MacDougall
First Grade
- Messages
- 5,744
Didn't he set up like 7 tries or something insane a few weeks ago?
Yep and he would have set up 5 or 6 again on Saturday.
And he's playing with an AC injury too.
Didn't he set up like 7 tries or something insane a few weeks ago?
Yes we have blooded heaps. 3 or 4 teenagers last year alone plus a few more young guys this year. This myth we hold players back keeps getting round Panthers forums because in 2011 Gus said he thinks most kids need to play NSW cup before FG which all of these kids have. We will debut atleast 3 or 4 more next season aswell. Martin is chance after some nsw cup, Kikau will figure then we have our 20s which have been going very well including the best playing up in nsw cup. The whole plan is to bring these kids through and its been happening and will continue next year.
It's nothing to do with that at all. If Wallace and Soward stay fit he wont play.
It's nothing to do with that at all. If Wallace and Soward stay fit he wont play.
So he'll play about 15 games next year then
I don't think giving young guys a run in the NRL is any real yardstick of how well a club is run.
You have to look at how their careers progress after they get a taste of NRL.
IMO some young kids play too many NRL matches at a young age, or are thrown into the NRL before they are ready.
Injuries often force those decisions, but some does poor planning, recruitment and retention.
In the case of young forwards, they have to be physically ready for the NRL, being big helps.
In the case of young halves, there are similar issues, they can get knocked around or loose confidence if they are thrown into NRL too early.
The really good players handle it, but there are not many of those.
For most young halves they need 2-3 seasons to become a top performer in the NRL.
The Tigers have Moses and Brooks, who have already had a couple of years in the NRL, Martin will get more opportunity at Penrith, I recon Wallace only has 1-2 more seasons of NRL.
Im not saying its makes us a better or worse club then any others its just our plan going forward is to develop and promote as much as possible from within with a clear path from NYC to NSW Cup and then to FG when the opportunity presents itself, in fact the problem we have now is we have to lose some depth to keep everyone we want too, we have lost or are losing quite a lot of experienced Fgers this year whose depth positions will be taken up by guys who have played very little to no FG.
Id rather if all our kids were forced to play close to a season in NSW cup especially forwards, though some of them don't need it its still an adjustment period for them physically. None of them are getting to FG without playing NSW cup atm so that's good enough. Out of four teens I mentioned debuting last year all them went on to play regular FG this year.
Turned down the Cowboys to play for a mid-tier club
Lacks ambition
Turned down the Cowboys to play for a mid-tier club
Lacks ambition
Fair enough, my comments were not directed at any particular club.
I always think the best players are the ones clubs develop themselves so I am 100% in favor of promoting and developing local talent.
Penrith usually have a lot of talented local juniors, so it makes good sense.
There was an era where some young guys from NYC were being thrown straight into the NRL, luckily that is now changing. Again I don't think that was any particular club, more of a general trend.
Most young players probably need 1 season in NSW cup or QLD cup before playing NRL.
Turned down the Cowboys to play for a mid-tier club
Lacks ambition