I don't mind having him in our 30
He's never going to set the world alight but for the most part he's reasonably consistent. He is a cheap fringe prop, if other cheap fringe props had more upside well then they wouldn't be on the fringe. They'd be starting and then cost $400k. For minimum wage at least you know what we're getting.
The alternative is signing some young up and comer - maybe more potential, sure, but think - errors, play the ball mistakes, dumb penalties, lack of game awareness etc
Across Tolman's last 4 appearances (I can't be bothered going back further), he hasn't made a single error, no penalties and only 1 six again conceded. Do I wish he had more spark? Of course - but with Fifita, Hunt, Pele & Graham all out, we're getting our moneys worth with him as a fill-in