Cupid Stunt said:
What does D have to do with with whether or not a QB can perform? Unless I have the wrong game they are two completly seperate issues.
If you consider Bryant, Galloway & Glenn a prime time receiving corp then I'll stop now. Glenn might make it as a #2 WR but the other two would be lucky to make that on most teams. Rating them higher than S. Moss & McCareins is ludicrous & if you truly believe that then I think it's time to update your edition of Madden. #-o
I never said he had no talent, or little talent, or anything similar. I just think Carter has the ability to be a better QB. I agree 02 was a good year for Penny but thats getting to be awhile ago. Keeping in mind that while healthy & behind a similar line *he threw 1TD & 6INTs in his last four games* last year, theres as much chance he becomes average as there is he becomes Montana.
* Yes I stole this from an article I read the other day but so what! :mrgreen:
lol whats that saying...oh thats right D wins Championships, they didnt win the championship but there defense were the ones who got them great field posession and saw them make the playoffs...carter continually messes up and thats shown by his 21 ints, on avg he gets just over 1 td a game..yup he is a hell of a qb ;-)
chad wont be a montana but he will be a consistant qb in the future, he can do everything quincy can without having the brain explosions...as far as back ups are concerned quincy is great but in my mind he will never be a decent starter.
im not a fan of pennington but to even think that quincy is better then him has gotta be the weirdest thing ive ever heard concerning football.
i know you wont admitt that quincy isnt as good as chad but heck ill try and make it so obvious that he is, that even if there is a shroud of doubt in the eyes of the rest of the people here it will be squashed.
chad started 9 games, in 9 games he threw for 13 tds and 12 ints..yep he had thrown 1td and 6 ints in his last 4 games, so up until then he had 12 tds and 6ints...its not great but for a qb on a losing team he played well considering he had been out for a while. quincy played ok but he made far more errors and had it not been for the defense the team wouldnt have even made the playoffs.
quincy's last decent game was against the lions in where he threw 3 tds 190 yrds for a qb rating of 133.3..thats very good except for the fact it happend in october roughly week 6, other then that he failed to even regesiter some decent numbers, yes he got them the wins but against big teams he was non existant.
an avg qb is still around 100x better then quincy lol.