Robbie Farah vs Cameron Smith - Better Hooker?

[joel caine number 1 fan]

He's a Top Hooker 2nd best in the NRL atm Behind Smith happy?

that is what most of us are trying too say but people are thinking that farah is so far behind its not funny

 

[DeeGan]

dont think smith has been that great at test level :?

he was ordinary in the SOO as well i thought

Wait ... :lol: ... no seriously ... :lol: ...

There are no bounds to the stupidity of some.

Whatever makes you sleep easy at night :roll:

 

[KniGhTs BaTTLeR]

nice player him and priddis were great a few years back

Farah has played one good season and a few solid ones and suddenly that makes him one of the two premier hookers? Who was the Blues captain and hooker this year? If this poll was fair dinkum then Bedsy would be in it.

Smith is class but look at the side he has, I would like to see how he fairs with a team we had last year, not that great IMO.

 

[philstorm]

Remember, Smith still played very well for Queensland in the years when we (the Storm) weren't so 'great'.

 

[KniGhTs BaTTLeR]

Remember, Smith still played very well for Queensland in the years when we (the Storm) weren't so 'great'.

And Buderus hasn't?

 

[perverse]

how smith got that MoM and rep player of the year over steve price still astounds me. totally undeserving.

 

[_Johnsy]

smith

 

[Mr Saab]

dont think smith has been that great at test level :?

he was ordinary in the SOO as well i thought

Whatever cred you had just went that way ------------------------------------------------>

 

[DeeGan]

Farah has played one good season and a few solid ones and suddenly that makes him one of the two premier hookers? Who was the Blues captain and hooker this year? If this poll was fair dinkum then Bedsy would be in it.

Smith is class but look at the side he has, I would like to see how he fairs with a team we had last year, not that great IMO.

Danny Buderus's representative career is over - Robbie Farrah and the selectors will see to it.

As a rugby league fan first, parocial Queenslander second, I hope he announces his retirement rather than see one of the greatest hookers of all-time be forced in to representative retirement by the the selection panel.

If we are going to be "fair dinkum", the most ardent Newcastle Knights supporter will acknowledge that Buderus is not the player he once was. Back-to-back seasons where he has been outclassed by Cameron Smith at Origin level where he has failed in making the impact he once did.

NSW selectors will usher in a "new breed" in 2008 and Farrah will be one of the first players selected barring injury and a dramatic loss of form.

 

[joel caine number 1 fan]

Danny Buderus's representative career is over - Robbie Farrah and the selectors will see to it.

As a rugby league fan first, parocial Queenslander second, I hope he announces his retirement rather than see one of the greatest hookers of all-time be forced in to representative retirement by the the selection panel.

If we are going to be "fair dinkum", the most ardent Newcastle Knights supporter will acknowledge that Buderus is not the player he once was. Back-to-back seasons where he has been outclassed by Cameron Smith at Origin level where he has failed in making the impact he once did.

NSW selectors will usher in a "new breed" in 2008 and Farrah will be one of the first players selected barring injury and a dramatic loss of form.

a tiger get selected in origin NA wont happen :crazy:

 

[Abz]

Do the names Benny Elias, Scott Prince of Brett Hodgson ring a bell to you?

Nonetheless, Cameron Smith quite clearly takes the cake here but there's no doubt Robbie Farah gave him a run for his money.