First one was off the boot, second was played at by Hindmarsh. You could debate otherwise, but Cummins definitely had a case with the calls he made.Bazal said:Oh my f**king god...how do you miss either of those knock ons??? Thank god we're 14 up
jimmyo said:Bahaha FG attempt...15-0 would make all the difference. Tim Smith shows his game awareness levels are optimum.
Good first half from the Eels there, although they could have pressed their advantage a bit more...
Ghoulies said:First one was off the boot, second was played at by Hindmarsh. You could debate otherwise, but Cummins definitely had a case with the calls he made.
Bazal said:Yes, because looking for as many points as you can get is criminal in this close competition :roll: The anti Tim Smith sentiments on these boards are getting beyond a joke
Originally Posted by Bazal
There's a case with the second one, but you see those week in and week out ruled knockon...The first one, we were denied a try because Grothe knocked it forward into his own hand last week...then again I guess consistency is too much to ask of the current crop of geniuss...er, referees
jimmyo said:He was in perfect position to put in a kick for Inu which is a 50/50 chance at a try so far - a much better option for points.
Do you honestly think Parra's season is going to hinge on one point even if he does kick it? That's a ridiculous suggestion. It was a selfish waste of good psition to give himself practice at kicking FGs in real game situations.
Tim Smith is the most unpredictable half in the comp - that makes him hard to play against and hard to support. Personally I reserve my right to saw whatever I want about him, if you're so far up his a#*e that you can't take it, then leave.