Ref Simpkins escapes axe

[Tonearm Terrorwrist]

"Clearly he's made an error, but thankfully that error didn't play any part in the outcome of the game,"

what about the sending off of hodges which after that willie tonga found himself in an orgasmic state and ripped apart our right side? might of been years ago but that did affect the outcome of the game and hodges wasn't even looked at on the monday and simpkins didn't get dropped. these wankers are full of sh*t simpkins should of been dropped years ago

 

[petetheileet]

Clark Reffing any saints game

 

[Eels Dude]

It may not have had an outcome on the match, but that was only because the incident was a minute from full time. So this raises the question as to would McKinnon have been sent off if it happened in the 50th minute? If not, then where's the consistency... If so then would Simpkins be dropped for it having an impact on the game?

 

[dragonfire]

I watched the first half of hte game to see how much he blundered. Thought he made some bad mistakes but at the same time i think the touchies were the ones who really hurt the Tigers missing the forward passes and knock into touch when they are right there. But yeh he isnt getting dropped because there isnt anyone there to step up and fill the hole

 

[Manu Vatuvei]

2003 - Shayne Hayne (Cronulla vs. Eels)

tbh, that was just poor discipline by a lunatic Sharks side who were lucky they weren't all sent off