Rumours and Stuff

[Avenger]

If Kelma was any good a club would have snapped him up by now.

 

[senior]

Hopefully Sua signing spells the end of Tuilagi at the club

You can't be consistently good with players like him

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Ask yourself. Would you trade Kelma for Edwards,Blaize or Papali'i?

Maybe Talagi, because we need a 6 next year and he will become a good one, eventually. But Papali'i in our team would look like Papali'i at the Tigers. We already have a fullback so it would be a waste of cap space to bring in Edwards.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

If Kelma was any good a club would have snapped him up by now.

There's about 200 players still available, including some better than Tuilagi.

 

[The Predictor]

The problem is he is 28 and has always been this type of player. He just continually makes poor errors. Thats why he is average

Agreed

 

[Wally21]

Having read through the last 20 pages, I’m none the wiser if Sua is a good signing, a bad signing, better than our current roster, or worse.
just to make it even more interesting, I’m going to say… Good signing!!
but then I know f**k all. Anyway, as you were lads. I’m off to Europe to work for a month or so, so will be following the forum closely for game day updates!!

 

[The Predictor]

If Kelma was any good a club would have snapped him up by now.

Like we did ?

 

[Timana]

He’s talking about John Maclain

Are maklsin, you've done it again

 

[The Predictor]

Having read through the last 20 pages, I’m none the wiser if Sua is a good signing, a bad signing, better than our current roster, or worse.
just to make it even more interesting, I’m going to say… Good signing!!
but then I know f**k all. Anyway, as you were lads. I’m off to Europe to work for a month or so, so will be following the forum closely for game day updates!!

Safe travels

 

[Timana]

I would say the kelma, sooa is coming and if you want to stay, play like a demon in the middle and make him a middle.

 

[Timana]

Physically he is bigger and faster then anyone in our NRL backline (Bloomfield)
Our other starter who many rate higher has dissapeared. I imagine injured.

Faster than jacs?

 

[hineyrulz]

Having read through the last 20 pages, I’m none the wiser if Sua is a good signing, a bad signing, better than our current roster, or worse.
just to make it even more interesting, I’m going to say… Good signing!!
but then I know f**k all. Anyway, as you were lads. I’m off to Europe to work for a month or so, so will be following the forum closely for game day updates!!

Enjoy Wal!! Stay safe buddy.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Having read through the last 20 pages, I’m none the wiser if Sua is a good signing, a bad signing, better than our current roster, or worse.
just to make it even more interesting, I’m going to say… Good signing!!
but then I know f**k all. Anyway, as you were lads. I’m off to Europe to work for a month or so, so will be following the forum closely for game day updates!!

Everyone except Jake thinks it's a good signing.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Faster than jacs?

No

 

[hindy111]

Maybe Talagi, because we need a 6 next year and he will become a good one, eventually. But Papali'i in our team would look like Papali'i at the Tigers. We already have a fullback so it would be a waste of cap space to bring in Edwards.

See id swap Kelma for Papali'i in a heartbeat

 

[Eelementary]

Our best attacker in the forwards, eliminate or minimise the rest, u have a very good footballer

He's 27, and at his third club - this is as good as he will ever get.

I actually reckon if we're going to persist in playing him, that he should come off the bench.

 

[hindy111]

Faster than jacs?

Over 100mtrs? Maybe big strides. Over 40mtrs no chance. But he would be 100kgs also.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

See id swap Kelma for Papali'i in a heartbeat

You're probably remembering Papali'i from when he played for us. And you might not have noticed that Tuilagi has gone to another level under Ryles. He has been excellent this year, after being very good last year. It's like how some people think Su'A must be shit because he plays for the Dragons.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Over 100mtrs? Maybe big strides. Over 40mtrs no chance. But he would be 100kgs also.

I'll be surprised if he doesn't play first grade next year.

 

[hindy111]

You're probably remembering Papali'i from when he played for us. And you might not have noticed that Tuilagi has gone to another level under Ryles. He has been excellent this year, after being very good last year. It's like how some people think Su'A must be shit because he plays for the Dragons.

Both playing better then previous years. At best they are fairly equal I agree. But ones consistent and other rock or diamonds. Kelma needs to be get rid of errors and silly plays