If anything the decision has heightened my opinion of Clarke's captaincy..

F&@k that hurt..:(
Agree with the lot of this mate, Clarke is showing he isn't afraid to make the tough decsions something Ponting the captain never could.
 

AlwaysGreen

Post Whore
Messages
51,033
"Ponting's axing from the one-day side earlier this week as Australia build for the 2015 World Cup triggered fierce debate in the country."

Really?
 

Tom Shines

First Grade
Messages
9,854
"I'm 100 per cent part of the selection panel - that's part now of the captain's job," he wrote in a New Ltd column. "We've made this decision as a panel.

Shouldn't he be 20 per cent of the selection panel?
 

Latest posts

Top