Round 14 Vs Sharks

[ACTPanthers]

Nobody is using May as a scapegoat... they're discussing poor performances. There is a massive difference.

 

[Kilkenny]

Nobody is using May as a scapegoat... they're discussing poor performances. There is a massive difference.

He’s certainly carried the brunt of criticism on here, rightly or wrongly.

 

[franklin2323]

Again, your attributing blame when the fact is there were at least half a dozen regulars who didn’t perform any where near what they should have done.

Where did I say we lost due to May?

Part of the reason we lost was playing a 7 that has never played the position

 

[franklin2323]

Nobody is using May as a scapegoat... they're discussing poor performances. There is a massive difference.

Who else's poor performance has been discussed?

 

[franklin2323]

The whole narrative around our GF loss or two most recent losses is to lay the blame around one or two individuals.

We lost the GF, primarily because the Storm were the better team.

Tyrone May has been a convenient scapegoat for our last two losses but it shouldn’t mask the fact we haven’t been good enough.

At the end of the day we have a really tough game on Friday night, without Kikau, who hasn’t been in the best of form anyway.

It shapes up as a really interesting contest and it will be very interesting to see how we perform.

We choked in GF simple as that

 

[Kilkenny]

We choked in GF simple as that

Maybe we didn’t play as well as we would have hoped, they didn’t allow us to, that up is what the Storm do better than any other team. Be no different this season, if we get that far.

 

[franklin2323]

He has no physical attributes to speak of. Runs slow and hits the defence softly when running even playing off the bench.

Which happens after an ACL injury and bulking up. Not sure a pre season fixes it.

As he gets older he is growing into more of a Terrell May ( prop) body shape and less like Taylan.

Is there a person here that thinks he starts anywhere but backrow in NSW Cup this week? That is where his future lies

 

[WestyLife]

Who else's poor performance has been discussed?

May
Kikau
Burton
Staines
Ivan
Momirovski

 

[WestyLife]

Which happens after an ACL injury and bulking up. Not sure a pre season fixes it.

As he gets older he is growing into more of a Terrell May ( prop) body shape and less like Taylan.

Is there a person here that thinks he starts anywhere but backrow in NSW Cup this week? That is where his future lies

No I think his days in the backs/halves are done which has really been my point this whole time.

 

[Kilkenny]

May
Kikau
Burton
Staines
Ivan
Momirovski

Add Crichton, Edwards and Sorensen into the mix they’ve all been getting there fair share.

 

[WestyLife]

Add Crichton, Edwards and Sorensen into the mix they’ve all been getting there fair share.

It's a pretty comprehensive list.

 

[DinkyDi]

We choked in GF simple as that

We were overawed, and inexperienced. It is that simple.

 

[Kilkenny]

We were overawed, and inexperienced. It is that simple.

And sadly beaten by the better side on the night.

 

[franklin2323]

May
Kikau
Burton
Staines
Ivan
Momirovski

No one is allowed to say a bad word about Burton on here.

No one agrees with me about Staines so it doesn't count.

We have mentioned Ivan I don't think others have

 

[franklin2323]

No I think his days in the backs/halves are done which has really been my point this whole time.

So how is it fair to blame him for the poor attack when we all agree he is out of position

 

[WestyLife]

So how is it fair to blame him for the poor attack when we all agree he is out of position

Because he played there. Both he and the club agreed to it. Poor decision or not he didn't do the job he was suppose to as our super utility back up guy.

No one is allowed to say a bad word about Burton on here.

No one agrees with me about Staines so it doesn't count.

We have mentioned Ivan I don't think others have

Can't they? His kicking game was horrible in the first half Vs Sharks.

The Staines part is untrue. I offered reason why Staines would keep the position IF we were to agree he has underperformed just like you did with May. Also disagreement doesn't mean it hasn't been discussed, you're just judging Staines by a different metric to me which is fine I just don't agree with it for reasons which I think are fair and well reasoned.

 

[Smug Panther]

We choked in GF simple as that

Nope we were on a slide from at least the Broncos game late in the season

 

[The_Frog]

And sadly beaten by the better side on the night.

As always, they were workmanlike. Beatable for sure, we just couldn't do it. Far too many mistakes in the first half.

 

[Fangs]

Be honest here, does any one have an inkling why May has not being named in the top side, yes I know he is on the reverses, or why he hasn't been named in the cup side?

He will be 18th man.

 

[DinkyDi]

He will be 18th man.

I hope not.