What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Pools Scrapped

crouching_tiger

Juniors
Messages
779
Clubs given more control over NRL draw

Tuesday, October 2, 2007 - 6:36 PM
The NRL has handed clubs the power to decide which teams they play at home in 2008 by scrapping its pool system for deciding next year's draw.
Clubs have until Wednesday to provide the NRL with a list ranking opponents from one to 15 based on who they most want to play at home next season.
It comes after the NRL club chief executives voted to remove the pool system which decided the 2007 draw because it prevented marquee match-ups and didn't capitalise on revenue for cash-strapped clubs.
Under the new system the NRL will try to accommodate as many club requests as possible for home games with the 2008 draw to be released later this month.
Clubs can choose their preferred home games based on marquee clashes, strong attendances, reducing travel or even avoiding the strongest teams to give themselves a better chance of premiership success.
NRL chief operating officer Graham Annesley said primarily the change in system was so that local derbies, such as Brisbane's growing rivalry with North Queensland and the Gold Coast, would be assured of being played twice each year.
"It should help to ensure those really high-profile games clubs like to play each year aren't missed because of the way the pool structure falls out," Annesley said.
"The Broncos playing the Cowboys and Broncos playing Gold Coast (twice) every year should pretty much be assured under this system.
"Depending on the pools (system) ... there may have been years when they played each other once rather than twice.
"It's got to be looked at in the context of each year there's only (six) teams I think it is you don't play twice anyway. In the past it has been a bit of lucky dip which six teams they are.
"We are instead going to move to a system where it is basically club requests for certain matches."
But Annesley has warned not all clubs will be happy with the final product and while there could be inequity in the 2008 draw, the NRL would try to even it out over two years.
"It's all been done in consultation with the clubs and in fact you could pretty much say it was club driven," Annesley said.
"They were fully aware under this system some clubs would do better than others in any particular year but we agreed to take a two year approach to it and if a club didn't fare as well as another club in one year then we would try and adjust that the following year."
One club ecstatic at the scrapping of the pool system is Manly.
The 2007 grand finalists were facing a horrendous draw under the pool system with guaranteed away games at Melbourne, North Queensland, New Zealand, Brisbane and Gold Coast.
"I am exceptionally pleased to hear that is not going to happen because the pools are being scrapped," Eagles chief executive Grant Mayer said.

------------------------
MY ORDER OF PREFERENCE

1. Storm
2. Broncos
3. Eels
4. Sea Eagles
5. Warriors
6. Titans
7. Knights
8. Cowboys
9. Rabbitohs
10. Dragons
11. Bulldogs
12. Panthers
13. Raiders
14. Roosters
15. Sharks
 
Messages
15,411
1. Storm
2. Broncos
3. Sea Eagles
4. Cowboys
5. Dragons
6. Eels
7. Bulldogs
8. Warriors
9. Knights
10. Titans
11. Panthers
12. Souths
13. Raiders
14. Roosters
15. Sharks
 

crouching_tiger

Juniors
Messages
779
LOL i assume everyone would prefer to see the Sharks at number 15. We have had the wood on them for quite some time now. Even if we were to play them twice a year at Shark Park most would feel pretty confident.
 
Messages
15,411
yeah, we want all the tough road trips as home games, then we can have all the teams we can draw high crowds against, then the rest.
 

innsaneink

Referee
Messages
29,384
Marshall_magic said:
yeah, we want all the tough road trips as home games, then we can have all the teams we can draw high crowds against, then the rest.

We'll still have to play some of these better teams twice though, I think its be better to only play them once if possible

I think clubs will be beingasked for one thingand recieving another...f**kin amatuer idea imo.

But Annesley has warned not all clubs will be happy with the final product and while there could be inequity in the 2008 draw, the NRL would try to even it out over two years.
"It's all been done in consultation with the clubs and in fact you could pretty much say it was club driven," Annesley said.
"They were fully aware under this system some clubs would do better than others in any particular year but we agreed to take a two year approach to it and if a club didn't fare as well as another club in one year then we would try and adjust that the following year."

pfft
 

crouching_tiger

Juniors
Messages
779
Bit like the refereeing this year....... Lets penalise the one team until they are beaten out of contention, then even the penalty count out when the game has already been lost. Makes for good business.
 
Messages
15,411
I reckon our draw will be the same as every other year, we'll get every single road trip out of Sydney, and will get all 8 Sydney teams at home, giving a minimal home ground advantage. We'll get the Cowboys in first 5 rounds, and Canberra in the middle of winter.
 

crouching_tiger

Juniors
Messages
779
Well either way.....we can't complain. We had a "dream draw" with a perfect run home into the finals at the end of this year and it all ended up on the scrapheap anyway.
 
Messages
4,743
I've thought about this and with a view to trying win our home games i've plumped for:
1. Soufs
2. Newtown
3. Adelaide Rams
4. Hunter Mariners
5. Western Reds
6. Glebe
7. Illawarra
8. Sth Qld Crushers
9. Annandale
10. Seven Hills - so Peter Lewis can return
11. University
12. Wynnum Manly

I reckon John Morris would be a hope of outplaying his opposite in at least 3 of those matches
 

crouching_tiger

Juniors
Messages
779
themanonthehill said:
I've thought about this and with a view to trying win our home games i've plumped for:
1. Soufs
2. Newtown
3. Adelaide Rams
4. Hunter Mariners
5. Western Reds
6. Glebe
7. Illawarra
8. Sth Qld Crushers
9. Annandale
10. Seven Hills - so Peter Lewis can return
11. University
12. Wynnum Manly

I reckon John Morris would be a hope of outplaying his opposite in at least 3 of those matches

Very surprised you haven't listed the Bega Roosters U/12s. :sarcasm:
 

Navjot

Juniors
Messages
393
uote=themanonthehill]I've thought about this and with a view to trying win our home games i've plumped for:
1. Soufs
2. Newtown
3. Adelaide Rams
4. Hunter Mariners
5. Western Reds
6. Glebe
7. Illawarra
8. Sth Qld Crushers
9. Annandale
10. Seven Hills - so Peter Lewis can return
11. University
12. Wynnum Manly

I reckon John Morris would be a hope of outplaying his opposite in at least 3 of those matches[/quote]
:lol: Im a bit suprised that sheens, simmons and co didnt rate a mention though in this , a bit dissapointing.;-)
 

T

Juniors
Messages
559
we should preference teams like souths, dragons, dogs, and roosters toward the bottom, as most play out of telstra and sfs (roosters) so there wont be much of a home ground advantage for them
 
Messages
15,411
themanonthehill said:
I've thought about this and with a view to trying win our home games i've plumped for:
1. Soufs
2. Newtown
3. Adelaide Rams
4. Hunter Mariners
5. Western Reds
6. Glebe
7. Illawarra
8. Sth Qld Crushers
9. Annandale
10. Seven Hills - so Peter Lewis can return
11. University
12. Wynnum Manly

I reckon John Morris would be a hope of outplaying his opposite in at least 3 of those matches

I'm surprised, he must of gone up a notch in your books because you called him John Morris not the ex parra spastic.
 
Messages
4,743
He's a f**king twat
An ex parra spastic f**king twat at that
We can only hope his sling is on for a year and we don't have to watch him murder 6 man overlaps again next season
Thank f**k it's only 3 months til the AGM/info day
 

aids

Bench
Messages
3,994
st george, bulldogs and souths all would get top picks from the club, these three are usually draw good crowds
 

smeghead

Bench
Messages
2,882
A balance needs to be found with this selection process.

Results matter so that is obviously the first consideration but sponsors dollars also are attracted by well supported teams.

As I said it's a balancing act.
 

chopsy_05

Juniors
Messages
613
I think the Tigers will be on the top of the list for most teams. Our fans travel well even though we've bombed the last 2 seasons.
 

Latest posts

Top