Sharks FG side Rnd 18

[Stonecutter]

1. Toshio Laiseni
2. Darren Albert
3. Nigel Vagana
4. Beau Scott :roll:
5. Luke Covell
6. Adam Dykes
7. Brett Kimmorley
8. James Stosic
9. Kevin Kingston
10. Luke Douglas
11. Greg Bird
12. Lance Thompson
13. Paul Gallen


14. Hutch Maiva :roll:
15. Matt Hilder
16. Reece Williams
17. Brett Kearney

 

[Special K]

Nobody wins when Beau Scott takes the field

 

[Macca]

Pom for Scott and I'd be happy. That side will win.

 

[Special K]

How do you pronounce Toshio Laiseni btw

is it like Tosh-io?

 

[Stonecutter]

PL side:

1. Dane NIELSEN
2.Tom KERR
3. Reece LOVEGROVE
4. Ben POMEROY
5.Leon BOTT
6.Jardine BOBONGIE
7. Nick DOIG
8. Clifford MANUA
9. Brett FINN
10. Richard VILLASANTI
11.Darren MAPP
12. Luke HARLEN
13. Leonard ROPETA


14. Sitaleki TIMANI
15. Russell AITKEN
16. Kurt PUOHOTAUA
17. Ryan BORG
18. Mitch BROWN

 

[Sharkie™]

no wonder scott doesnt try and improve because he is basically immune from the axe.

 

[Macca]

I think it's Tow - she - owe -- Lie - See - Knee

 

[Macca]

Russ Aitken on the Bench? What's wrong with him?

 

[Stonecutter]

I don't get it. Pommeroy gets a chance to pove himself, he outplays Beau Scott in a position he isn't used to and still ends up in PL. Give the bloke a go ffs.

 

[Snoop Shark]

So basically Stu:
1. Has no confidence in Albert at fullback
2. Wants us to hate Scott even more
3. Must think Pom still needs to work on confidence
4. Is scared of copping a king hit from Hutch!

PLEASE NOTE: Hutch and Hilder offer nothing!

 

[imasharkie]

Scott in the team is a disgrace.

He's leaving to go to Easts and was outplayed by Pommeroy.

Whats wrong with our selectors.

And obviously Villa is on the outer if he can't get a start in front of Hutch or Hilder.

Still can't see why Waltzing is in the 17. Surely Kearney can cover Kingo. We got steamrolled by the big Bronco forward pack and we persist with 2 small players on the bench.

Whats doin Raper.

 

[McLovin]

Kelly copped some of the same if i remember correctly...

 

[Alan Shore]

How's Aitken doing in PL?

 

[Breadman]

Hutch on the bench is a joke, a not very funny one.
Scott needs a week or 2 in PL regardless if he is staying or not,
he just doesn't seem to learn, definately the most frustrating Shark to watch.
I thought Hilder was pretty good last week, much more energy than the other forwards and put on some good hits but we do need another big bopper

 

[beekershark]

Hmmmm Hilder is hardly "small" Ima !

I can see where he's coming from, minimising changes has it's plusses, it would have been a biger ask for Toshio to debut in a backline that also had Pommery finding his feet in it. Only change is a forced one, ie simmo out, direct replacement Toshio, and Gallen back into the side, Pom drops off the bench.

I like it, the side was on a winning streak before last weekend, whilst im not a scott fan, I like that he's minimising changes , for the time being at least.

Also, I like it far better that he's playing Tosh straight into his preferred position, I don't like chopping and changing and playing em out of position, if Tosh is to shine, let him have every chance in the number 1 jumper, rather than outside B scott or nigel on the wing.

 

[nullasharks]

My side would be

1.Albert
2.Scott
3.Vagana
4.Pomeroy
5.Covell
6.Dykes
7.Kimmorley
8.Douglas
9.Kingston
10.Stosic
11.Bird
12.Thomsen
13.Gallen

14.Villasanti
15.Williams
16.Hilder
17.Kearny

 

[imasharkie]

Except for Albert at fullback, Nulla that looks the right side.

Why can't supercoach see that.

 

[blacktip-reefy]

The side is fine.
Doesnt matter who is picked now!!!!
toshi is there.
throw your houses on this result!!!!!!!!

2 try debut.

for us i hope.

 

[Sheros los Deros]

I think it's Tow - she - owe --

My woman in Tow - she - owe

 

[!fullback!]

cannot believe beau scott is in first grade. not only does he drop the ball at the worst times but he cant even read the defense. ffs stu, give someone else a shot