Ratings & Coomemts for players against Souths

[blacktip-reefy]

More like sh*t sandwich.

 

[Feej]

More like sh*t sandwich.

As long as there's, you know, sex and drugs, I can do without the rock and roll.

 

[Mako]

Peachy – 8 Simmo might play fullback but he is never going to replace Peach!
Simmons – 5 Ordinary positional play and would have got 3 except for the good attempt on the bomb and some slightly improved defence
Nutts – 6 Below par for him
Stevo – 6 Gone for a few weeks I think
Bailey – 6 The usual pushed pass but his D was good
Williams – 6 Tried hard while he was on, not enough game time
Vagana –6 Worked hard in defence and not given much opportunity in attack
Dykes –5 How the hell can a play maker make plays when he has been tackling his ass off???
Noddy –5 Ditto the Dykes but he is still playing awful when for someone with his ability and paycheck
Sully –1 Time for PL. Defence is awful and added nothing in attack
Hutch –5 Up and down but at least some effort
Covell –6 Goal kicking has gone to crap but thought generally he was ok.
Galloway –2 Was prepared to let him play despite the move to Tigers – back to PL and goodbye
Gallen –5 Ordinary in the position he was played and whats worse weakened us overall
LooLoo –4 Went ok but nothing special this week. Mind ya he did not seem to get a lot of game time Mellor –1 Should go to the bench as a forward or to PL
Mellars –4 Thought he went ok but don’t see him as a forward

In short Sully and Galloway have to go!

WTF is our coach doing? The players don't seem interested.

Ohhhh and the support staff rating - 0000000000000000000
What a second rate outfit - that whole jumper deal was a joke!!!

 

[NikkiShark]

Mellor MUST NOT PaLY ANOTHER GAME.

I agree. Vince played better...

Raper- 1- do the poll on him this week. I would vote fugging hopeless.

haha, I would vote fugging hopelessly useless use of the bench.

Peachey- 9 (best on the field for me)
Simmons- 7 (I missed the first 13 minutes, said to my mum that Simmo would get the first try.. and when the club that I was at, Finally decided to change the channel, he did)
Vagana- 5 (average, not his dazzling best)
Mellor- -10 (had another shocker- get rid of him NOW)
Covell- 4 (could have got two of the goals at least
Dykes- 6 (tried his best)
Kimmorley- 4 (what is wrong with him?!)
Stevens- 5 (FFS, not again)
Gallen- 7 (not a hooker, but did alright...)
Nutley- 6 (where did State of Origin go, what happened to that kind of performance?)
Williams- 8 (our best forward, needs more game time)
Leuluai- 3 (we have established that he's no starter)
Bailey- 6 (went okay-ish)

Maiava- 7 (was good, but don't start him next week if Stevo is going to be out, put Stosic on)
Mellars- 8 (sorry, it's my biased opinion)
Galloway- 1 (not sad to see him leave)
Sullivan- 2 (I'm one of the ones that actually like him, and sad to see him go, however, I though he had a pretty bad game)

Super coach Raper- 1
~needs better use of the bench
~Mellor needs to be dropped
~Sully and Galloway back to PL
~WTF is Stuey on? it needs to be confiscated

 

[Alan Shore]

3. Peachey
2. Williams
1. Vagana

I know everybody else went through the whole team, but I really couldn't be bothered.

 

[Craigshark]

Peachey - 9 - Brilliant..
Simmons - 6 - Nothing special, but he had a go..
Vagana - 6 - Did a few things which were ok.. Intercept was good..
Mellor - 2 - Shocking defence..
Covell - 6 - Tried hard..
Dykes - 5 - Missed a few tackles, didn't really step up in attack..
Kimmorley - 3 - Get him out of the side if he is injured.. He is trying really hard in defence, but his attack is woeful..
Stevens - 6 - Did some stupid things..
Gallen - 5 - Quiet.. Not a hooker..
Nutley - 6 - Tried hard as usual..
Williams - 6 - Don't think he had as good of game as he has had..
Leuluai - 7 - For the time he got, he was great.. Big hits in defence and some good strong runs..
Bailey - 5 - Brain explosions.. If we are in trouble, this guy pushes the pass all the time..

Maiava - 7 - Very effective..
Galloway - 2 - SOFT..
Mellars - 5 - Nothing special..
Sullivan - 4 - Tried hard.. Pretty shocking though..

 

[Big_Bad_Shark_Fan]

Peachey - 9 - My MOM
Simmons - 8 - thought the kid played great
Vagana - 6 - was ok
Mellor - 3 - made 2 costly errors, other than that was ok
Covell - 8 - cant belive any1 gave him a score of 4. had an absolute blinder. came up with two try savers, defused several tough bombs and tried his guts out all night
Dykes - 5 - him and mellor didnt go well together in defence
Kimmorley - 5 - better , but still not good
Stevens - 6 - yeah
Gallen - 7 - his usual level of guts
Nutley - 6 - same as above
Williams - 4 - poor
Leuluai - 7 - looked good
Bailey - 5 -

Maiava - 7 - tops
Galloway - 2 - cat
Mellars - 5 - average
Sullivan - 5 - brilliant and poor things

 

[roboshark]

Peachey - 9 - My MOM
Simmons - 8 - thought the kid played great
Vagana - 6 - was ok
Mellor - 3 - made 2 costly errors, other than that was ok
Covell - 8 - cant belive any1 gave him a score of 4. had an absolute blinder. came up with two try savers, defused several tough bombs and tried his guts out all night
Dykes - 5 - him and mellor didnt go well together in defence
Kimmorley - 5 - better , but still not good
Stevens - 6 - yeah
Gallen - 7 - his usual level of guts
Nutley - 6 - same as above
Williams - 4 - poor
Leuluai - 7 - looked good
Bailey - 5 -

Maiava - 7 - tops
Galloway - 2 - cat
Mellars - 5 - average
Sullivan - 5 - brilliant and poor things

:lol:

 

[Nulla_Fan]

As everyone has already mentioned playing Gallen at hooker is stupid, wheres the point? Through this positional change we lost an 80minute player who makes well over 100 metres a game, just a silly move by Raper

 

[Frenzy.]

As everyone has already mentioned playing Gallen at hooker is stupid, wheres the point? Through this positional change we lost an 80minute player who makes well over 100 metres a game, just a silly move by Raper

Exactly. Gallen never was able to play himself into the game. Only got 60 odd metres as opposed to his normal 166 metre average. Farged up the left defence as well as Gallen is normally doing the Bailey thing on that side.

Desperate move from a desperate coach with NFI.

 

[fatshark]

the 2 coaches, Staff & runners need a f*ckin rokket the size of a scudd missile & should have their jobs on the line ASAP.

These clowns are not performing!!!

What about the jersey???
What about the selections?
What about players getting on the field with injuries??


MY FUGGIN god IM furious with these pretenders!!!!!

Totally agree....that was just embarrasing

 

[millersnose]

Peachey 7
Simmons 6
Vagana 6
Mellor 6
Covell 5
Dykes 5
Kimmorley 6
Gallen 6
Bailey 7
Williams 6
Stevens 6
Leulai 5
Nutley 6
Maivia 6
Mellars 6
Sullivan 3
Galloway 5
Raper 1 Has learned


just on galloway

many people use the term "soft"

a 19 year old playing first grade and making normal front rowers meters cannot be described as "soft"

 

[blacktip-reefy]

haha
Kimmorley 6 peachey 7.

 

[millersnose]

yes peachey was better than kimmorley

the best shark on the field

but last night that isnt saying that much

and his performance wasnt excelent just better thn the others

 

[blacktip-reefy]

cmon. forget about comparing peachey, Noddy a 6?
He was 4 at best which means below average.
there is not one part of his game that is working.
by the way, I dont consider it all his fault. Got some goss on he Sharks game plan through the week & although it is clearly evident i]what it is, I thought there was some part missing or not being executed. There isnt. thats it!.

 

[millersnose]

i thought he went well in defence

hius passing game suffered because there were no runners

the good thing is his kicking game seems to be on the mend

peachey got intercept happy reefy when he should be tackling- and it must be admitted one of them probably cost the try at a critical point in the game

 

[blacktip-reefy]

yeah well im not complaining about his defense that consisted of 9-12 misses.
souths used Geddes & Logan & run at him all night. Good tactic.
Noddys misses lead to 2 tries.
peach went for the intercept was a bad call.
worse though was the inability of the 2 wingers to cover it & clean up.

 

[blacktip-reefy]

Also, his passing game has suffered because there are no runners. Agreed.
& I would be f*cked if i would run off his hospital passes either. he has he worst passing game in the comp at the moment because he has fallen back into his old ways. his comfort zone.
Reecey ran off him all night & got the ball milliseconds before he got smashed for waiting defense.
Good tactic by Reecey to stay in the top grade, keep running off the captain, but i wonder how long his health will hold out.

 

[millersnose]

half has to assume the runners are running at gaps

williams didnt...in fact only mellor and peachey were

 

[blacktip-reefy]

cmon Millers, his passing game is shyte. its so f*cken bad its not funny.
he needs to create the confidence & style for the players t orun where he wants them to.
He just cant play like shyte like he is & expect other players to bring him out of his form slump.
He needs to run a bit more & do a few things differently. His predictability is skilling him and us.
FFS!! when acommentator says watch this kimmorley will do a cross play & kick for the bottom right corner, before he does it, your in trouble.