What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

Legal Eel

Juniors
Messages
1,029
Has Moretti ever played first grade? Murchie has, at three different clubs. He might be a plodder but what does that make Moretti?
Come on guys, just wait until Moretti is picked in first grade and has a bad run and is persisted with by BA - only then will Pou cherry pick a few stats and sing his praises from the rooftops!

remember the golden rule, a player is only good if they are designated so by the coach….it is the only metric that counts
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
153,712
disgusted married with children GIF
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,657
I've seen him in cup. He is better then your peanut friend Murchie
Last year he was always banged up with injuries, this year (5 games in) he’s showing why we signed him in the first place.
Moretti was a schoolboy prodigy in both league and union. He broke a longstanding record after being picked in the Australian schoolboy's for both codes. Can't hurt to give the lad a crack
But let’s not get ahead of ourselves. He’s not top 30 and you’ll need to think long and hard before you give him one of those willy wonka golden tickets.
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
62,867
Has Moretti ever played first grade? Murchie has, at three different clubs. He might be a plodder but what does that make Moretti?

I think NSW CuP is on tv this week. Watch and tell what you think. The fact he is putting up the best numbers of any forward in our side. Most offloads, meters, PCMs.
It is a good sign because we have Moimesea,Ogden,Rodwell,Murchie to compare him with.

Grieg and Bryce played with these guys and right now are going find in NRL.

Mataele is far more explosive but he has missed 29 tackles this season. Needs to stiffen up his defense a tad.
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
62,867
Last year he was always banged up with injuries, this year (5 games in) he’s showing why we signed him in the first place.

But let’s not get ahead of ourselves. He’s not top 30 and you’ll need to think long and hard before you give him one of those willy wonka golden tickets.


On TCT 60s guy posted he is eligible to play NRL after rnd 10. I thought only development contract guys where.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
153,712
Last year he was always banged up with injuries, this year (5 games in) he’s showing why we signed him in the first place.

But let’s not get ahead of ourselves. He’s not top 30 and you’ll need to think long and hard before you give him one of those willy wonka golden tickets.
If only the club thought long and hard before they handed out golden tickets to plodders like Mummamoasia, Odgen and Rein. Especially when we had better options already at the club.
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
62,867
If only the club thought long and hard before they handed out golden tickets to plodders like Mummamoasia, Odgen and Rein. Especially when we had better options already at the club.

As I said I am basing on very small samples. But I saw 5mins of Moimesea amd said he was junk. It wasn't long before BA dumped him to NSW CUP and then Cayless dropped him to the bench.
You need a certain physical side and if that's not there forget everything else.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,334
Come on guys, just wait until Moretti is picked in first grade and has a bad run and is persisted with by BA - only then will Pou cherry pick a few stats and sing his praises from the rooftops!
It's more that there are reasons to pick a player and reasons not to, and the stats can usually show both reasons.
remember the golden rule, a player is only good if they are designated so by the coach….it is the only metric that counts
When you're tempted to second guess the coach, and criticise things you don't understand, it's worth having a look at why he keeps picking the player you hate, and why he doesn't pick the player you don't hate yet.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,657
On TCT 60s guy posted he is eligible to play NRL after rnd 10. I thought only development contract guys where.
I'm going to say that shit has changed and as usual the NRL don't tell us anything.

From Rnd 10 you get to use your 2nd tier merkins + Dev Players.

Why have Dev Players then ? Cos they are outside the NSW Cap / Flegg Cap and you can pay them more.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,334
I'm going to say that shit has changed and as usual the NRL don't tell us anything.

From Rnd 10 you get to use your 2nd tier merkins + Dev Players.

Why have Dev Players then ? Cos they are outside the NSW Cap / Flegg Cap and you can pay them more.
I believe you actually have to pay them more. They are expected to be full time footballers, and under the old second tier system (outside the top 25) there was a minimum salary for full time second tier players compared to part-timers (i.e. merkins doing uni/TAFE/apprenticeships). I assume there is also a minimum (and maximum) for players in the development list.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,657
If only the club thought long and hard before they handed out golden tickets to plodders like Mummamoasia, Odgen and Rein. Especially when we had better options already at the club.
Name a club who has a gun in every position in their top 30. I'll wait.

Facts are that they all gamble on ugly ducklings turning into swans and every club inevitably is left with a few that don't work out. That's the only way you can balance your cap. But go ahead and have a whinge anyway.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,334
If only the club thought long and hard before they handed out golden tickets to plodders like Mummamoasia, Odgen and Rein. Especially when we had better options already at the club.
I'm sure they do. Past performance is a better predictor of future success than most data, and these guys have all earnt top 30 spots in the past, across multiple years. And if you hate plodders you better not look at some of the merkins in the bottom of the Storm and Roosters squads.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
153,712
Name a club who has a gun in every position in their top 30. I'll wait.

Facts are that they all gamble on ugly ducklings turning into swans and every club inevitably is left with a few that don't work out. That's the only way you can balance your cap. But go ahead and have a whinge anyway.
Who’s saying that you Tit?? My point was we brought in absolute dross and gave them top 30 spots when we had arguably better talent at the club. Mummamoasia is one of the most embarrassing signings we’ve had in ages. 2 year deal development club lol.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
153,712
I'm sure they do. Past performance is a better predictor of future success than most data, and these guys have all earnt top 30 spots in the past, across multiple years. And if you hate plodders you better not look at some of the merkins in the bottom of the Storm and Roosters squads.
All clubs have plodders, my point was we brought in plenty of dross when we had better talent already at the club. What does that say about a club that wants to be labeled a development club?? Hands is a perfect example we are lucky he never chucked the shits and went elsewhere.
 
Top