What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Stacy Jones out?

Kevinator

Juniors
Messages
6
They need to get rid of Jones and stick Locke at number 7. Jones is well past his day and needs to go. Maybe take one of the big boys from the U20 and put them as wing?

What are your thoughts?
I think we also need some more impact within the forwards. We rely too much on Price. Packer has potential, but he doesn't offload enough, same with the rest of our forwards.
 

Revelation 3:20

Juniors
Messages
1,028
Well the Warriors need to do something! drop some under performers.
Manu, Locke and brown were the Warriors best. I dont blame Stacey but something needs to be done, and if dropping him is the answer then so be it. I think Mannering, Luck or Lillyman should be dropped.
 

ozbash

Referee
Messages
26,922
Well the Warriors need to do something! drop some under performers.
Manu, Locke and brown were the Warriors best. I dont blame Stacey but something needs to be done, and if dropping him is the answer then so be it. I think Mannering, Luck or Lillyman should be dropped.

Locke played 1 game at 6 and 1 at 7 iirc, it was Iro showing the powers that be his versatility and that he could adapt.
He is an awesome fullback.

I'd like to see quite a few dropped actually, Mannering, Luck, Lillyman head the list and McKinnon isnt far behind them. Moon is an experiment gone wrong.

Stacey is the best we have got, everyone bitching and pissing about his form do so very well but fail in one area,, no alternative.

He was signed as a stop-gap, emergency halfback.
He turned out to be still streets ahead of Fein (a hooker), he offers more than anyone else we have (including Shaun Johnson, who still has a long, long way to go).
Leave him there or give Heremaia a shot, we dont have Foran anymore so they should have built the plays around the incumbent 7 (Mr Jones) instead of trying to force the halfback around the plays.
 

Kevinator

Juniors
Messages
6
Locke played 1 game at 6 and 1 at 7 iirc, it was Iro showing the powers that be his versatility and that he could adapt.
He is an awesome fullback.

I'd like to see quite a few dropped actually, Mannering, Luck, Lillyman head the list and McKinnon isnt far behind them. Moon is an experiment gone wrong.

Stacey is the best we have got, everyone bitching and pissing about his form do so very well but fail in one area,, no alternative.

He was signed as a stop-gap, emergency halfback.
He turned out to be still streets ahead of Fein (a hooker), he offers more than anyone else we have (including Shaun Johnson, who still has a long, long way to go).
Leave him there or give Heremaia a shot, we dont have Foran anymore so they should have built the plays around the incumbent 7 (Mr Jones) instead of trying to force the halfback around the plays.

In my opinion, McKinnon is one of the best fullbacks in the competition. I think he brings a lot to the back line, and it would be a mistake to drop him.
Jones really brings nothing to the table, other than his kicking, that Locke doesn't. Locke has the pace and the confidence over Jones, and I think if they tried him out at 7 we would find he has a decent boot too.
The reality is, Stacy is passed his use by and shouldn't be named next season. We should start putting Locke at 7 to get him used to the position and give him some experience for 2010.

It's obvious we have no hope in this competition, so we might as well start preparing for next season.
 

ozbash

Referee
Messages
26,922
Kevin Locke is not a halfback.

He used to be at the Tigers when he was younger, but he wont be at the Warriors.

In my opinion, McKinnon is one of the best fullbacks in the competition.

was mate, 2-3 years ago. He's useless now.
 

Skinner

Coach
Messages
13,581
Nobby is a natural fullback. He's not a 6 or a 7. He was born with number 1 on his back.

He's going OK at wing at the mo, so don't try and make him a pivot.
 

Revelation 3:20

Juniors
Messages
1,028
Locke played 1 game at 6 and 1 at 7 iirc, it was Iro showing the powers that be his versatility and that he could adapt.
He is an awesome fullback.

I'd like to see quite a few dropped actually, Mannering, Luck, Lillyman head the list and McKinnon isnt far behind them. Moon is an experiment gone wrong.

Stacey is the best we have got, everyone bitching and pissing about his form do so very well but fail in one area,, no alternative.

He was signed as a stop-gap, emergency halfback.
He turned out to be still streets ahead of Fein (a hooker), he offers more than anyone else we have (including Shaun Johnson, who still has a long, long way to go).

Leave him there or give Heremaia a shot, we dont have Foran anymore so they should have built the plays around the incumbent 7 (Mr Jones) instead of trying to force the halfback around the plays.


Mannering - looks to be in dreamland some where
Luck - Can someone tell him he is not a number 6, Cant break the line to safe himself.
Lillyman - Is not an impact player, prone to knock-ons, to simial to luck
Moon - is not a centre!
Hendo - needs to stop trying to milking penilties, ref do fall for it
Lance - Is not a 6

I disagree about Stacey, its not about his skill level its about the team structure - and he stick out like a sore thumb in defence. And looks to rushed in end of the set plays. I wouldnt suggest dropping him cos he sucks but because they should blood new players and need to change the structure - its just not working. To all those who bag Stacey, there are those who stick up for him. Whats happening at the Warriors is just not working. Players need to be dropped and if it continues the coach will be getting edgy. They need to get back to basics
 

Kevinator

Juniors
Messages
6
Nobby is a natural fullback. He's not a 6 or a 7. He was born with number 1 on his back.

He's going OK at wing at the mo, so don't try and make him a pivot.
Well if we're ever going to make him a pivot, nows the time. As is said, the season's over for us and we should start preparing for next year. I reckon we try him out at some new positions and see how he goes.
 

Rich102

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
11,773
Oh great! Another three years of rebuilding.:crazy:

Buy some more Aussie has-beens and play them out of position.
 

Micistm

Bench
Messages
4,470
Jones on the bench. Some so-called experienced heads to roll and be dropped. Jones was average...but so were the team around him. Lack of confidence, complancency...call it what you will, by any other name it isn't good enough. These senior players are making dumb, dumb errors you don't see in the U/20s...and the U/20s know how to score tries. Promote a few of these, drop a few of these seniors who are not living up to their paychecks-And let's at least see a team which will be entertainment.
If I was a season ticket holder, I would be wanting a godd rebate for this year, the entertainment factor is sh*t
 

Meth

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
35,764
I don't know who's more idiotic- Kevinator suggesting Locke at 7, or Ozbash trying to claim Jones is the best we've got.

In saying that, Jones was not the worst on the paddock today; it was actually one of his better games in a long time- credit where it's due.
 

Meth

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
35,764
re today;

Locke and Vatuvei were both good. I thought Moon's performance at centre was encouraging. Henderson played very well, I thought. Rapira worked hard.

Hohaia was poor; I want him to be a utility, not a 6. Lillyman is a waste of time
 

dazza

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
960
Oh great! Another three years of rebuilding.:crazy:

Buy some more Aussie has-beens and play them out of position.


i was thinking the same thing mate.

isn`t it about time they signed another hooker :sarcasm: they seem to go thru them pretty regularly.



cheers dazza
 

Lox

Juniors
Messages
231
their kicking options were poor especially from hohaia who isn't a 6 by the way...
 
Top