What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Round 19 vs Canberra

Messages
4,420
Happy with the continued inclusion of Feagai are we ??????
Obv has talent but is way down on form and confidence at present
I AM NOT HAPPY. He is also way down on game awareness, specially with his reading in defense.. abysmal. Every time he leaves his wing to attempt a hit he opens a huge hole for the opposition centre or winger to stroll into, usually leading to points we cant afford. I wince when I see it, am dumbfounded why our useless selectors have not acted on this major flaw in his game and booted him.
 
Last edited:
Messages
4,420
I'm a little more hopeful now. Sloane has been a weak point all season so it's time to try someone else, and Turner is at least a bigger body.
Without Sloans silky attacking skills, we'd have been cellar dwellars far sooner. Turner is not first grade material, may be bigger than Sloan but has nowhere near his skillset. There are parts of Sloans game where he is still a work in progress, but dumping him back to Ressies wont help that progress..
 
Last edited:
Messages
4,420
Ben Murdoch-Masila
What about the continued selection of this 118K log. He may have been a decent edgie once, when he played for Tonga, these days he hides in and clogs our back line. At best he should be a bench prop. Read his abysmal 15 game season stats, average RM 60, 2 LB, 5 OL PCM mediocre. Affective defense is acceptable but lazy, making 200 less tackles than Jack de Belin.. and both play the same minutes.
 

justadragon

Bench
Messages
4,093
I AM NOT HAPPY. He is also way down on game awareness, specially with his reading in defense.. abysmal. Every time he leaves his wing to attempt a hit he opens a huge hole for the opposition centre or winger to stroll into, usually leading to points we cant afford. I wince when I see it, am dumbfounded why our useless selectors have not acted on this major flaw in his game and booted him.
He may have got us dumbfounded but surely its up to the coaches to rectify this, its been happening for weeks.
 

Jeremy Dragon

Juniors
Messages
1,327
I have gone off him, seems to be following the same selection blueprint as Griffin. What has us hamstrung is our poor recruitments have to be picked as all are in our Top 30 while more talented players have missed the cut so are not eligible.
Dan Russell is not in our top 30
 

Slippery Morris

First Grade
Messages
7,885
In all fairness to Carr he does not really have many options. When was the last time we heard Saints sign anyone? What is happening there is anybody's guess. The reserve grade side is not in the top 8 and firing all cylinders. They had a great win on the weekend against the Jets but what about all the other weeks. Plus reserve grade has more chance of making the 8 than first grade so why weaken reserve grade especially now that they are hitting some sort of form.
 
Messages
4,420
Well let’s hope he’s a cross between Reece Walsh and James Tedesco
You jest. Not in the same street.. reason he has been stuck in Ressies since he arrived. Has been swapping between f/b and halves, as not been able to nail down either position.
 
Last edited:
Messages
4,420
Dan Russell is not in our top 30
He must be, a late inclusion, perhaps for Kerr or did Ryan Couchman take his place. Have they dumped Bird for Russell? One a poor defender the other a good'n. Said as much after watching him in the pre season. We sure as hell need to add some more umph to our middle defense, to help out Jack, Block and Liddle.
 
Last edited:
Messages
4,420
He may have got us dumbfounded but surely its up to the coaches to rectify this, its been happening for weeks.
Who exactly of our two assistants is defense coach. Is his job to rectify the problem, if he cant then show him the door. This disease is in both grades too. We fans have the answer, sack him, but unfortunately we dont pick the players.
 

R&WTILLIDIE

First Grade
Messages
5,696
Not that we had a snowballs chance in hell of winning anyway, but the ref is going to Peter Gough so we will get hammered with penalties and restarts - just to add insult to injury.
In my opinion, If we can limit our errors and penalties in the first 10 minutes of the game, and actually show some passion, then we should only lose by 40 instead of 50. But that’s just my opinion
 

Latest posts

Top