*spoiler* melbourne

[bluenwhite]

MELBOURNE GOT ROBBED.
worst video ref decision ever.

 

[aussies1st]

Join the club - Video refs robbed us (Its getting bigger)

 

[cainen]

Every club has been robbed at some point this year, sometimes more than once.

 

[camsmith]

Pretty bad time of the year to be robbed though...

Shocking!

 

[oxenham]

Which decision?

 

[bluenwhite]

the one where matt bowen obstructed billy slater but then matt bowen was given a penalty try!

yeah, it's the worst part of the season to make such a crap decision, especially when both teams were playing for a home semi-final.

 

[ParraDude_Jay]

Billy took Matt Bowen out first

 

[aids]

fair call by the ref

 

[bluenwhite]

no, matt bowen took out billy first.. well that's just my opinion.

 

[simostorm]

That was a joke as was Webb punching Hoffman in the face, what a joke he should have been sent from the field. Sing screaming into young Inglis's face, what a tosser Sing is.

 

[lotti]

that's for sure, feels weird saying this about Melbourne but at least we're still in the 8.

 

[aussies1st]

What a joke the Refs have been this year. I agree with what Gould said on the Sunday Footy show. Get rid of them!

 

[steaming stormer]

Bowen obstructed Slater first, then Billy obstructed Bowen. Even if you ignore the first indiscretion, how can you be 100% sure that he would have scored??? Absolute bullsh*t decision and in the end it has cost us... (but really our first 20 mins is what cost us!!!)

 

[foster]

you are kidding right.if slater didn't tackle bowen without the ball it was a certain try.as for webb hoffman should have been penalised for going on with it in the tackle.the ref should have blown it up well before the punch was thrown.

 

[steaming stormer]

Scotty Sattler got it spot on... worst decision of the year

 

[snave]

Gee I remember not so long ago Parramatta missed a Goal (2003) but got the 2 points any way against the Cowboys. Didn"t see anyone blow up about that.

You lose we win end of story !!

 

[innsaneink]

Billy took Matt Bowen out first

I knew eventually you'd get something correct. \\\\/

Sing screaming into young Inglis's face, what a tosser Sing is.

I suppose he too ...like Ben Cross, shouldve been binned for giving an opponent a spray???:lol:

Come on man, are we playing footy or is it netball?

If he does it after fulltime, yeah.....hes a tosser, but in the heat of battle, the adrenalins flowing, winners can laugh and losers cop sh*t.

 

[steaming stormer]

Gee I remember not so long ago Parramatta missed a Goal (2003) but got the 2 points any way against the Cowboys. Didn"t see anyone blow up about that.

You lose we win end of story !!

Read my earlier post... it was the first 20 minutes of the game that cost us, but that still doesn't excuse what is a woeful decision. Even Matty Bowen knew he caused the first obstruction... http://www.smh.com.au/news/league/webb-punch-could-hurt-cowboys-most/2005/09/03/1125302785114.html

 

[smeghead]

Bad decision I think. I remember a Bulldogs knock on in goal that led to a try last year and ended up costing my team it's first finals appearance. It happens but at least you are still there

As for Sing giving it to Inglis I think it was a heated encounter all game. Kidwell got out niggled by Sing hahahahahaha

 

[snave]

Steve Roach may have just put the Mocker on us.

Just stated on 7 sport show "Cowboys are the team to beat" !!

Thats what I am thinkin but I won"t say it till it happens !!!

Go you Cowboys


ps Congrats to Parra for winning the 100,000 hard cold cash