Rd19: Parramatta v Warriors LIVE GAME DAY thread 27/7/19

[crocodile]

Yeah but that's still a penalty so what does it matter?

Not quite. Under the changed rule, several defenders can reef at the ball and arms. As long as all bar one let go at the moment the ball pops out it's all good. Then the ref has to, in real time, make sure that one of the other defender's fingernail isn't touching the ball carrier.

That's why I don't have a problem with Harris-Whatsisname getting penalised. He was all over the ball while Blair had hold of him but managed to release him just as the job had been done. It wouldn't really matter how secure the ball is with every man and his dog having a tug at it.

 

[strider]

Its a f**ked up f**kin shit f**kstick rule .... Anyone says otherwise has no f**kin idea

I will bet my right testicle the rule wont stay as is too far into the future

 

[I'm a loser baby...]

Its a f**ked up f**kin shit f**kstick rule .... Anyone says otherwise has no f**kin idea

I will bet my right testicle the rule wont stay as is too far into the future

Have you gone off Righty? Or did you get Lefty one too many times?

And yeah, it can't stay as is. Just unworkable.

 

[Noise]

That's why I don't have a problem with Harris-Whatsisname getting penalised. He was all over the ball while Blair had hold of him but managed to release him just as the job had been done.

No, the reason you didn't have a problem with it was because it went against the Warriors and benefited the Eels. The ref f**ked up and we got the reward.

 

[strider]

Have you gone off Righty? Or did you get Lefty one too many times?

And yeah, it can't stay as is. Just unworkable.

I'm putting righty up as collateral because i am that confident the shit rule can't stay .... otherwise i would have just offered up lefty

 

[Eelogical]

I'm putting righty up as collateral because i am that confident the shit rule can't stay .... otherwise i would have just offered up lefty

What a sack.

 

[crocodile]

No, the reason you didn't have a problem with it was because it went against the Warriors and benefited the Eels. The ref f**ked up and we got the reward.

I don't mind that it went against the Worriers. How can the ref see with any certainty that the ball came out at the precise moment the other defender didn't have a fingernail on the ball carrier. He didn't f*ck it up. The rule is f*cked and unworkable.

 

[Noise]

I don't mind that it went against the Worriers. How can the ref see with any certainty that the ball came out at the precise moment the other defender didn't have a fingernail on the ball carrier. He didn't f*ck it up. The rule is f*cked and unworkable.

Well the ref did get it wrong so yes he did f**k up. But I agree that sometimes it’s hard for the ref to gauge

 

[crocodile]

Well the ref did get it wrong so yes he did f**k up. But I agree that sometimes it’s hard for the ref to gauge

That's why it's f*cked and unworkable. A lottery.

 

[golfer]

That's why it's f*cked and unworkable. A lottery.

Agree but I think that at the time the ball was stripped Blairs chest but not his arms was in contact with Brown. How do they expect referees to adjudicate on that.

 

[I'm a loser baby...]

By using the superiority of their positronic brains.

 

[Gronk]

Not his go.

 

[strider]

Not his go.

They thought the nrl were still bowing down and govelling to them?

 

[Twizzle]

the guy who was next to me wont be happy, he was a Warriors fans and said it was just a copybook dominant tackle

 

[Gazzamatta]

Not his go.

Well I guess Luke just found out hes not as nice a bloke as Jake.

 

[golfer]

Well I guess Luke just found out hes not as nice a bloke as Jake.

THe tackle by Jake was as bad if not worse than Lukes. The NRL judiciary system is a joke with its inconsistancies,

 

[Suitman]

the guy who was next to me wont be happy, he was a Warriors fans and said it was just a copybook dominant tackle

I think he needs to keep up with the laws of the game.

 

[Gary Gutful]

An embarrassment. So confusing trying understand what the refs and judiciary are doing at the moment. Might as well have @hindy111 in charge.

 

[IFR33K]

Its a f**ked up f**kin shit f**kstick rule .... Anyone says otherwise has no f**kin idea

I will bet my right testicle the rule wont stay as is too far into the future

I guess it’s better than betting a lottery ticket...... unless you loose

 

[Gary Gutful]

An embarrassment. So confusing trying understand what the refs and judiciary are doing at the moment. Might as well have @hindy111 in charge.

or @Eelogical