What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumoured Targets 3

Knight Tales

Bench
Messages
3,031
A huge part of the problem with Brooks will be he is going from a club where mediocrity is even more built in than ours, to a club where he has been talked up so much that the pressure will be even higher. The kid is set for life already. Why do it to yourself?
 

SamSepi0l

Juniors
Messages
496
Bottom line with Brooks is he's just not that good. No matter how we try and frame it, if we sign him our expectations will still be to miss the 8.
 

Old dog

Bench
Messages
2,661
My recollection of Brooks is he was very good when burst on the scene 8-10 years ago so it’s not that he wasn’t good it’s more of why isn’t he still good even though still in prime years.
His options seem to be, stick with Tigers and same old same old OR make a move and rekindle his game and desire with option to show the doubting thomases.
I think signing him is preferred against what we have and if we do sign him let’s see what he can show us
 

ryan.a87

Juniors
Messages
816
The Mole reporting that Tigers blocked a swap of Klemmer and Brooks and will most likely have them both in 2024 because Klemmer wants out badly
 

PhilGould

Bench
Messages
3,469
Manly have tabled flyer Reuben Garrick a bumper four-year deal which comes with a surprise positional switch.

The Sea Eagles will also flatly reject any bid for Garrick to be released early from his deal to join Newcastle next year.

The Sea Eagles have shown their intent in trying to make Garrick a key part of their long-term future as they try and starve off an approach from the Knights.

In doing so they will shift Garrick from wing to centre next season.

It is understood the Sea Eagles tabled the four year deal last week.

Manly boss Tony Mestrov confirmed Garrick was a priority re-signing.

“The club sees Reuben as a real leader,” Mestrov said. “We have a very good group of players that can vie for the top four year on year and we want him to be a leader in this group moving forward.

“He is a quality human being and a professional. From a cultural point he is also a very important player.”

Garrick has made it clear he wants to make a permanent shift away from the wing and play fullback. Newcastle will offer Garrick that chance which would lead to Kalyn Ponga moving to the halves.

While his opportunities to play fullback at Manly are limited to filling in for superstar Tom Trbojevic, the Sea Eagles plan on moving Garrick to the centres next season.

Garrick has only started one of his 91 top grade games at centre but will get first crack at the spot leaving the likes of Morgan Harper, Brad Parker and Tolutau Koula to battle it out for the other position.

He played 14 games at fullback this year in Trbojevic’s absence.

“We’ve offered him a strong four year deal which would match any offer the Knights give him,” Mestrov said. “He wants to play fullback and obviously with Tom at Manly he can’t do that.

“However our offer is with the intention of playing Garrick at centre. He will play in the centres. He played all his junior representative football at centre. He is also an amazing goal-kicker which adds to the need to keep him.”

When asked if the club would entertain a release Mestrov simply said: “We won’t be releasing him”.

The Sea Eagles are keen on securing Garrick before the November 1 free agency period opens on Tuesday.

Trbojevic is recovering well from a season-ending shoulder injury and will certainly be fit and ready for round one next season.

 
Messages
2,093
So they want to stave off him wanting to move elsewhere to play fullback by offering him a 4 year deal to play....centre?

New Ltd article at its finest lol
 

Jono078

Referee
Messages
21,201
Garrick is a fine player but I don't like us pinning our hopes on him as a fullback.

He wouldn't be in the top 8 fullbacks in the comp and some of the ways he got beaten this year were embarrassing.

I like him but I don't see him as an answer.

Then again, I don't know what the better alternatives are (for our shitty halves situation which Garrick helps as a byproduct of Ponga switching to #6).
 

Old dog

Bench
Messages
2,661
I hope plans are in place for Ponga to stay at 1 and prepare the 4-5 players who will now be striving, we hope, to achieve positions 6 or 7.
Will we be better in 2023 in any position than in 2022, yes less injuries would improve things but we have failed to improve over all at this stage. I may concede we lost Barnett and got Elliott which looks a slight improvement
 

Jono078

Referee
Messages
21,201
You would think if the club is willing to let Clifford go…..after loosing the great Milford…..they must have something locked in
Like how we had a replacement for Pearce? :p

Wonder which half we'll let go next year in the off-season? Clune, Crossland or Gamble..
 

Latest posts

Top