Slater or Hayne

[simostorm]

Has someone picked Slater up from Brookvale Oval yet? Last seen steamrolled by TREX.

nah.. Slater got up on his own right away.. Your probally used to seeing your players lay down for abit though ay? :lol::lol:

 

[simostorm]

I'm so happy to see Tony playing well and starting to fulfill his enormous potential. He's such a talented bloke, and it looks like Des has got the best out of him, or is starting to.

So jealous.

Dont think so. On a few occasions last ngiht he could have been so much more damaging.. even the commentators were abit baffled at his lacking play.

 

[Eelementary]

Dont think so. On a few occasions last ngiht he could have been so much more damaging.. even the commentators were abit baffled at his lacking play.

Well, fair point. I still think he should be playing in the back row, though.

I wish he was back at Parra, though. He's Parra through and through, but Michael Hagan didn't rate him.

 

[simostorm]

Well, fair point. I still think he should be playing in the back row, though.

I wish he was back at Parra, though. He's Parra through and through, but Michael Hagan didn't rate him.

Idris to me looked much better in the back row.. this guy would be more damageing there for sure.. But then again.. when you got Watmough and Stewart.. theres no point.. and he did score trys last night that maybe lesser wingers wouldnt have.

 

[Eelementary]

Idris to me looked much better in the back row.. this guy would be more damageing there for sure.. But then again.. when you got Watmough and Stewart.. theres no point.. and he did score trys last night that maybe lesser wingers wouldnt have.

Yeah Idris has performed very well in the back-row.

I can understand why he's not playing there for Manly, but it just seems like he is going to end up in the back-row one day anyway.

Maybe I tend to over-rate him a bit because he's an Eels junior and I watched him play in our lower grades. Not sure. But I'd have him back in a heartbeat!

 

[CliffyIsGod]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lztKkkOF9A4