What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

Joshuatheeel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
20,191
Wasn’t Linnett playing on the edge occasionally this year (happy to be corrected), don’t think he has a contract for 2019, would he have taken a small contract ?
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,031
Starring in a QLD comp as a 27yo? You didn't even know the difference between him and a corroboree frog until he was signed up. The QLD ISC winners got flogged like a convict by the Bulldogs and he was nowhere near that team. Smoking cane most likely.
If you’re going to star in any grade you’ll do it at your peak. Why would you think a 27 year old who hasn’t played NRL is going to be worse than a 21 year old who hasn’t played NRL? At least the 27 year old has experience against grown men in reserve grade (including some NRL players).

And the reason the QLD Cup teams get smashed is because there are fewer NRL teams using it to field their backups, meaning there are fewer NRL contracted players in those teams.

But if a bloke is playing to a high enough standard in reserve grade then he should be picked up by an NRL club. He was outplaying other blokes from the bottom end of the Broncos/Cowboys/Titans/Storm top 30 squads. If they have NRL contracts why shouldn’t he?
 

Eelogical

Referee
Messages
23,380
If you’re going to star in any grade you’ll do it at your peak. Why would you think a 27 year old who hasn’t played NRL is going to be worse than a 21 year old who hasn’t played NRL? At least the 27 year old has experience against grown men in reserve grade (including some NRL players).

And the reason the QLD Cup teams get smashed is because there are fewer NRL teams using it to field their backups, meaning there are fewer NRL contracted players in those teams.

But if a bloke is playing to a high enough standard in reserve grade then he should be picked up by an NRL club. He was outplaying other blokes from the bottom end of the Broncos/Cowboys/Titans/Storm top 30 squads. If they have NRL contracts why shouldn’t he?
LOL. You haven't lost your touch Pou. The Eels pluck some ageing unknown from obscurity who will most likely play reserves unless the six options in front of him are injured. That doesn't sound like a plan for the future to me. Have you seen him? Junior could inhale him. It's even worse if those dollars used to sign him restrict our ability to give Hayne another season. To me, he's an average signing at best.
 
Last edited:

strider

Post Whore
Messages
79,010
LOL. You haven't lost your touch Pou. The Eels pluck some ageing unknown from obscurity who will most likely play reserves unless the six options in front of him are injured. That doesn't sound like a plan for the future to me. Have you seen him? Junior could inhale him. It's even worse if those dollars used to sign him restrict our ability to give Hayne another season. To me, he's an average signing at nest.
A minimum salary player wont harm any prospects of signing hayne

Minimum salary guys make it possible for the greedy ones to get rich
 

Eelogical

Referee
Messages
23,380
A minimum salary player wont harm any prospects of signing hayne

Minimum salary guys make it possible for the greedy ones to get rich
No worries mate. But if anyone can say he's an astute signing or even a good signing that will help us move forward then enlighten me. If not, then it's more money pissed up against the wall.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,031
LOL. You haven't lost your touch Pou. The Eels pluck some ageing unknown from obscurity who will most likely play reserves unless the six options in front of him are injured.
Ageing? He is 27. Peak age for a rugby league player, regardless of how good they are.
That doesn't sound like a plan for the future to me.
The fact it’s a one year contract should have tipped you off.
Have you seen him? Junior could inhale him. It's even worse if those dollars used to sign him restrict our ability to give Hayne another season. To me, he's an average signing at nest.
The dollars used to sign him need to be spent on an NRL backup. And plenty of signings are worse than average.
 

Eelogical

Referee
Messages
23,380
Ageing? He is 27. Peak age for a rugby league player, regardless of how good they are.

The fact it’s a one year contract should have tipped you off.

The dollars used to sign him need to be spent on an NRL backup. And plenty of signings are worse than average.
Well, we won that lottery! BTW, I consider 27 to be old in NRL player terms when you're a noob.
 
Messages
42,876
I like to see an underdog given a go. If he really has put on 7kg then he might be the type who was in need of a full-time contract before he could reach his potential. And he's tall isn't he? Anyway, not expecting great things but he's minimum wage, and I doubt we'd have got much better with someone else. It's the expensive guys you need to be selective about.
 

Eelogical

Referee
Messages
23,380
I like to see an underdog given a go. If he really has put on 7kg then he might be the type who was in need of a full-time contract before he could reach his potential. And he's tall isn't he? Anyway, not expecting great things but he's minimum wage, and I doubt we'd have got much better with someone else. It's the expensive guys you need to be selective about.
I've had my say so I'll leave it at that. He can take solace in the fact that I rarely know what I'm talking about.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
154,318
LOL only Pou would talk up a signing of a bloke he has never seen play.


Living up here in two headed country I watch a fair bit of ISC. I have watched the Blackhawks a bit the last few years and I must admit I have never noticed him.( but but but but but you merkins only watch attacking players * channeling Pou ) For a bloke to be offered a top 30 NRL deal from the ISC you would hope the bloke is slaying it like Kenny Edwards was when he was was signed from here. If this bloke somehow cracks an NRL game in the next two years we are on the fast train to spoon town. I would be surprised if we didn't have a few better options in Wenty let alone flegg or even SG ball. I'm sure this bloke was signed by that tight arse Max to get a few cheap jobs done around the Leagues club.
 
Last edited:

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,031
No worries mate. But if anyone can say he's an astute signing or even a good signing that will help us move forward then enlighten me. If not, then it's more money pissed up against the wall.
You have to sign 30 players ffs. On at least minimum salary. You can't only sign 20 and spend the savings on your favourite player.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,031
LOL only Pou would talk up a signing of a bloke he has never seen play.
Who's talking him up ffs? I'm just countering the usual death riding bullshit we get around here. If merkins weren't in such a hurry to put shit on the signing I would never have mentioned it.

He's a backup. And like any backup I hope he never has to play first grade.
 
Top