murphyscreek for the Dragons....an early hit-up to settle the nerves
749 words between the stars
*****************************************************************
Just A Word
Best get these things over and done with. N****r. That word with the stars in it rhymes with bigger. Im now hoping the sky wont fall in before youve finished reading this.
I live near, and work in, the Queensland rural city of Toowoomba. Also known as The Garden City. A beautiful and magnificent rural centre servicing the rich pastoral and crop producing area known as the Darling Downs. A city steeped in history. A city with some of the finest schools in the Country and a first rate University. A city that has given us a splendid annual event in its Carnival Of Flowers.
A city that for nine years was divided over the public display of one word. That word was N****r.
Before expanding on this it would be prudent to note that Toowoomba is a staunch Rugby League town. From the early days of Toowoombas 1924/25 Invincibles that took on all comers and prevailed, local expectations were set high. Their astonishing run included victories over Sydney premiers Souths, Ipswich, Brisbane, NSW, New Zealand and England. That team starred Herb Steinohrt, Mick Madsen, and the legendary Duncan The Fox Thompson. There is a long list of great players who have come from The Garden City since the formation of the Toowoomba Rugby League (TRL) in 1919 up until the present day.
Prior to the emergence of the Invincibles, Toowoomba had already provided its first ever Kangaroo in 1921. Edward Stanley Brown.
Aka N****r Brown.
There are two possible explanations for his nickname given his Anglo-Saxon descent. The first is there was a N****r Brown colour available at the time in the Nugget brand of boot polish (later renamed Dark Tan). The other explanation for the nickname was the fact he had unusually fair coloured skin. Juxtaposed in a similar way that someone with red hair could be known as Blue.
Now lets fast forward to the late 1960s when the TRL decided, in its wisdom, to name the main grandstand of its premier rugby league venue Athletic Oval, the E.S. N****r Brown Stand. Now this writer might be showing some bias here, but I would have thought that in the enlightened sixties the TRL might have shown a bit more, well,
enlightenment. Surely there must have been some discussion about dropping the nickname? But in the context that Queensland Aboriginals did not gain the right to vote in Queensland State elections until 1965, perhaps one shouldnt be so surprised. Lets fast forward again.
The year is now 1999 and the start of what would become a fierce and bitter debate when local Aboriginal activist, Stephen Hagan, complained to the TRL about the signage and requested the word N****r be removed. His point then, and subsequently, was the word is so offensive that its use should not be condoned for public display regardless of the context (the censor function on this site would appear to agree, as did E.S. Browns family). The TRL, through its Chairman John McDonald, politely refused.
In growing disbelief Mr Hagan took the matter through our legal system right up to the High Court which deemed the word not to be in convention of the Racial Discrimination Act. Mr Hagan advanced the case to the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination and consequently UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan himself deemed the sign offensive and recommended it be taken down. The TRL, through its Chairman John McDonald, politely refused.
Even when the stand was eventually demolished the TRL announced they would put a brass plaque on the replacement structure, dedicated to E.S. N****r Brown. It was only the direct intervention of Queenslands Minister of Sport that prevented this.
So nine years later Stephen Hagan, with the help of Judy Spence, had prevailed. In the process he was often vilified and maligned via the pages of the local paper. He reports receiving hate mail and abusive phone calls, some purporting to come from a local chapter of the Klu Klux Klan. Threats that Mr Hagan and the police took seriously and eventually Mr Hagan sold his house and relocated his family as a direct result of the intimidation.
A few short weeks ago the culmination of NAIDOC Week saw Timana Tahu receive an award for speaking out against racism in sport. I applaud Timana and Stephen Hagan, but despair of a society where such acts of self-sacrifice are still necessary.
***************************************************************