Sam Mac on the comeback trail

[OldPanther]

These young guys have a higher ceiling but Grant would be good experience wise come finals time and should RCG get the call up for Origin

That's all we really need. For now.

 

[Port Panther]

Surely Sam retires and we medical relief dispensation , Mansour gets the longest serving player allowence enabelling Josh to resign for his true worth . Sounds harsh i know but has to happen . Are you with me ?

 

[PANTHERMIKE]

Surely Sam retires and we medical relief dispensation , Mansour gets the longest serving player allowence enabelling Josh to resign for his true worth . Sounds harsh i know but has to happen . Are you with me ?

C

 

[MrBlack]

Toleman being shopped around as well.

Would be a handy pick up for 2 years (then the money goes into the Cleary war chest)

 

[Tronald Crump]

Toleman being shopped around as well.

Would be a handy pick up for 2 years (then the money goes into the Cleary war chest)

Read the other day Dogs may have changed their minds on keeping him. They finally figured out If Woods and Klemmer are called up for Origin they will have no one up front with experience.

 

[Fangs]

 

[Fangs]

Looks like he is fighting on into 2019.

Not sure if this is good for the Panthers or not. But hoping he gets another chance. At the start of the year he look really good.

 

[herbert henry1908]

He should come back, play one game and retire. Go out his way. You’ve got to figure there’s a high chance of this happening to him again.

 

[Panfa]

Sam is a true warrior but after 3 reconstructions it might be time for him to give the game away we have plenty of young forwards coming through and also grant as cover

 

[Bob]

should retire, bone graft, 3 reco s,

 

[The Realist]

My heart wants him to play on and see what he has got. At the start of the season he looked like our best prop.

My head says that at this stage he is almost certainly not going to be the same player he was, and that he might just be too big a risk to take.