Sharks Hall of Fame

[DJDL]

But he does

Nope.
He only satisfies 3 of the 5 criteria.

 

[2012....Sharks Year]

Nope.
He only satisfies 3 of the 5 criteria.

I reckon 3 is being kind

 

[Peach & Apricot]

Chris McKenna qualifies

 

[DJDL]

I reckon 3 is being kind

Roger that.
But I was in a generous mood.

 

[Ozzi_78]

Nope.
He only satisfies 3 of the 5 criteria.

I missed that bit.

 

[2012....Sharks Year]

So just to stir the pot... Nicho would qualify in either another 36 games or a premiership. Think the latter might come first.

 

[Special K]

I like the 100 game milestone as a mark especially for moving forward. A lot of clubs (not sure about us) give life membership after 100. It makes 100 actually mean something. I take the point of players careers going longer but you need a line in the sand and if someone made such an impact under it you could fight it or use the other stuff to fit them in like Maloney. Kennedy has 109 games and unless gets bitten by a spider and turns into a super hero isn't going in so I do see the 100 games now not meaning as much as back then.

Players of note who didn't crack 100 - Moylan 96(Wouldn't make it), Lang 96 (Nope), Richardson 92 (Nope), Bird 82.

Players who just cracked 100 - Holmes 105 (I'd argue yes), Bailey 101 (No) and Pomeroy 151 (unquestionable).

Perhaps the different gates need different values. But Maloney (46 games) for example hits

• Demonstrated exceptional performance on and off the field
• Played State of Origin
• Been an international Test representative. (Including Rugby League World Cup matches) - 2017
• Played 100 first-grade games for the Cronulla Sharks or won a premiership with the Club

And made our team of 50 years. All of them should go straight in.

Ennis(51) played origin, execptional performance, won a comp but not sure if he won an award with us. For mine how important he was he needs to go in. Perhaps contributions to success could be looked at down the line. But again 1 comp in however many years how do you define that?

Ash is a mate. Nobody knows more about the club or loves us as much as him. He will take this stuff beyond serious and ensure the historical figures aren't left behind. He takes our history so serious the club created a role for him. From memory he had stuff the club hadn't seen for years sitting in his garage/storage. The collection is unreal go check out his insta - https://www.instagram.com/all_things_cronulla_sharks/

 

[Chimp]

The origin one is silly…. If they’re wanting to ensure calibre of player, they should just have had ‘played representative’ - that covers international and origin - origin kind of rules out all non-Australian players. It would makes sense if it were something along the lines of must have all 4 of the below;
X Number of games
Representative honours
Exceptional Performances
Outstanding contribution to club and community

And the trump card is being part of a Sharks Premiership winning team - you only need 2 of 4 if you’re part of a Premiership.

 

[shadowboxer]

Dumb criteria and dumb club. As noted, anyone who would deny Tommy Bishop should be …. Whatever. It’s 1209 and I’m in my first beer.

 

[Cheese sandwich]

Dumb criteria and dumb club. As noted, anyone who would deny Tommy Bishop should be …. Whatever. It’s 1209 and I’m in my first beer.

How big is the bottle?

 

[Stake Removed]

Dumb criteria and dumb club. As noted, anyone who would deny Tommy Bishop should be …. Whatever. It’s 1209 and I’m in my first beer.

It makes is so much harder for any player who finished career prior to 1980.
The club should be thinking of those players and all our fans who watched these players.
Also the younger fans would get to know these players putting highlights up at the ground.

 

[bluefox68]

So no one before 1980 is eligible if they don't have 4 other criteria? Dumb criteria.

Hey, Frenz - maybe you could apply to present your Mr. Angry awards as a curtain raiser to the main event.

 

[Frenzy.]

Hey, Frenz - maybe you could apply to present your Mr. Angry awards as a curtain raiser to the main event.

Nuh. They'd be saved for the still unnamed Frenzy/Stake podcast

 

[Frenzy.]

So just to stir the pot... Nicho would qualify in either another 36 games or a premiership. Think the latter might come first.

I think Paul Green qualifies. Sorry the following screen is a bit small. Has all the 100 gamers

 

[2012....Sharks Year]

I think Paul Green qualifies. Sorry the following screen is a bit small. Has all the 100 gamers

View attachment 97546

Would be a nice touch for Greeny to be inducted. Only played 95 according to Wikipedia but rules are made to be broken if that's the case.

 

[Quigs]

How many games did Farrar play? Vincey should be first cab off the rank.

 

[Ozzi_78]

How many games did Farrar play? Vincey should be first cab off the rank.

Doubt he’d get any votes as you’d be the only one who remembers him.