Round 5 vs Bulldogs

[Iamback]

My understanding of the rule is that the challenge had to be within 10 seconds of the call/stoppage. That bit of play went on for about a minute. Get rid of the Capt/Challenge please.

The amount of wrong calls shows it is needed. Just need the refs to know the rules

 

[WestyLife]

It's worse when the ref allows the challenge after 30 or 40 seconds which happened once already this year.

 

[The_Frog]

Annesley said cook should’ve been sin binned for the deliberate holding down penalty in the second half when they held on just so the challenge the call of no knock on by Penrith just before that, he also said the challenge shouldn’t have been allowed as it was a non call, you can challenge a knock on call as there is a stoppage but not a non call, giving away a penalty like south’s did to force a stoppage will now just be a sin binning like it was for the broncos. You’d think between the on field ref and the bunker they could’ve got this right in our game.

This was a really strange one. Regardless of whether it was a knock on or not, we ended up with the ball, yet when they challenged the knock on call they got the ball. It should have been 6 tackle set vs 7 tackle set, that's all.

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

Gus playing mind games again, "Kikau wanted out of Penrith" so he signed him. Nonsense I say.

Meaning Gus didn't chase him. LOL. Contrast that with what Billy said in the jersey presentation, and I know whom I believe.

Billy was offered a HUGE payday by the dogs, which Penrith couldn't match, without stuffing their cap. Billy supports his wider family in fiji plus his growing family here in Australia. In this circumstances he was going to take the money and run. But for Kiks I think it was a challenging decision.

As I said earlier the Dogs have spent their money in all the wrong places, flashy players like kiks, without building a decent foundation.

The dogs will come out all guns blazing on Sunday night, and if we're not on our game we will get done.

 

[The_Frog]

The dogs will come out all guns blazing on Sunday night,

Trouble is they don't seem to have that many. Just respect them and don't expect an easy game and we'll be right.

 

[Blues Riff]

The Kennel is hilarious ATM. Last year when I had a look, they were discussing which other Panthers they'd take with their unlimited funds.
Now it's like a bunch of amateur mechanics trying to fit expensive parts onto a broken down Datsun 120Y.

 

[Iamback]

Trouble is they don't seem to have that many. Just respect them and don't expect an easy game and we'll be right.

They don't have any. when they fire Barrett the side we offer something but atm they have nothing

 

[soc123_au]

The Kennel is hilarious ATM. Last year when I had a look, they were discussing which other Panthers they'd take with their unlimited funds.
Now it's like a bunch of amateur mechanics trying to fit expensive parts onto a broken down Datsun 120Y.

There is some comedy gold on there. Some of them get it and I feel for those ones, but some of them are dead set mouth breathers.

 

[Smug Panther]

Team is out with no real surprises. Salmon will hopefully drop off the bench for either C Smith or Hopgood. These are the perfect games to see what the fringe forwards have

 

[WestyLife]

Dogs recalled Flanagan. Talk about throw a guy to the wolves... well Panthers but still.

 

[Thirsty Panther]

Same squad we used against Souths.

Dylan EDWARDS
2. Charlie STAINES
3. Izack TAGO
4. Stephen CRICHTON
5. Taylan MAY
6. Jarome LUAI
7. Nathan CLEARY (c)
8. Matt EISENHUTH
9. Apisai KOROISAU
10. James FISHER-HARRIS
11. Viliame KIKAU
12. Liam MARTIN
13. Isaah YEO (c)

14. Mitch KENNY
15. Scott SORENSEN
16. Spencer LENIU
17. Jaeman SALMON

18. Robert JENNINGS
19. Chris SMITH
20. J'maine HOPGOOD
21. Lindsay SMITH
22. Soni LUKE
23. Christian CRICHTON
24. Sean O'SULLIVAN

 

[Smug Panther]

Dogs recalled Flanagan. Talk about throw a guy to the wolves... well Panthers but still.

Right call. Now stick with him for the year

 

[WestyLife]

Right call. Now stick with him for the year

Would be the right call if they did that but how likely so you think it is? More likely an excuse to never pick him again.

 

[Iamback]

Team is out with no real surprises. Salmon will hopefully drop off the bench for either C Smith or Hopgood. These are the perfect games to see what the fringe forwards have

if anyone drops off it will be Kenny. He only handles the middle. I was hoping to see him fill in other positions but is just a waste

 

[Iamback]

Would be the right call if they did that but how likely so you think it is? More likely an excuse to never pick him again.

As a former assistant coach tweeted today.

Barrett is a Gus puppet. Gus wants to see him off so he needs to play

 

[Smug Panther]

As a former assistant coach tweeted today.

Barrett is a Gus puppet. Gus wants to see him off so he needs to play

Moylan and Carty pulling shit out of our arses had us 4th. I love the narrative that Hook can coach, will never not be funny

 

[Iamback]

Moylan and Carty pulling shit out of our arses had us 4th. I love the narrative that Hook can coach, will never not be funny

Cleary in 2015 then..

Whatever you want to use. Barrett after finishing 16th

Will be 1 win 5 losses to start 2022..Should be out the door on previous Gus form

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

The Kennel is hilarious ATM. Last year when I had a look, they were discussing which other Panthers they'd take with their unlimited funds.
Now it's like a bunch of amateur mechanics trying to fit expensive parts onto a broken down Datsun 120Y.

It's fascinating isn't it. Attempting to sew a silk purse on a sows ear.

 

[Smug Panther]

Cleary in 2015 then..

Whatever you want to use. Barrett after finishing 16th

Will be 1 win 5 losses to start 2022..Should be out the door on previous Gus form

Maybe this means Flanno has the gig. Will improve them instantly if true

 

[Iamback]

Maybe this means Flanno has the gig. Will improve them instantly if true

Reports are they are $1m or so over the cap for next season. So will have a weaker roster but there is still enough garbage teams to push into the 8