Shark Ratings v Rabbits

[millersnose]

D.Simmons 5,
F.Anderson 6
D.Cooper 5,
J.Hannay 6,
L.Covell 5,
B.kearney 6, awful kicking game
B.Kimmorley 7 - as ricky said we had only 2 players putting in a first grade effort
G.Bird 7
L.Thompson 7
R.Williams 5, Not his best game
B.Ross 6,
K.Kingston 4, i would say he is about to get dropped
C.Stapleton 6,
L.Douglas 5
I.De Gois 6 only marginally better than the other useless hooker
P.Loo Loo 5
C.Ciraldo 4 time for a change

 

[azzah72]

Simmo honestly looked like he was tip toeing to the line at no speed, he was horrible.
Kearney looked lost at 5/8 for about and hour.
Hannay isn't doing much nor did Cooper.
Covell and Anderson Tried and thats al i can ask, need to get more footy.
Forwards were all decent i reckon bar a few dropped balls with Bird and Thommo (especially Bird) really standing out, ciraldo probably the worst.
Kimmorley's Defence was pretty damn good most of the time and his kick chases were great, he just has zero creativity in attack at the moment, and looked like he was trying to do it all himself like a few years ago.

We would of been better with seymour in at 5/8 i reckon and left kearney at fullback.

When Gallen comes back i reckon i'd still leave Bird in at lock. is going great Guns atm.

 

[cheese]

You can't be too tough on kearney's quiet first half.

The poor karn't didn't even see the ball.

hoggthebally was up to his usual tricks.

 

[cheese]

Btw ...I still don't reckon he's a half..... He's a ball runner. Needs to be our fullback. At least for the mean time. Kimmorley will continue to make his other half like look a hack. No matter who it is.

 

[blacktip-reefy]

simmons 3
covell 6
Cooper 5
Hannay 7
Anderson 6
kimmorley 5(for effort)
Ross 6 I think he is injured
Kingston 4
Dougie 7
thomo 8
Williams 6
Bird 4
Ciraldo 3
Loo Loo 6
Degois 6
Stapo 5

 

[Surely]

You may be fishing reefy, but seriously how do you give bird a 4 ?

 

[blacktip-reefy]

You may be fishing reefy, but seriously how do you give bird a 4 ?

because he has been given the green light to play how & where he wants by the coach. he has infinite more opportunities to create & look better. No tackle 1 & 2 rucks. Wait for opportunities & gaps & look good.
He has all that, & played like Shiitt for 2 consecutive games now.
hurry back Gallen & use Bird for short iimpacts when the defense is fatigued & he cant f*ck up as much.

 

[Surely]

You're kidding, if our slow lazy backs had of backed him up we probably win the match.

 

[The Dodger]

Simmons - 6 made some good metres but thats about it. not sure if it his shoulder but he looks like a girl out on the field.

anderson - 8 improving by the week. excellent player. the ball should travel to him and hannay more often.

cooper - 4 didnt do much at all. doesnt know how to read the defence for shiit.

hannay - 7 he does well for whatever posession he can get. him and adnerson look like a good combination.

covell - 6 missed a few crucial tackles, even though there were a few times he was left alone to fend for himself. like others, would like to see him in the centre spot.

kearney - 5 put him back to fullback. not a good half at all.

kimmorley - 6 the effort is there but the quality is missing.

ross - 4 did he play?

kingston - 5 overated. did not see no dummy half runs from him all night.

stapleton - 8 the guys a machine.

williams - 8 workhorse.

thommo - 8 the guys a leader. his try should have been allowed. also, should have been called a strip when they called him for a drop ball halfway through the second half.

bird - 6 favourite player. crucial missed tackles cost us the game i think.

douglas - 7 did well. his defence is great.

ciraldo - 6 average. defence was also good.

da gois - 7 so much better than kingston. in attack and defence.

loo loo - 7 did well. good metres gained. defence was good.






Overall - our forwards are amongst the best in the league. they can match it with any other pack. no doubt.

our backs are slowly improving, need some minor adjustments.

our halves need help...

 

[Chondricthyes]

simmons 5 Chase and TACKLE ffs
covell 5
Cooper 4
Hannay 6
Anderson 7
kimmorley 6
Ross 5 he is injured
Kingston 3
Dougie 7
thomo 8
Williams 6
Bird 7
Ciraldo 3
Loo Loo 4
Degois 6
Stapo 6

Gees our bench must scare the opposition sh!tless. Just so many impact players.
Kingston - PL
Need speed out wide
Anderson he looks the goods
Nod to hooker we need a faster 7 to get the ball out wider quicker.
Cam- PL
Loo Loo not enough offensively or mongrel
Ross - hurt
Coop- don't know yet

Wings, centres, FB have got to want to support

Can Seymore Kick? long, short.. anyone know?

 

[carcharias]

D.Simmons3 Utter crap ...looks genuinly petrified
F.Anderson 5 Caught out not marking his man.
D.Cooper 4 quiet
J.Hannay 8 He is all about experience
L.Covell 7 Scored a top try and saved one ...plus nearly caught Merrit
B.kearney 6 the new sully hot and cold
B.Kimmorley 4 too predictable has nothing..not fit to be Thurston's arse paper
G.Bird 5 huge fug up on missing Merrit...thats 2 big ones in 2 weeks
L.Thompson 8 Toiler ...did good
R.Williams 7 usual solid effort
B.Ross 3.1 marginally better than Simmo.
K.Kingston 5 not happening this year yet.
C.Stapleton 9 only bloke to break the line all night
L.Douglas 7 same as Weirdo
I.De Gois 7 scored a try woo hoo.
P.Loo Loo 6 Looked good on his first hit up ...but got driven
C.Ciraldo 4 did he play?

 

[Mr Angry]

Yes Seymour has a good kicking game, his defence is sound.

His attack is a little lacklusture.

 

[spider]

Yes Seymour has a good kicking game, his defence is sound.

His attack is a little lacklusture.

its not as though he would need much on this years 5/8 to replace him anyway MA

sounds like a gun replacement in honesty - he offers much more

 

[blacktip-reefy]

degois has some very good stats from saturday night.

 

[spider]

degois has some very good stats from saturday night.

i have not looked - but which stats, by whom?

 

[blacktip-reefy]

official stats

 

[spider]

official stats

which source though?

 

[blacktip-reefy]

which ever. All the same. NRL site should have them.

 

[spider]

lol - but i mention NRL and its not a credible source of stat

 

[The Dodger]

its pretty much spot on. but like inferno said, you need to wait a few days for them to correct the original results.