Stand Alone Rep Round

[adamkungl]

How does this sound.
R1-R15. All teams play each other once.
3 week break for Origin.
R16-R22. Top 8 teams play each other once. Top 6 progress to finals series in spots 1-6 respectively. Meanwhile, bottom 8 teams play each other once.
R23. Top 2 from Bottom8 group play bottom 2 from the Top8 to decide the last 2 finalists. Top 6 enjoy the week off.
FINALS SERIES PER CURRENT FORMAT.

Thoughts?

Let's call it the McIntyre Rule.

If your sports league idea is more complicated than it absolutely needs to be, it could at the very least use improvement.

That said this isn't too bad an idea really. I think the current way the draw is decided, who plays who twice rather than once, could use a more defined structure than it has now, and the fact we have teams playing each other twice in 5 weeks still is rubbish.

 

[POPEYE]

How does this sound.
R1-R15. All teams play each other once.
3 week break for Origin.
R16-R22. Top 8 teams play each other once. Top 6 progress to finals series in spots 1-6 respectively. Meanwhile, bottom 8 teams play each other once.
R23. Top 2 from Bottom8 group play bottom 2 from the Top8 to decide the last 2 finalists. Top 6 enjoy the week off.
FINALS SERIES PER CURRENT FORMAT.

Thoughts?

That'll do . . . anything, as long as people keep talking up a 3 week break for Origin

 

[JamesRustle]

AFL will be scheduling the "Battle of the Bridge" ...
Swans v GWS....

I say bring it on and put it against Fiji v Samoa...

We will still take them...

Which bridge goes from Moore park to Liverpool? Or do they play for all the bridges in NSW?

 

[Lambretta]

Origin and rep rounds should be played under proper Rugby League rules - as stand alone

Shoulder charges allowed
Sin bins, not send offs for punching
All in brawls encouraged
1 referee
Video ref for try's ONLY and no ruling on interference bullshit, just groundings

All Origin games to be on a Saturday
Friday Nights can be reserved for Pacific Islands for the first 2 Origin weekends

If game three goes to a decider, the Friday night will be best Pacific Island v NZ

Sundays can be festival of the boot for NSW & QLD Cup with triple headers where clubs play at the same ground on the same day. Throw it open free for kids - have Origin players meet and greets on the day and make it a Statewide celebration of Rugby League. Just not NRL

NSW games could all be at Penrith or Parramatta or Kogarah. A traditional suburban ground with all games televised.

 

[Lambretta]

Which bridge goes from Moore park to Liverpool? Or do they play for all the bridges in NSW?

I was wondering if the GWS are suddenly representative of the lower North Shore

Maybe they mean Gladesville Bridge?

 

[JamesRustle]

I was wondering if the GWS are suddenly representative of the lower North Shore

Maybe they mean Gladesville Bridge?

GWS is definitely surviving on a bridging loan and Swans had bridging finance by way of a living allowance from afl hq. I think that's what it means!

 

[Lambretta]

GWS is definitely surviving on a bridging loan and Swans had bridging finance by way of a living allowance from afl hq. I think that's what it means!

For the people of Western Sydney it's a bridge too far

 

[mistertaylor]

Oi no AFL crap on the RL forums fellas! Haha

 

[mistertaylor]

That said this isn't too bad an idea really. I think the current way the draw is decided, who plays who twice rather than once, could use a more defined structure than it has now, and the fact we have teams playing each other twice in 5 weeks still is rubbish.

Agree 100%.

When I came up with this, my thinking was that it generates more games between top 8 teams in the post-Origin period. By contrast, it also creates more games involving bottom 8 teams, but that is the only fault I can find with this format.

 

[WaznTheGreat]

We need a standalone SJW/Feminist/Liberal/safe space/transgender round

 

[Reggie70]

What about this idea;
Competition pauses for 3 weeks for:

Women S.O.O NSW V QLD Thursday ngt x 3

Men S.O.O NSW V QLD Friday night x 3

Saturday 3pm/5pm/7pm

Tonga V Samoa x 3

FIJI V Cook Islands x 3

PNG V NZ x 3

Draw can change each year

Sunday

NSW cup V QLD cup 12pm

City V Country Sunday 3pm Regional NSW

That gives players in NRL squads to play in eligible teams.

Also gives NSW & QLD cup players a chance to players opportunities too.

NSW & QLD Cup competitions still run as per draw.

 

[kdalymc]

What about this idea;
Competition pauses for 3 weeks for:

Women S.O.O NSW V QLD Thursday ngt x 3

Men S.O.O NSW V QLD Friday night x 3

Saturday 3pm/5pm/7pm

Tonga V Samoa x 3

FIJI V Cook Islands x 3

PNG V NZ x 3

Draw can change each year

Sunday

NSW cup V QLD cup 12pm

City V Country Sunday 3pm Regional NSW

That gives players in NRL squads to play in eligible teams.

Also gives NSW & QLD cup players a chance to players opportunities too.

NSW & QLD Cup competitions still run as per draw.

kangaroos have a team too you know. unless we go back to the end of year tri/4 nations. that was dope

 

[taste2taste]

What about this idea;
Competition pauses for 3 weeks for:

Women S.O.O NSW V QLD Thursday ngt x 3

Men S.O.O NSW V QLD Friday night x 3

Saturday 3pm/5pm/7pm

Tonga V Samoa x 3

FIJI V Cook Islands x 3

PNG V NZ x 3

Draw can change each year

Sunday

NSW cup V QLD cup 12pm

City V Country Sunday 3pm Regional NSW

That gives players in NRL squads to play in eligible teams.

Also gives NSW & QLD cup players a chance to players opportunities too.

NSW & QLD Cup competitions still run as per draw.

SOO has to be on a Wednesday, ch 9 have experimented with different days and it doesn’t rate as well.

If you have SOO on Wednesday you can then have Tonga V Samoa on Sunday so the PI origin players can back up and play, Tonga v Samoa without its origion players takes a lot of appeal out of the game.

I wouldn’t have it as 3 consecutive weekends, SOO works well with a few rounds between, this builds up the hype and improves ratings.

 

[kdalymc]

why are we obsessed with a time of year for rep...? you know why union shit on us when it comes to internationals- cos they f**king play internationals, all year round...

 

[siv]

SOO would work on a Tuesday