sattler out fulton in

[westie]

which 2 did he miss directly? Explain the one where covell lost confidence in his inside man? If I remember correctly that was a bad piece of defence by Covell. Doesn't matter if he's lost confidence. If he comes in they'll always score. If he stays outside there's at least a chance Benji will stop him.

Kidwell, Slater and the one where Covell took both the center and winger but the winger managed to pass back inside to an unmarked player. Luke should have stayed on his man, you should always stay on your man. But it's VERY bad if you can't trust your inside man.

Benji mightn't have been able to stop Kidwell but he should have grabbed the ball and held him up ala Duff Man on Puletua. You are taught to do this at a young age coming through the grades... Sorry, I forgot, Benji didn't come through the grades.

I'd hardly expect Benji to hold Kidwell up. I don't remember Duff on Puletua, I was off my face that night.

Cop out about it being very bad if you can't trust your inside man. It's your job to trust him and stay on your man. Always.

Fair enough Benji's miss on Slater was bad. But i'd hardly say he was resonsible for 3 tries. Come on.

 

[Anonymous]

Then why did you put the try down to Benji?

Because you're a little liar. You're right it IS very bad if you can't trust your inside man. Very bad DEFENSE.

 

[hybrid_tiger]

I challenge any one to stand up and disagree with that fact that Benji is the worst defender this club has seen.

I disagree Westie.

WTF is your problem with him?

His defence has improved from last season, when I thought it would be a problem.

Fitzhenry is a worse defender than Benji will ever be.

 

[westie]

Then why did you put the try down to Benji?

Because you're a little liar. You're right it IS very bad if you can't trust your inside man. Very bad DEFENSE.

Why do you assume I think Covell did well? If Luke hadn't come in, they run straight at Benji and score again. Both aren't in the team this week, so it's useless discussing.

Hybrid: Benji's front on tackling technique is great. Royce has done a great job with him. It still remains that his defense, not tackling technique needs to be worked on. He's got plenty of time to fix it up for next year.

 

[Mighty Tiger]

Yes, my magpies feathers are making me think Benji is a sh*t defender. You really are a smart fellah Phil. Jacko was sh*t, really sh*t, but he was never the result of 3 trys in 1 game. Murph never let in 3 trys. We've had some real turn styles in this club, but never a player who's defense let in 3 trys in 1 game.

Wrong yet again how about you go back and watch the game when the Knights gave it to us I think you will find that the player you just brought up in Murphy actually did allow 3 tries and it could very well of been more ;-)

Once again, you bring Magpies into it. Me thinks you have a slight problem there.

You think ???? Yeah that would be a first :roll:

 

[westie]

Yes, my magpies feathers are making me think Benji is a sh*t defender. You really are a smart fellah Phil. Jacko was sh*t, really sh*t, but he was never the result of 3 trys in 1 game. Murph never let in 3 trys. We've had some real turn styles in this club, but never a player who's defense let in 3 trys in 1 game.

Wrong yet again how about you go back and watch the game when the Knights gave it to us I think you will find that the player you just brought up in Murphy actually did allow 3 tries and it could very well of been more ;-)

Once again, you bring Magpies into it. Me thinks you have a slight problem there.

You think ???? Yeah that would be a first :roll:

You should teach your kid that one. It would go down well at the local preschool :lol:

 

[Mighty Tiger]

Let in 3 tries? Which ones? (Honestly.)

The two he missed directly and the one where Covell had completely lost confidence in his inside man and was trying to cover two blokes at the same time.

Could that exact confidence be why he was dropped this week ???

Yeah I can see it was all the inside man that was causing he all sorts of problems and obviously so could Sheens thats why he didn't play today :lol: :lol:

 

[Mighty Tiger]

Benji mightn't have been able to stop Kidwell but he should have grabbed the ball and held him up ala Duff Man on Puletua. You are taught to do this at a young age coming through the grades... Sorry, I forgot, Benji didn't come through the grades.

Well since you brought the "Duff Man" into it and coming through the grades I also thought that holding onto a ball whilst being tackled also is something you are tought ????

I guess "Duff Man" isn't up to scratch then is he :lol:

 

[Mighty Tiger]

WTF is your problem with him?

didn't you know he asked him out and was rejected straight away!

Fitzhenry is a worse defender than Benji will ever be.

Look out Hybrid your house might now be blown up or something like that bagging a Magpie player who has come through the ranks ;-)

 

[Mighty Tiger]

Why do you assume I think Covell did well? If Luke hadn't come in, they run straight at Benji and score again. Both aren't in the team this week, so it's useless discussing.

There is a difference if 1 wasn't injured he would be in the team and the other wouldn't be ;-) I wonder who that would be :lol: :lol:

 

[Mighty Tiger]

You should teach your kid that one.

Well whatever your into I'm not!!!!

I don't know about you but I don't have a goat, maybe you should have become the Warriors mascot :shock:

 

[westie]

I couldn't really make out what most of those posts ment but they were definately a waste of your time. I still can't understand your fetish with magpie players. You seem to love talking about them, they appear in quite a few of your posts. In fact, you seem to like them more than you think i do. I must say, you are really amusing the way you pretend not to love them.

 

[magpiemax]

not many gap's in the back line this week eh boy's????????? :lol: