While Wests Tigers' rejection of Melbourne star Brandon Smith seemed daft at first, the club are laser-focused on building for the future rather than excavating the past.
www.abc.net.au
It's not often the Tigers are in a position to turn down a player of Brandon Smith's calibre, but if it was going to cost them the player who could be the cornerstone of their pack for the next decade, it made the decision a no-brainer.
Melbourne offered up their star dummy half to the joint venture on a one-year deal ahead of his anticipated move to the Roosters for 2023, but the Tigers slammed the door shut on any talks when the Storm asked for rising prop Stefano Utoikamanu in return.
Smith is close to the top hooker in the NRL, and even one year of the star rake would have been a boon for the Tigers, but in Utoikamanu they've got close to the best young forward in the competition.
"Even if it's [a swap] for one of the best players in the league at the moment, he's [Utoikamanu] still young and has a lot to learn and can get better and better. It was an obvious decision but the Tigers made the right decision," said Tigers skipper James Tamou.
"It's a massive wrap, he's still a kid too and as a front rower he's got a lot of maturing to do. After the year he had he's going to get better but fingers crossed he'll stay at the club for a long time."
For all the criticism the Tigers wear over their recruitment and retention, landing Utoikamanu from Parramatta last season proved to be a masterstroke.
The 21-year old grew in leaps and bounds as the season went on, justifying the wraps he earned as a junior and landing a berth in the Blues Origin camp for Game III.
He ended the season as the club's best middle, a title he will likely hold for years to come as he continues to improve.
After 10 years outside the finals it's natural for fans to look for a quick fix, but it's rare that one big signing changes a club's fortunes – most of the time you need to hit a few singles before belting a six out of the ground.
In Utoikamanu, Adam Doueihi and Daine Laurie in recent years, the Tigers have built a very solid foundation for the future. And landing established stars Isaiah Papali'i and Api Koroisau for 2023 is proof the club is not as far off the pace as their finish to this season may have indicated.
Tamou knows first hand the impact Koroisau, a former teammate at Penrith, can bring to Concord.
"For him to come here, and the way the game has gone and how many times a hooker touches a ball, you've got forwards who are fatiguing easier, you need a quick, decisive hooker like that to create," Tamou said.
"He's the best in the business after winning the grand final with the Panthers. He's a great signing for us and an indicator of where this club's heading."
While coach Michael Maguire still faces an uncertain future after he barely escaped the sack following the Tigers' meek finish to the year, where they were outscored 118-36 in their final three games, Tamou said the former premiership winner was working harmoniously with new football boss Tim Sheens.
In landing Koroisau and Papali'i, Sheens has made an immediate impact – but it's worth noting that both players have strong links to Maguire.
Koroisau was part of South Sydney's 2014 premiership side while Maguire handed Papali'i his Test debut for New Zealand in 2018.
"Madge has room to knuckle down and coach and especially with the young group we had, we all made an agreement we wouldn't experience another 12 months like that, so our improvement needs to be through the roof," Tamou said.
"It gives me confidence that the club is in a great place.
"I'm still in rehab at the moment. It was well documented at the end of the season that some coaches got tapped on. What I hear is that everything is going great.
"We've got a couple of new coaches coming in, Nathan Cayless from the Roosters and Ben Gardiner who's been with a couple of clubs and with the NSW Cup side and around Madge for a while.
"[Sheens brings] a lot of footy knowledge, you can't doubt that with Sheensy. Broosky [Luke Brooks] for example has come in firing and ready to train the house down. He's taken a step forward and Sheensy has a lot to do with that.
"This is Madge's team and he's not shy in letting anyone come in and help out where needs be. Sheensy has taken that burden off Madge so Madge can do his thing."