What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

RL independence day arrives - NRL Independent Commission announced for November 1

Status
Not open for further replies.

Razor

Coach
Messages
10,077
So News and the ARL are going to vote, and if the ARL doesn't vote the way News wants it to they'll throw their toys out of the cot and shut the whole thing down?

Was thinking exactly the same thing this morning. The Fairfax press questioned the commission earlier this year concerned it would be all News Ltd approved commissioners, and not independent. N ow it looks like that's the way it's going to happen.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
69,869
just d1ck waving from all involved. Shame that for once they can't think of the good of the game before their own egos (on both sides, part of the reason for the SL war in the first place). No wonder we've had conflict of interest with ARL accepting money from Ch9, explains the lack of ARL discontent at the way the game has been screwed by them.
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
http://www.couriermail.com.au/sport...ndent-commission/story-e6frep5x-1226032322465

Former ARL boss will not be part of Independent Commission

Phil Rothfield Sports Editor-at-large
From: The Daily Telegraph
April 01, 2011 11:00PM

FORMER ARL supremo John Quayle is officially out of the running for the NRL's new Independent Commission after a shortlist was finalised yesterday that included several women but no former officials.

A meeting at recruitment firm Spencer Stuart reduced the final list to about 14 names - and Quayle wasn't one of them despite a desperate push from the ARL in earlier negotiations.

The identity of those on the list is a closely guarded secret after News Limited's Peter Macourt, the ARL's John Chalk, the QRL's Terry Mackenroth and Rabbitohs boss Nick Pappas agreed to confidentiality agreements in front of lawyers at yesterday's meeting.

"It was a very good meeting, very constructive, very positive and we're working towards the right outcome," said Macourt, News Limited's chief operating officer.

"There was absolute agreement among the four we would not discuss names of people on the list.

"Spencer Stuart will now talk to the people on the shortlist and see how enthusiastic they are to join the commission.

"I'm confident we'll get the right balance of skills. Board balance is important to us. Not just with females. We need people from different backgrounds with a mixture of skills and ideas."

A highly-placed source told The Daily Telegraph last night: "There is a reasonable number of females on the list."

One is believed to be Westpac boss Gail Kelly, but Harvey Norman boss Katie Page has missed out because of her previous role on the NRL board.

Brisbane IT guru John Grant is certain to be on the list and is tipped to be the inaugural chairman.

Grant, 60, played centre and wing for Brisbane Souths and was a member of Australia's 1972 World Cup squad.

He played alongside supercoach Wayne Bennett at representative level and has spent the past 28 years honing his business acumen with the IT company Data3 in Brisbane.

Few other details are known about the identity of other candidates.

Quayle's omission will upset ARL stalwarts who have been vigorously pushing his claims.

The former ARL boss, who quit his post after the Super League war was settled, fell victim to News Ltd's strong opinion that appointing officials who left the game more than a decade ago would be a backward step.

After originally announcing an April 30 exit date, News Limited is reluctant to confirm if the deadline can be met because of delays in setting up yesterday's meeting.

A source said it was more likely the commission would be formed in late May or early June and certainly up and running before the finals.
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-league/...ed-by-end-of-month-pappas-20110401-1crk9.html

Commissioners to be named by end of month: Pappas
Brad Walter
April 2, 2011

RUGBY LEAGUE'S new independent commission remains on track to be finalised by the end of the month, despite delays yesterday in selecting the inaugural commissioners.

A three-hour meeting between News Ltd chief operating officer Peter Macourt, ARL chairman John Chalk, QRL director Terry Mackenroth and South Sydney chairman Nicholas Pappas narrowed down the number of candidates but did not settle on the final eight names.

However, Pappas, who represents the NRL clubs on the four-man subcommittee charged with making the most important appointments since the end of the Super League war in 1997, said progress had been made and he expected the handover of power to coincide with the April 30 deadline imposed by News Ltd in February.

''It was a positive meeting, the members of the subcommittee are working well together, and there was good debate about some of the candidates,'' he said. ''But there is still some work to do before we get down to the final list of names.''

The four were each required to sign confidentiality agreements at the start of the meeting by international consultancy firm Spencer Stuart, which was hired in December to facilitate the appointment of the eight commissioners.

It has been a drawn-out process, with Spencer Stuart's head of board services and chief executive practices, John Mumm, an Australian Rugby Union director, producing an initial shortlist of 168 candidates.

Since then the members of the subcommittee have been able to individually remove names from the list - although the Herald understands that neither Pappas nor Chalk removed anyone.

It is believed about 30 candidates remained before yesterday's meeting but there were concerns that they might not fill each of the job descriptions for the eight commissioners.

''It is important not just that we get the right individuals but also the right complexion of the board,'' Pappas said. ''We have to make sure that there is a balance in the skills sets and the complexion of the board.''

Among those believed to be under consideration for positions on the independent commission are former Billabong chairman Garry Pemberton, former TAB boss Warren Wilson, former federal police commissioner Mick Keelty, media buyer Barry O'Brien, IT guru John Grant - a former international forward - and former ARL boss John Quayle.

The four members of the subcommittee must form a consensus on each candidate before they are invited. The list of eight names will then be forwarded to the ARL board and News Ltd for approval, in what could be the final act of each organisation before departing the game.

The ARL will remain in name only, with the new body to be known as the ARL Commission.

The NSWRL and QRL will administer the game in their states and have charge of their State of Origin teams, but the commission will oversee the running of the code from grassroots to the elite level, and decide big issues such as funding, expansion and broadcast rights.
 

Lockyer4President!

First Grade
Messages
7,975
A source said it was more likely the commission would be formed in late May or early June and certainly up and running before the finals.
I’m so very glad that they’ve gone about this slow and steady and haven’t rushed anything but goddamn I’m getting impatient.
 

adamkungl

Immortal
Messages
42,971
Is anyone else getting sick of the constant going on about Katie Page? Yes, she can't be on the commission, yes she's a successful female. Yawwwn. You'd think she was Dally Messenger, Donald Trump, and Bill Gates all rolled into one, except female.
 

CC_Roosters

First Grade
Messages
5,221
I’m so very glad that they’ve gone about this slow and steady and haven’t rushed anything but goddamn I’m getting impatient.

Same here, its the future of the game and deserves to be sorted through thoroughly

The telegraph said Gail kelly of westpac is in contention. aren't westpac a sponsor of the afl, if so how does that work? Personally i don't care who is on it as long as they are fit for the job, but the guy Foster seems to be the ideal candidate, so it will be interesting to see if he has progressed to the final cut
 

bobmar28

Bench
Messages
4,304
Same here, its the future of the game and deserves to be sorted through thoroughly

The telegraph said Gail kelly of westpac is in contention. aren't westpac a sponsor of the afl, if so how does that work? Personally i don't care who is on it as long as they are fit for the job, but the guy Foster seems to be the ideal candidate, so it will be interesting to see if he has progressed to the final cut

Maybe not for long if Gail Kelly comes on board as a commissioner.
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-league/...tens-to-derail-commission-20110409-1d8tp.html

'Collusion' threatens to derail commission
Adrian Proszenko
April 10, 2011

THE formation of rugby league’s independent commission is in jeopardy following claims that News Ltd and the Queensland Rugby League have conspired to push through their preferred candidates.

The issue will top the agenda at the next meeting of the NRL clubs’ chairmen amid fears the clubs effectively will be blocked from having any say in the running of the game.

The Sun-Herald has been told that News and the QRL had secretly agreed to vote as a bloc to ensure that they continued to wield influence over rugby league under the new structure. News had pledged to withdraw from the game on April 30 but the fallout from the latest development could delay or even derail the formation of the code’s new governing body. News denied the claims it was colluding with the QRL.

Recruitment firm Spencer Stuart has been charged with finding the eight inaugural commissioners. A lengthy list of candidates is slowly being whittled down, with News chief operating officer Peter Macourt, ARL chairman John Chalk and QRL director Terry Mackenroth representing their respective interests and South Sydney chairman Nick Pappas representing the clubs. The quartet can make confidential objections to potential candidates directly to Spencer Stuart and the list of names is a closely guarded secret. However, a source close to negotiations claims News’s fingerprints are all over the process. There are fears that negotiations could collapse if the clubs band to oppose the move. ‘‘There is a suspicion that some names dropped off the list - and others stayed on - because some people were getting their heads together,'' the source said. ''It would appear that has happened.''

Asked if he was referring to collusion between News Ltd and the Queensland Rugby League, the source replied: ''Yes.''

He added: ''The game is about everybody but, at NRL level, it's mostly about the 16 clubs. It defies understanding that the 16 clubs should not have the principal say in who is running their game.

''If you were selling your business, you would never sell the company and then reserve the right to appoint the directors after you've gone.

''That's just lunacy.''

Several disgruntled club chairmen will raise the matter when they next convene, most probably before the end of the month. News had previously been a vocal critic of the ARL and QRL, claiming their intransigence was responsible for delays in forming the commission.

''Some people from the clubs will be sh*tty at the proposition that others are telling them who they can and can't have to run their game,'' the insider said.

News's director of corporate affairs, Greg Baxter, labelled the claims ''nonsense''.

''This whole process has been besieged by anonymous sources claiming to have all sorts of insights into this process,'' Baxter said. ''There has not been one assertion made [in the media] from one of these so-called anonymous experts that has come to pass.

''Lots of people have tried to influence the outcome of this process in an underhanded way and they have not been successful because the process is very well designed.

''When they've been called to account they haven't been able to deliver on the speculation.''

Baxter said News still hoped to pull out of the game in, or just after, April if the commissioners were ready to start work next month.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
69,869
The clubs should realise they don't own the game or need to run the game. At some point collusion has to happen otherwise how are they going to decide the final 8? The damage of not having an IC in place within the next couple of months is going to be far greater if we get stiffed on TV rights by missing the window of opportunity to be doing a deal alongside the AFL one.
 

Slackboy72

Coach
Messages
12,114
The clubs should realise they don't own the game or need to run the game. At some point collusion has to happen otherwise how are they going to decide the final 8? The damage of not having an IC in place within the next couple of months is going to be far greater if we get stiffed on TV rights by missing the window of opportunity to be doing a deal alongside the AFL one.

We're not talking about the game of rugby league.
We're talking about the premier competition which the clubs do have a right to say they own and run. The independent commission is all about stopping the leeches such as the QRL and NEWS from sucking the money and life out that competition.
 
Messages
14,139
No, it is about the whole game. The IC will have far reaching impacts on the game at all levels and having the clubs choose the members and set the agenda is probably worse than having News remain involved. The clubs are the ones who have an insatiable appetite for draining central funds from the NRL. The other RLs are just trying to administer the game at all levels.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
69,869
exactly! If clubs run the whole game, how much funding and good decisions do you think will be made for anything under NRL? The whole point of the IC is to have a strategic plan for all levels of teh game. otherwise we might as well just letthe clubs run the NRL and the ARL run the rest, which is exactly what we don't want.
 

Parra

Referee
Messages
24,900
. The independent commission is all about stopping the leeches such as the QRL and NEWS from sucking the money and life out that competition.


bullsh*t. The IC is all about News Ltd getting a better exit deal than they would get under the current agreement.

That others see the opportunity to get their snout into the trough is a side issue.
 

Brutus

Referee
Messages
26,354
Just heard an interesting call from Geoff Prenter on 2SM and he reckons the IC will not happen. He was dead serious about this.

The other parties believe News LTD's demands are too great and some of the people they want on the board are a definite no go.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
153,769
Just heard an interesting call from Geoff Prenter on 2SM and he reckons the IC will not happen.

The other parties believe News LTD's demands are too great and some of the people they want on the board are a definite no go.
I knew this would happen, News getting out of our game was too good to be true. f**king maggots.
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
Just heard an interesting call from Geoff Prenter on 2SM and he reckons the IC will not happen. He was dead serious about this.

The other parties believe News LTD's demands are too great and some of the people they want on the board are a definite no go.

who is he?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Top