Qld got some good decisions

[Binga]

Source - http://www.news.com.au/dailytelegraph/sport/nrl/story/0,26799,25584944-5006066,00.html

Clear as day - Try

 

[kruzin]

Hayne threw the ball back, wasnt forward. Might have travelled forward, but he threw back.

LOL U moron...the ball was thrown 2 metres inside the field of play and bounced to metres in the in goal, a ball doesnt "Drift" forward 4 metres,

NSW Try 1 - Benefit of the Doubt
2 NSW Tries - Off bad QLD Charge downs
Creagh try - Definatley a no try,

So sure, NSW Got bad calls, but qld won and rightuflly so. they were the better team on the night.

 

[kruzin]

Spot the similarity

I was watching the game last night with a German guy who had never seen League before. He looked at the screen and then asked "Why are the referees sponsered by the same company as Queensland?"

:shock:roll:

LOL, Archer is a NSW loving prick, don't even try that.

 

[Iafeta]

How is the Creagh penalty BS? The rules are that you aren't held until the referee calls held. If you look at the replay, the defender on Creagh (cutie??) had rolled over him and Creagh had in effect broken the tackle (not surprising, he was destroying cutie all night). The tackle wasn't completed and he went to play it. It's a penalty every day of the week.

 

[Iafeta]

Looks on the line to me, no question. I can't believe it took them so many replays to get it right.

It does seem fairly obvious. But wait, I bet we'll hear about velocities and parralex's and third world twilight dimensions as to why you wouldn't rule that out.

Frankly, where's the blame on Hayne for running so close to the line? He's already busted the line, he's only got Slater to go, so drawing back in field is the more logical option. For some reason he tip toes with death and loses.

 

[Iafeta]

:lol: Right. If that was the ONLY angle we saw the replay from. Wonder why you didn't even bother to touch those rear-shots?

Would you like stump cam as well? Perhaps anus cam? What about football cam? How about a shot of the cheerleaders?

THe foot is out. He's even wearing specially coloured boots so people like yourself can get a grip and see reality....

 

[Iafeta]

a question
when thaiday 'intercepted' that ball in the 2nd half
was he ever on side?
i thought he wasnt, and my friend thought it was
but he was a qlder anyway so i dont know whether to trust him

No I thought Thaiday was offside for sure.

Question, when lockyer took the field gold shot, how far offside was Farah?

No conspiracies here mate. Calls went both ways all night. That's football.

Having said that, Steve Price also veered off to take out someone who was coming through to put pressure on Lockyer. Could easily have been a penalty either way.

 

[KHunt]

Love it how people south of the border need to have a whinge and can't say well done to Queensland once.

 

[Game_Breaker]

LOL U moron...the ball was thrown 2 metres inside the field of play and bounced to metres in the in goal, a ball doesnt "Drift" forward 4 metres,

NSW Try 1 - Benefit of the Doubt
2 NSW Tries - Off bad QLD Charge downs
Creagh try - Definatley a no try,

So sure, NSW Got bad calls, but qld won and rightuflly so. they were the better team on the night.

What are you on about?

4 metres forward, bloody hell. I know QLDers are biased, but no need to make crap up like that

:lol::lol::lol:

 

[Matt23]

Love it how people south of the border need to have a whinge and can't say well done to Queensland once.

We would, if you weren't all such a bunch of sore winning pr*cks, win or lose, you carry on like absolute tools :roll:

 

[KHunt]

We would, if you weren't all such a bunch of sore winning pr*cks, win or lose, you carry on like absolute tools :roll:

:lol:

What was the score last night again?

 

[8Ball]

:lol: at the people whinging at the decision. Regardless of whether the decision was correct or not, your mob should have shown a little ticker, given you were still 2-0 up at that stage with 6367455845 minutes left on the clock.

I seem to recall a game in 2006 where QLD were 14-4 down after a couple of shocking decisions in the second half..

We all know how that went.

 

[Binga]

Surely NSW coming back from 22 - 4 down shows they have ticker??

 

[8Ball]

And how about those 3 tries they let in straight after that decision on Hayne? The only person who did was Wing. He inspired the whole team in the second half.

 

[skaines]

Hayne no try

Creagh penalty for playing the ball too quickly

Falou penalty

Thaiday intercept - he was never onside and was at the time nsw had all the momentum

Wallace knocked on and gets six more.

Farah a mile offside for Lockyers field goal attempt.

Grid iron pass from hayne.

Offside from the kick when QLD where metres on side.

Do i need to go on?

 

[aussie_q_factor]

Wallace knocked on and gets six more.

Farah a mile offside for Lockyers field goal attempt.

Grid iron pass from hayne.

Offside from the kick when QLD where metres on side.

Do i need to go on?

Can't have that...you know...a little objectivity to this debate. :crazy:

These are blues supporters here. How dare you attack their pathetic, misguided conceptions of being Rugby League gods. :lol:

 

[skaines]

not to mention NSW lead the penalty count 5-4, and if he was truely in the pocket, NSW could of been penalised a lot more Parallel markers.

 

[Red Bear]

No I thought Thaiday was offside for sure.



Having said that, Steve Price also veered off to take out someone who was coming through to put pressure on Lockyer. Could easily have been a penalty either way.

I thought that was a clear penalty.

Not that it matters, qld were the better side, but you cant take out a defender like that, its essentially a shepherd

 

[lockyrulz]

I thought that was a clear penalty.

Not that it matters, qld were the better side, but you cant take out a defender like that, its essentially a shepherd

They guy he 'took out' was 10 meters offside. Should have been a penalty allright, to QLD.

 

[Knightmare]

Would you like stump cam as well? Perhaps anus cam? What about football cam? How about a shot of the cheerleaders?

THe foot is out. He's even wearing specially coloured boots so people like yourself can get a grip and see reality....

Oh, a gay joke. What a mature way to answer my query. I notice you still don't want to go near that OTHER camera angle which tells a different (and more accurate) story to the one you are bleating on about. If last nights' game was an episode of South Park then Hayne's boot would touch the line. But as it turns out, real life is 3-dimensional.