Report Card

[madunit]

Share your ratings/record card scores for the Tigers players at the midway point of the season:

All players marked out of 10

Collis 6.5
Farah 7
Flanagan 7
Fulton 6
Galea 5
Galloway 7.5
Gibbs 7
Halatau 6.5
Hanbury 4
Harrison 6
Head 8
Heighington 9.5
Hodgson 9
Lawrence 7.5
Lawrie 6
Marshall 6.5
McDonnell 6
Metuisela 4
Moltzen 5.5
Morris 6
Payne 6
Payten 7.5
Ryan 7.5
Tagive 7
Tandy 4.5
Te'o 6.5
Trimarchi 4.5
Tuiaki 6

 

[Champ]

Collis 6.5
Farah 7.5
Flanagan 7
Fulton 6.5
Galea 5.5
Galloway 8.5
Gibbs 7.5
Halatau 6
Hanbury 4
Harrison 6
Head 7.5
Heighington 9.5
Hodgson 9
Lawrence 7
Lawrie 7
Marshall 6.5
McDonnell 6
Metuisela 5
Moltzen 5.5
Morris 6.5
Payne 5.5
Payten 7.5
Ryan 7
Tagive 5.5
Tandy 4.5
Te'o 5.5
Trimarchi 4.5
Tuiaki 6

 

[TV Ted Ellery]

Collis 6
Farah 6
Flanagan 3 (Hasn't been used enough)
Fulton 5
Galea 4
Galloway 6.5
Gibbs 6
Halatau 6.5
Hanbury 2
Harrison 4
Head 7
Heighington 8.5
Hodgson 8
Lawrence 5.5
Lawrie 2 (one game)
Marshall 4.5
McDonnell 5.5
Metuisela 2
Moltzen 4
Morris 6
Payne 3.1
Payten 5 (injured)
Ryan 5.5
Tagive 3
Tandy 2
Te'o 6.5
Trimarchi 2
Tuiaki 5

 

[aids]

Collis Good
Farah Good
Flanagan OK
Fulton OK
Galea OK
Galloway Good
Gibbs Good
Halatau Great
Hanbury OK
Harrison Poor
Head Good
Heighington Great
Hodgson Great
Lawrence OK
Lawrie NA
Marshall Poor
McDonnell Poor
Metuisela NA
Moltzen OK
Morris OK
Payne sh*t
Payten OK
Ryan Good
Tagive Poor
Tandy NA
Te'o Poor
Trimarchi NA
Tuiaki Poor

 

[joel caine number 1 fan]

i thought Halatau been our 2nd best this year

i dont think ive seen a bad game from him

 

[Vicious]

i thought Halatau been our 2nd best this year

i dont think ive seen a bad game from him

Are you serious ??? What has he done that`s benefited the team ???
He`s a hooker and only a hooker, problem being he can`t be a hooker with us while we have Robbie Farah.

 

[aids]

Halatau, Heino and Hodgo have been out best three by far this year.

 

[Vicious]

Halatau, Heino and Hodgo have been out best three by far this year.

I haven`t seen Halatau do anything out of the ordinary that`s helped towards us winning a game, tell me what has he done that`s been impressive ???

 

[TV Ted Ellery]

I haven`t seen Halatau do anything out of the ordinary that`s helped towards us winning a game, tell me what has he done that`s been impressive ???

His best performance of the year was in the centres v the Dogs.

 

[aids]

he helps by making good meters running in a straight linewith the occasional bust.
is a true utility, as he can play backrow, center and hooker and his defense is solid.

i was worried about his form coming off the past 2 years, but he is currently playing great football.



Gibbs is a massive improvment as well.

 

[Vicious]

he helps by making good meters running in a straight linewith the occasional bust.
is a true utility, as he can play backrow, center and hooker and his defense is solid.

i was worried about his form coming off the past 2 years, but he is currently playing great football.



Gibbs is a massive improvment as well.

The only time that I see Halatau contribute is when he runs from dummy half. Very good dummy half runner, but doesn`t do much else. He hasn`t done much wrong, but hasn`t done much full stop, he certainly doesn`t worry the opposition except for when he scoots out of dummy half and i`m still dumbfounded as to how anyone can rank him in our best 3 players this season.
I`m not even sure we`ve had 3 good players, perhaps Heighington, Galloway and Hodgson, that`d be about it !

 

[Dave Q]

Heighington has been brilliant.

Source: weeklytimes.com.au

 

[brook]

Dene was playing his best football for us this year when he was at centre (which suprised the hell out of me to be honest). His defence during that period was fantastic and better than any of our backs (aside from possibly hodgo) has offered since.

When we get a few forwards back he should be moved back there and Lawrence shifted to the wing where his lousy defence can do less damage.

 

[magpie_man]

Collis C
Farah B+
Flanagan C-
Fulton C
Galea D-
Galloway C+
Gibbs B-
Halatau B
Hanbury D-
Harrison D-
Head B-
Heighington A
Hodgson A-
Lawrence C-
Lawrie C
Marshall D
McDonnell D+
Metuisela D-
Moltzen D
Morris C-
Payne E
Payten C+
Ryan C
Tagive D
Tandy D-
Te'o D
Trimarchi D-
Tuiaki D-

 

[hybrid_tiger]

5 = Average
Under 5 = Below average
Over 5 = Above average

Not rating players who have only played one or two games.

Collis 5.5
Farah 6
Flanagan 6.5
Fulton 6
Galea 5
Galloway 7.5
Gibbs 6
Halatau 6.5
Hanbury n.a
Harrison 5
Head 7.5
Heighington 8.5
Hodgson 9
Lawrence 5
Lawrie n.a
Marshall 4
McDonnell 3
Metuisela n.a
Moltzen 5.5
Morris 3
Payne 1 (for turning up)
Payten 6.5
Ryan 6.5
Tagive 5.5
Tandy n.a
Te'o 4
Trimarchi n.a
Tuiaki 4.5

 

[Callan Pk]

Team as a whole: C-