What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

team for shellharbour trial

westie

Bench
Messages
3,936
He runs a nice angled line, but he's one of those classic players without a position. Not enough ball playing ability to be a 5/8th, too sh*t to be a fullback or centre - not big enough in the current game to be a floating lock.
 
Messages
42,652
If he runs one nice angled line per game, he leaves Morris' attacking ability in the dust behind him.

We have a better 5/8 at the club, we just haven't found him yet and Uncle Tim is set on starting Morris somewhere and he can't start him at his real position.
 

Palms

Juniors
Messages
543
Always amazes me when someone backs Morris up. Makes me think it's Morris himself, or Sheens, because you just can't have watched Morris since he came to the Tigers and think he's a halves arsehole...

I know he'll be our starting 5/8 and deep down I really hope he does the business, but I simply don't think the ability is there.

Im not backing Morris up, and defo dont think he is a halves shoelace...terrible kicking game with no vision, but just stating that there are no better options at this stage for 5/8 with Benji our first choice Halfback. I agree 100% his possy is at hooker mate.
 

Palms

Juniors
Messages
543
Thanks EA and super coach, they were bloody good answers from a couple of brain dead supporters;-).. Seems Palms is the only genius here., maybe teflon could sign him up to cover while he is away coaching the Roo's.

By brain dead supporters I mean those people that shoot off at the mouth without backing up their taunts. I thought EA and super coach had very valid points, and SC I didnt get to see much of moltzen at fullback in the u/20's last year so thanks for the info.

Ultimately I think Gallant has shown enough from last year that he deserves first crack at the FB job this year and I reckon that is what Sheens will run with. My point macnaz (where did i state i was a genius?) is that its still a trial, gallant has proved he has what it takes and its not like we are playing an NRL team so why not give Moltzen game time. If it fails we have lost nothing if it works then sheens knows he has another option up his sleeve should gallant fall injured!
 
Last edited:
Messages
42,652
TBH, I'd have Moltzen in a 5/8 and I would have had him there in all the trials. I think he has the potential to be a very good 5/8.

Morris had potential, in 2001.
 

matty-ducati

Juniors
Messages
251
there is alot of its only a trial being said on here.. correct its only a trial, but ffs leave gallant at fb, let him get as much time with the team on the field as possible, f**k this trialing this guy here and this guy there, we have out fullback, f**k everyone else off then, if he gets injured im sure teflon will have a backup plan like he always does.. maybe gibbs at fullback! i think our team has trialed players in every position and failed big time, how but we f**ken leave the team for once and see how it goes.
 

MacDougall

First Grade
Messages
5,744
I have no idea why the Tigers coaching staff turned Blake Lazarus into a fullback let alone Moltzen. Lazarus was a ready made superstar halfback. Not that it matters now. I'd say Moltzen is our best option at 5/8 as long as Marshall is really turning it on as a halfback and Farah is playing well. If Marshall and Farah are struggling then you gotta give Wayde Dunley the green light.
 

Joe's Magpies

Juniors
Messages
601
Wests Tigers recorded a 70-4 victory over Shellharbour City Dragons in a first grade trial at Ron Costello Oval, Shellharbour, on Friday, March 6.
In front of a crowd of more than 4500, Wests Tigers ran in 13 tries to one in a strong, final hit out before opening their Telstra Premiership campaign against Canberra Raiders at Campbelltown Sports Stadium on Monday, March 16.
Shellharbour, the St George-Illawarra Dragons NSW Cup team, never stopped trying against their more experienced and classier opponents.
It appears Wests Tigers have suffered no major injuries out of the trial.
Wests Tigers opened the scoring in the fifth minute when centre Chris Lawrence made a break down the left flank before linking up with winger Taniela Tuiaki to score out wide for a 4-0 lead.
The opening 10 minutes of the match was played in near dark due to a power failure but the lights were soon back on.
Full-back Tim Moltzen then made it 8-0 after finishing off a backline play to score in the corner. Half-back Benji Marshall converted from the sideline for a 10-0 scoreline after 14 minutes.
It became 14-0 when centre Dean Collis ran onto a pass from Gareth Ellis to step past three defenders to score next to the posts. Marshall converted the try for a 16-0 lead after 17 minutes.
Three minutes later, Tuiaki finished off a backline play involving five-eighth John Morris and Lawrence to score in the corner. Marshall converted for a 22-0 lead.
Moltzen then scored his second try when he ran off an inside ball from Marshall to score next to the posts. Marshall converted for a 28-0 lead.
Tuiaki scored his third try in the 25th minute when he beat three defenders from 20 metres out to score. Marshall converted for a 34-0 lead.
Moltzen then scored his third try when he raced 20 metres to score after a break up the middle by Morris.
Marshall converted the try for a 40-0 lead after 27 minutes.
Shellharbour threatened the Wests Tigers line in the 34th minute and looked set to score before a shoulder charge by Marshall stopped their momentum. The defence held strong on the last tackle to keep the Dragons at bay.
A short pass by Farah to Collis saw him juggle the ball before stepping his way to score near the posts in the 43rd minute. Marshall converted for a 46-0 lead.
Prop Keith Galloway then added to the tryscoring tally when he charged over from a short pass to score out wide for a 50-0 lead. Marshall converted for a 52-0 lead after 55 minutes.
Winger Beau Ryan then got his first try when a short kick by Farah in goal was dropped by Shellharbour for Ryan to dive on the loose ball to score. Marshall converted the try for a 58-0 lead after 60 minutes.
A short grubber kick by Marshall saw the ball sit up perfectly for Tuiaki to scoop it up to score in the corner for a 62-0 lead. Marshall failed to convert from the sideline.
Shellharbour got on the board in the 70th minute when second-rower Neville Costigan beat two tacklers to score in the corner for a 62-4 scoreline.
Junior Roqica was brought on for the final 10 minutes after a good performance in the U20s trial. He almost scored with his first touch when a grubber kick by Morris saw him dive in the corner only for the ball to be forced dead.
Roqica did get on the board when he scored in the corner after some quick hands out wide for a 66-4 lead. Robert Lui, also rewarded from the U20s game, failed to convert after replacing Marshall.
Roqica grabbed his second try in the 79th minute when he finished off a fine play by Morris and Moltzen to score in the corner for a 70-4 scoreline at full-time.

From weststigers.com.au
 

nqcowboy87

Bench
Messages
4,181
Shellharbour threatened the Wests Tigers line in the 34th minute and looked set to score before a shoulder charge by Marshall stopped their momentum.
testing those glass shoulder out
 

innsaneink

Referee
Messages
29,384
testing those glass shoulder out

Yep...the flicks still good too

2005_Marshall%20flick%20pass_w480.jpg
 

nqcowboy87

Bench
Messages
4,181
now that wasnt called for
Quote:
Originally Posted by matty-ducati
i think next he will put Daine Laurie at fullback or maybe galloway... why wouldnt that suprise me

:lol: unfortunately it wouldnt
well mr sheens has played daniel fitzhenry at halfback and hooker before
 
Top