Rumours and Stuff

[Noise]

So Haze Dunsters mutual option…
He will take it up and waste a spot next year.

 

[JokerEel]

Cartwright?

No

 

[EppingEel]

No

Why? Guymer hasn't proved anything, and Kelma is nothing more than average.

 

[EppingEel]

So Haze Dunsters mutual option…
He will take it up and waste a spot next year.

I'd argue post recovery Dunster is a better player than Cini atm, and that's not a good thing.

 

[Gronk]

So Haze Dunsters mutual option…
He will take it up and waste a spot next year.

You are reading it through the lens of the Josh Hodgson contract MO. Dunster's contract would be a vanilla MO.

 

[hindy111]

@hindy111 nailed that re-signing a little while back.

2 years hopefully he can build and improve his game i think he is a centre more then a winger so its hard to judge atm not playing in his preferred position. Our defence atm is a shambles and Blaize isn't helping defending inside him making some horrible reads.

He is a better backup option then Morgan Harper moving forward i feel with more upside at least carting the ball out of his own end.

Little

 

[JokerEel]

Why? Guymer hasn't proved anything, and Kelma is nothing more than average.

Really what's Cartwright done in his time at the club? His defense is horrible and doesn't have a power game.

He is a 5/8 in a forwards body..

Kelma even though needs to work on defense has a better running game.

Guymer is young can defend and do a job that's what we need

 

[Joshuatheeel]

Could be happy with Barlow Joffa starting front row next year..

Barlow
Hands
Joffa
Guymer
Kelma
Hopgood

Guymer may have played on the edge, but don't think his future is there. Not sure he is up to playing on the edge defensively

 

[Soren Lorenson]

Cartwright?

 

[JokerEel]

Guymer may have played on the edge, but don't think his future is there. Not sure he is up to playing on the edge defensively

Better defender than Carty and Lane who currently play 11 & 12.

Defended well in the middle for his 2 games

Also had better fitness and defense than Hopgood in his games in the NRL..

 

[hineyrulz]

So Haze Dunsters mutual option…
He will take it up and waste a spot next year.

Having wastes of space with MO's are what the smart clubs do.

 

[Joshuatheeel]

Better defender than Carty and Lane who currently play 11 & 12.

Defended well in the middle for his 2 games

Middle is totally different to the edge defensively. Look at hoppa, one of our best players and is defensively great. But he wouId get carved up on the edges

Lane/Cartwright issue is they can be lazy at times, but they have the mobility. Don't think Guymer does have the mobility for the edge, plus while playing edge in NSW cup has missed a lot tackles.

 

[Pazza]

Also had better fitness and defense than Hopgood in his games in the NRL..

I feel like Hopgood has been miscast as an 80 minute workhorse. To me he's more a Cayless type player, a smaller skill full middle who is tough as nails. Should be playing 50 - 60 mins a game.

 

[EppingEel]

Really what's Cartwright done in his time at the club? His defense is horrible and doesn't have a power game.

He is a 5/8 in a forwards body..

Kelma even though needs to work on defense has a better running game.

Guymer is young can defend and do a job that's what we need

Apart from a more explosive running game (which Cartwright doesn't lack), Kelma provides nothing. Cartwright is fitter, and will draw more defensive attention than Kelma.

Cartwright also has a great combination with Moses. It's important to note that those two have only played a handful of games together this year.

 

[Noise]

You are reading it through the lens of the Josh Hodgson contract MO. Dunster's contract would be a vanilla MO.

View attachment 92544

You are reading through the Major League Baseball lens

 

[Joshuatheeel]

Apart from a more explosive running game (which Cartwright doesn't lack), Kelma provides nothing. Cartwright is fitter, and will draw more defensive attention than Kelma.

Cartwright also has a great combination with Moses. It's important to note that those two have only played a handful of games together this year.

Thought Kelma was pretty dangerous starting on the edges under Barrett before his injury. His last 3 games, sharks 10 runs / 109 m, 3 TB, dogs 15 runs 138m, 4 TB and roosters 19 runs / 180 m. His defence was ok too.

 

[JokerEel]

Middle is totally different to the edge defensively. Look at hoppa, one of our best players and is defensively great. But he wouId get carved up on the edges

Lane/Cartwright issue is they can be lazy at times, but they have the mobility. Don't think Guymer does have the mobility for the edge, plus while playing edge in NSW cup has missed a lot tackles.

Hoppa? Joffa? Hopgood?

Guymer has more mobility than Lane and Carty.

 

[JokerEel]

Apart from a more explosive running game (which Cartwright doesn't lack), Kelma provides nothing. Cartwright is fitter, and will draw more defensive attention than Kelma.

Cartwright also has a great combination with Moses. It's important to note that those two have only played a handful of games together this year.

Carty will also get lazy and do sweet f**k all.
Was fine 2 seasons ago but not anymore.

Look at the better teams second rowers these days Carty isn't it

 

[JokerEel]

Thought Kelma was pretty dangerous starting on the edges under Barrett before his injury. His last 3 games, sharks 10 runs / 109 m, 3 TB, dogs 15 runs 138m, 4 TB and roosters 19 runs / 180 m. His defence was ok too.

Yep agree big body with speed gives Brown Moses and Gutho options.

Puts the defense into 2 minds on how to defend him.

 

[Joshuatheeel]

Hoppa? Joffa? Hopgood?

Guymer has more mobility than Lane and Carty.

Hopgood