What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Simpsons Inanimate Object Mafia Game Thread (Over, Summary up!)

Monk

Referee
Messages
21,347
:lol: at the term bean people

i guess it will be good to finally have whall outed

change vote: whall
 

KeepingTheFaith

Referee
Messages
25,235
So I must be mafia because I've only helped flush out one faction. How about all the people who have helped flush out nobody at all. Of course some of them might not have a helpful power or been unlucky with the powers they do have. But I bet some of them are the bean people happily hiding in the background while someone like me who is helping gets people suspicious

It's not your actions, but your words that expose you - as I've said several times and yet you conveniently ignore it, not to mention your last sentence associating all the quiet people with the bean people.

Ok, let's review....

Says the guy who thinks he knows what happened to every town person even though what you're saying you think happened is not what was in the writeup.

If you vote for PP I will give you the benefit of the doubt. But my theory is PP is in your faction.

If PP is anything but the flying object mafia role I volunteer myself for lynching.

Also, if I am part of a Mafia faction and I'm here furiously trying to get people to vote for someone other than Monk shouldn't that make you MORE suspicious on Monk, not less? Unless you know I'm not Mafia.

Come on, vote for PP and I take back what I allege about you. If PP is anything but mafia aligned we all vote for me.

this was the first post that caught my attention, specifically the bolded part. The favourite and well tried mafia tactic, "Unless you know I'm not mafia". Whall comes up red and you have something to go back to when defending yourself. Preempting is one of the biggest signs of mafia, especially when two factions are involved, especially when the preempt feels very tacked on to a paragraph that barely

Not enough, OK, lets move on to something a little more transparent.

Whall asked you if you doubled his powers night 1, and your response...

Possibly. I don't recall who I did it to each night but I have tried every night, if you got doubled night 1 it probably was from me as I doubt there's someone else with a similar power.

Night 4 and you have no clue who you targeted on night 1? Seriously, nobodies memory is that bad. Even if it was all it would take is a single minute to check your sent PM's to see who you targeted. This answer is a massive tell because it's deliberate avoidance of answering a simple yes or no question.

You're not an overly active poster, but when you do post it's usually quite astute and close to the mark in regards to the game and players in it. This response to a simple question really set alarm bells ringing.
 

BunniesMan

Immortal
Messages
33,738
I think whalls own vote was the clincher, got more than enough.

I will love to hear how if he turns out to be mafia that makes me more likely to be mafia.

Vote for me tomorrow or kill me tonight if you want. Then everyone will look stupid.
 

whall15

Coach
Messages
15,871
Okay everyone, as long as noone blocks me tonight I'll check out Rebel and see if she's mafia.
 

KeepingTheFaith

Referee
Messages
25,235
I think whalls own vote was the clincher, got more than enough.

I will love to hear how if he turns out to be mafia that makes me more likely to be mafia.

Vote for me tomorrow or kill me tonight if you want. Then everyone will look stupid.

More preempting. :lol: What about 2 mafias do people not get?

If you'd like Bunny once I'm done with SGB I'll move onto you. Your tells are far more obvious.

Especially the one that involved your vote this phase and how you basically admitted to being mafia without realising it.
 

StGeorgeBull

Juniors
Messages
452
It's not your actions, but your words that expose you - as I've said several times and yet you conveniently ignore it, not to mention your last sentence associating all the quiet people with the bean people.

Ok, let's review....



this was the first post that caught my attention, specifically the bolded part. The favourite and well tried mafia tactic, "Unless you know I'm not mafia". Whall comes up red and you have something to go back to when defending yourself. Preempting is one of the biggest signs of mafia, especially when two factions are involved, especially when the preempt feels very tacked on to a paragraph that barely

Not enough, OK, lets move on to something a little more transparent.

Whall asked you if you doubled his powers night 1, and your response...



Night 4 and you have no clue who you targeted on night 1? Seriously, nobodies memory is that bad. Even if it was all it would take is a single minute to check your sent PM's to see who you targeted. This answer is a massive tell because it's deliberate avoidance of answering a simple yes or no question.

You're not an overly active poster, but when you do post it's usually quite astute and close to the mark in regards to the game and players in it. This response to a simple question really set alarm bells ringing.
1. The bit relating to Monk was a simple reply pointing out faulty logic if whall was genuine in what he was saying.

He supposedly suspected me of being bad. He votes for Monk, I argue we should vote for someone else. He takes his Monk vote back. Why would someone who genuinely thought I was mafia do that. If he believed what he was saying that should have made him even more confident of voting for Monk.

2. With my power I've been picking people at random. There hasn't been a set plan to it and that's why I wasn't sure about a name I may or may not have chosen 4 cycles ago. The only names I know for sure are PP for obvious reasons and Dutchy because I remember him pointing it out shortly after it happened.

As for checking sent PM's I don't know if my thing is broken or what but my sent folder has always had 0 messages in it.

And most importantly, I don't understand why me being unsure about this action makes me suspicious. If I was in a mafia I could easily track down the quicktopic post where I announced my action and be able to give a confident answer and not have it turn into a big drama
 

BunniesMan

Immortal
Messages
33,738
More preempting. :lol: What about 2 mafias do people not get?

If you'd like Bunny once I'm done with SGB I'll move onto you. Your tells are far more obvious.

Especially the one that involved your vote this phase and how you basically admitted to being mafia without realising it.
My point was to highlight the stupidity being used against me. If he's mafia, I'm the other mafia, if he's town then I'm certainly mafia. There is literally no way I can win with you. I hope you are Mafia because then the rubbish you're coming up with is for a purpose. If you're town you will look stupid as soon as I die or am confirmed.

Do you play poker? The only thing worse than not picking up tells is imagining ones that aren't there.

My gut feeling right now is you and SGB are together. And that he may be your protection. You're making a pretend argument with him while coming at me for no reason at all to try and get people suspicious of me. Because you know it won't take much for them to vote me off.

That way when you're found out after I die any suspicions go off him. And with suspicion off him at that point you're unkillable
 

BunniesMan

Immortal
Messages
33,738
Ladies and Gentlemen of the town, I think the powers that be have decided I'm their target. Whall is about to be lynched which should be a good thing but I am very confident I will die tonight. If that happens and you see proof I am telling the truth, please consider KTF a major nontown suspect and if he turns out to be one of them look at SGB also.
 

KeepingTheFaith

Referee
Messages
25,235
1. The bit relating to Monk was a simple reply pointing out faulty logic if whall was genuine in what he was saying.

He supposedly suspected me of being bad. He votes for Monk, I argue we should vote for someone else. He takes his Monk vote back. Why would someone who genuinely thought I was mafia do that. If he believed what he was saying that should have made him even more confident of voting for Monk.

2. With my power I've been picking people at random. There hasn't been a set plan to it and that's why I wasn't sure about a name I may or may not have chosen 4 cycles ago. The only names I know for sure are PP for obvious reasons and Dutchy because I remember him pointing it out shortly after it happened.

As for checking sent PM's I don't know if my thing is broken or what but my sent folder has always had 0 messages in it.

And most importantly, I don't understand why me being unsure about this action makes me suspicious. If I was in a mafia I could easily track down the quicktopic post where I announced my action and be able to give a confident answer and not have it turn into a big drama

Again, is your memory really that bad? Regardless of whether you pick people at random you still have to read there name, write it down and send the PM.

But here's the interesting thing about that. First we'll quote this post....

I'm the reason the flying object acted twice. I targetted PP and basically doubled up his power. I've been targetting people thinking if they're town I'm doubling up a good persons power and if they're mafia I could find out through the writeup. That happened last night.

Your entire plan is based around either helping townies or paying attention to write ups for signs of your power yet you so easily forget who you sent your powers too.

But that's not the worst part of it.

I have a good feeling about

vote: dutchy

Soc made little sense earlier, if I was on I would have voted for him. Hopefully we are right.

Your entire plan was to either help town or double the powers of mafia to help out them. Does anyone else remember the TWO FORCE VOTES on night 1? Does anyone remember the confusion they created which resulted in the lynches of both Soc and Dutchy?

If this was your plan and it worked perfectly night one, that means you were in the perfect position to speak up and clear the air, yet you didn't.

That's why I'm suspicious. Your own arguments betray your earlier actions.
 

StGeorgeBull

Juniors
Messages
452
Ladies and Gentlemen of the town, I think the powers that be have decided I'm their target. Whall is about to be lynched which should be a good thing but I am very confident I will die tonight. If that happens and you see proof I am telling the truth, please consider KTF a major nontown suspect and if he turns out to be one of them look at SGB also.
You are an idiot.
Again, is your memory really that bad? Regardless of whether you pick people at random you still have to read there name, write it down and send the PM.

But here's the interesting thing about that. First we'll quote this post....



Your entire plan is based around either helping townies or paying attention to write ups for signs of your power yet you so easily forget who you sent your powers too.

But that's not the worst part of it.





Your entire plan was to either help town or double the powers of mafia to help out them. Does anyone else remember the TWO FORCE VOTES on night 1? Does anyone remember the confusion they created which resulted in the lynches of both Soc and Dutchy?

If this was your plan and it worked perfectly night one, that means you were in the perfect position to speak up and clear the air, yet you didn't.

That's why I'm suspicious. Your own arguments betray your earlier actions.
I was looking at the night writeups for clues. When I didn't see any I moved on and the nights without clues didn't stick out in my memory.

But yes in hindsight the double force vote is a possible indication but not a guarantee. You can always have fake force votes. Anyone can write anything and make it look like they're being force voted when they really aren't. That's why I didn't pay as much attention to them as I did to the night writeups. I didn't want to out my role so soon for possibly no gain at all.
 

BunniesMan

Immortal
Messages
33,738
whall'a alignment is irrelevant. You claimed you weren't roleblocked on a night every single townie was roleblocked. You aren't town.

hahaha idiot. I don't even have an active power. I made it up. Sometimes you have to lie to expose a truth. I lied to make you and whall look like liars and to convince people to vote for you. I knew whall was bad as soon as he said everyone had to be roleblocked so if my little white lie helped people vote for you then it was worth it and for the greater good.
 

Parra Pride

Referee
Messages
20,443
Why don't you go check you PMs and tell us who you double powered on night 1, we can take care of the pesky force vote for you.
 

Apey

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
28,285
Weather Update: Mostly sunny with a chance of rain.

Day 6 Votes


whall15 - 8 (BunniesMan, butchmcdick, KTF, Bazal, SGL, SGB, Drew-Sta, whall15)

~~~

For several reasons, town decided that it was time for whall15 to go.

It was a good choice, but it wasn't time for him to go yet.

whall15 has NOT been destroyed, he is Kirk’s Drawing of Dignity, Mafia aligned Masterpiece.

It is now Night 6. PM your actions.
 

Parra Pride

Referee
Messages
20,443
hahaha idiot. I don't even have an active power. I made it up. Sometimes you have to lie to expose a truth. I lied to make you and whall look like liars and to convince people to vote for you. I knew whall was bad as soon as he said everyone had to be roleblocked so if my little white lie helped people vote for you then it was worth it and for the greater good.

Your "little white lie" didn't force people to vote for me, they'd already done it. You're desperately scrambling to try and get yourself out of the fact you outed yourself. You're just lucky these idiots seem to have something against lynching you when the reasoning is something other than "He's BM
get him!"
 

Parra Pride

Referee
Messages
20,443
You guys just wasted a lynch on the don, when you could've munched the Bunny instead. Poor move guys, poor move.
 

BunniesMan

Immortal
Messages
33,738
Your "little white lie" didn't force people to vote for me, they'd already done it. You're desperately scrambling to try and get yourself out of the fact you outed yourself. You're just lucky these idiots seem to have something against lynching you when the reasoning is something other than "He's BM
get him!"

Stop talking the talk and start walking the walk and gun for me tonight
 

KeepingTheFaith

Referee
Messages
25,235
My point was to highlight the stupidity being used against me. If he's mafia, I'm the other mafia, if he's town then I'm certainly mafia. There is literally no way I can win with you. I hope you are Mafia because then the rubbish you're coming up with is for a purpose. If you're town you will look stupid as soon as I die or am confirmed.

Do you play poker? The only thing worse than not picking up tells is imagining ones that aren't there.

My gut feeling right now is you and SGB are together. And that he may be your protection. You're making a pretend argument with him while coming at me for no reason at all to try and get people suspicious of me. Because you know it won't take much for them to vote me off.

That way when you're found out after I die any suspicions go off him. And with suspicion off him at that point you're unkillable

OK, onto the Bunny.

First off, dismissing my argument (scum loves to dismiss without reason or decent argument) as pretend to get people questioning you is stupid in itself. All anyone would need to do is say "Ah, hey guys, how about we lynch the Bunny?"

Also, your dismissal of my reasoning clearly shows you're not paying attention to my argument against SGB. I don't get alignments, all I have to go off is what I read and see, and based on that for the reasons I've already pointed out, SGB looks suss (whether by bad luck or guilt is not something I can confirm).

Lastly, before I start quoting. Accusing someone of being mafia just because they accused you. Not cracking under the pressure are we there Bunny?

Lets look closer though.

I'm not in any mafia faction or indie faction or cult faction or bean faction or lollypop faction or anything else. I was happy to go after SGB if he was wrong. I just felt there was no reason not to believe him and that whall more or less implicated himself. Based on those facts and those facts alone I felt siding with SGB was the right thing to do.

If I was bad I wouldn't have led the charge (or at least second led after SGB) I would have waited for a train to start and then hopped on.

SGB might still be part of the other mafia faction for all we know. But there hasn't been any reason to think that just yet. Either way I don't know because I'm town and so I'm not certain of what others are.

How many "covering my ass" sentences and statements are in here?

Happy to go after SGB if he was wrong (unless you already knew he was right) - Safe play, especially when your previous posts were along the lines of "come on everybody, lets vote" as if people need the extra encouragement to jump on a train.

If I was bad I wouldn't have led the charge after SGB - :lol: Seriously, I could list several times when mafia have voted early, middle, late etc etc. The fact you feel there's a set time and that by going against it proves something shows either weak argument or guilt.

Either way I don't know because I'm town - Clarifying you not knowing by adding in town, again, why do townies feel the constant need to qualify everything they say with "because I'm town".

Then there's this.....

It should be pretty obvious at this point:

vote: whall

Clearly in cahoots with PP. Knew things in the last day phase only Mafia would know when he insisted we'd all be roleblocked.

The only thing whall and PP claimed was that the town couldn't act due to a power they had.

You then claim that you acted so if you believe them then there's no way you could've acted, making you not town.

If you claim to be town then you don't believe them, yet you base your reasoning for voting here on something you don't believe?

You can't believe them AND act as town, those two contradict themselves. If it were a lynch train and you hopped on then sure it wouldn't look suspicious, but you were so quick to start a lynch.

Speaking of starting that lynch, you and SGB both said "if you vote PP that will give you the benefit of the doubt" and yet here you are starting a lynch immediately. So we've already established you're happy to lie to sway a vote.
 

whall15

Coach
Messages
15,871
Weather Update: Mostly sunny with a chance of rain.

Day 6 Votes


whall15 - 8 (BunniesMan, butchmcdick, KTF, Bazal, SGL, SGB, Drew-Sta, whall15)

~~~

For several reasons, town decided that it was time for whall15 to go.

It was a good choice, but it wasn't time for him to go yet.

whall15 has NOT been destroyed, he is Kirk?s Drawing of Dignity, Mafia aligned Masterpiece.

It is now Night 6. PM your actions.

1403.gif


Um Apey, I think you confused me with whall16. This is the role you PMed me remember.

Apey said:
whall15, you are Linguo, Town aligned gramatically correct robot

As Linguo, you have the ability to find out whether people are correct or not.

This manifests itself through your power. Every night you may PM me a name and I will inform you whether they are correct (town) or incorrect (non-town).

You also cannot be lynched.

WIN CONDITION: You win once all threats to town are eliminated.
 

Latest posts

Top