Why not, sin binning has nothing to do with suspension, which is why they differentiate . . . not guilty is not worth a sin bin, guilty is worth moreYou can't have sin-binning for relatively trivial offences when violent acts just get put on report.
Plot twist, Davi is KiwiI saw who posted the thread and got excited that Kiwi was back. RIP Kiwi
So a player who holds another player back gets time off the field while a player who knocks a another player out illegally stays on? He may be ultimately be suspended but that's irrelevant if the game is a GF.Why not, sin binning has nothing to do with suspension, which is why they differentiate . . . not guilty is not worth a sin bin, guilty is worth more
So a player who holds another player back gets time off the field while a player who knocks a another player out illegally stays on? He may be ultimately be suspended but that's irrelevant if the game is a GF.
How about only a 5 minute bin and it counts as an interchange . . . if you want the coaches to really sit up and take notice
This is how I'd like the send off to work. Player gets sent off, team still has 13 on the field but one less interchange player to use
Nope, because that neglects the disadvantage of a player been sent off if the player who has been sent off injuries a opposing player who can't come back on the field.
So a player who holds another player back gets time off the field while a player who knocks a another player out illegally stays on? He may be ultimately be suspended but that's irrelevant if the game is a GF.
Referees are reluctant to sin bin any player for anything considering the potential to change a game, but if they do you'd want to think it wasn't for something trivial.Not rocket science ol' mate, if a referee puts someone on report it means he's not sure how to punish other than a penalty. I'll give you the cost of a phone call . . . give Archer a ring and ask him why referees don't send players on report to the bin
This is how I'd like the send off to work. Player gets sent off, team still has 13 on the field but one less interchange player to use