Round 8 vs Sharks

[meek]

Or maybe you should have watched Cartwright's three before that, or the great bulk of last season. He wasn't even bad, just over hit two kicks and missed Blake outside him.

he wasnt bad , seriously he was shocking , forced passes at rediculous times etc etc
here we go again
you cant seriously believe hes ready for first grade
he will be a great firstgader but seriously you blokes see a couple of decentgames and all of a sudden he should be playing for Aust ( figuratively speaking)
rcg is imo more ready for firsts than carty
cartwright will ultimately be better just not ready yet
btw did watch last season and still had the same opinion
lucky blokes like you dont promote our juniors or we would be killing a lot of promising careers.

 

[chrisD]

He was the under 20s player of the competition and lead us to the premiership with makeshift halves. "A couple of decent games", f**k you're such a clueless spastic.

 

[maple_69]

Pretty hard to argue with that. He was rated the best junior in the game, above Brooks et al. From what I've seen when he is dialled in he could shred a NRL quality team. He needs to get more consistency though. His grand final performance was aweful in many ways. He needs to be in NSW Cup at this stage I think. 3/4 games towards the end of origin then back before a full season to have a crack at the bench next year.

 

[meek]

He was the under 20s player of the competition and lead us to the premiership with makeshift halves. "A couple of decent games", f**k you're

Deleted my comment
your not worth pming for a smack in the gob
Go f yourself

 

[meek]

Dont want to get banned so deleted

 

[chrisD]

Hey
clueless spastic am I
how old are you
pm me
Id like to see if you are a smart mouth in person tool

Or you could just stop saying such clueless spastic shit.

 

[meek]

Ill pm you
smart mouth
need to see if you are as smartarse in real life

how do I pm ?
cant pm you
see if you can pm me

 

[meek]

Cant seem to pm you
looks like you can hide behind the keyboard
if there is anyway for you to pm me please do
I think you smart mouth needs shuting

 

[franklin2323]

I wouldn't mind seeing Seg get a game in NSW Cup this week. A full game starting to see what he has.

 

[murraymob]

Boys gentle warning keep it down

By all means debate any issue do not get personal with insults

 

[meek]

I will not except some tool hiding behind a keyboard calling me a spastic for voicing an opinion on cartys readiness for first grade

Dont want to get banned so will quiten it down and make no further comment on the carty issue
btw anyone know how to pm

 

[umina panther]

I wouldn't mind seeing Seg get a game in NSW Cup this week. A full game starting to see what he has.

Not a bad idea

 

[chrisD]

I wouldn't mind seeing Seg get a game in NSW Cup this week. A full game starting to see what he has.

I'd like to see us get more minutes from our props by playing one at lock some of the time, give Plum the 20 or so Docker won't be on, then we can use Peachey at dummy to cover Segs for a rest.

I will not except some tool hiding behind a keyboard calling me a spastic for voicing an opinion on cartys readiness for first grade

Dont want to get banned so will quiten it down an make no further comment on the carty issue

I'm hiding behind a keyboard, get more worked up. Knock yourself suggesting Cartwright isn't ready, I've had that argument and can't be bothered by it much anymore, but saying a few decent games is all the reasoning for him to play first grade is a spastic thing to say. He was the most dominant player in the U20s last season, and equally as dominant recently.

 

[The Teach]

Well you should considering we have the best player in the U20s competition already in that position.

Do you ever have anything positive to say? I personally think Andy is more first grade ready than Bryce right now, mainly due to the defensive requirements. That doesn't mean Bryce won't get a chance before Andy, it's just my opinion!!

 

[chrisD]

Do you ever have anything positive to say? I personally think Andy is more first grade ready than Bryce right now, mainly due to the defensive requirements. That doesn't mean Bryce won't get a chance before Andy, it's just my opinion!!

About Saunders playing first grade in the back row not likely. He did play a game in the back row this season, or was at least named there, I don't remember seeing it so probably an away game. He was back to prop the next game tho.

 

[murraymob]

judging by the amount of players on rep duty this week.We may see a few of the u20 boys getting a call up to nsw cup

 

[bellyache]

judging by the amount of players on rep duty this week.We may see a few of the u20 boys getting a call up to nsw cup

LOL! with your NSW cup #6 in the NZ squad, NZ will cop a 100 - 0, polishing..

 

[mxlegend99]

I can see John being the better of the halves with Johnson nit even making an appearance. The guy is the most talented and skillful half in the competition IMO. But seems to struggle to deliver under pressure.

 

[meek]

Chris
if you read it I actually said
he will be a great firstgader but seriously you blokes see a couple of decentgames and all of a sudden he should be playing for Aust ( figuratively speaking)
rcg is imo more ready for firsts than carty


you blokes see a couple of games NOT that he has played only a couple of decent games .

anyway enough of this rubbish

You need to get over this habit of abusing anyone whos opinion you dont agree with - if you dont like peoples opinions there is a right way and a wrong way to debate them . You always take the wrong way - ive clamed down now but seriosuly im over smartarses on here abusing everyone whos opinion they dont agree with .
tried to PM you to sort out but cant for some reason -
anyhow no more comment on this from me on the carty issue

 

[Scotty03]

for sh!ts and giggles...

1. Moylan
2. Simmons
3. Whare
4. Idris
5. DWZ
6. Soward
7. Wallace
8. Grant
9. Segeyaro
10. Kite
11. Mansour
12. Manu
13. Docker

14. Peachey
15. Plum
16. Latimore
17. Robinson

Some might say Mansour is too small for 2nd row but i disagree, I think he runs hard and rarely gets bent back when carrying the footy. Has a decent offload which can may add some space outwide.

Kingston is a good club man and tries hard but with the talent we have at the moment it would be silly to keep playing him for 80min and weakening our back row when segz/peachey are on.