Team List Tuesday Rnd 7 vs Knights

[golfer]

Jake! Not on what I saw yesterday.

I totally agree, he was slow and very cumbersome. My thoughts were that he will not see 1st grade again this year. I am dumbfounded that he is listed in the reserves.

 

[Gronk]

I totally agree, he was slow and very cumbersome. My thoughts were that he will not see 1st grade again this year. I am dumbfounded that he is listed in the reserves.

It was between Jake, Carty, Rein or Emu. The rest are not top 30.

Of those 4 Carty and Rein should not be rewarded for being rubbish. Emu is not ready (but could play).

Jake is selected like Haze was for yesterday. He will only see the grass if we get an injury 1-7.

 

[JokerEel]

JA... I just don't understand it.

He sits on the bench for 70 minutes and gets no game time or plays NSWcup and get 80 minutes...

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Just remember every dude you bring off the bench is fewer minutes for someone else. But you have to pick 17 so why not use one slot for injury cover?

 

[Noise]

It was between Jake, Carty, Rein or Emu. The rest are not top 30.

Of those 4 Carty and Rein should not be rewarded for being rubbish. Emu is not ready (but could play).

Jake is selected like Haze was for yesterday. He will only see the grass if we get an injury 1-7.

How was Carty rubbish yesterday? He made 14 runs for 112m, 1 try assist, 23 tackles with 0 missed and 0 ineffective (100% tackle efficiency) and 1 error.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

It’s his recent performances in first grade that are alarming. How many solid games in reserve grade make up for that?

 

[Noise]

It’s his recent performances in first grade that are alarming. How many solid games in reserve grade make up for that?

What is alarming?

His last game in first grade he only missed 1 tackle (against Fifita who is the hardest merkin to tackle, as did Matterson).

I think in the game prior against St George he only missed one tackle too.

And we won them both.

 

[Gronk]

How was Carty rubbish yesterday? He made 14 runs for 112m, 1 try assist, 23 tackles with 0 missed and 0 ineffective (100% tackle efficiency) and 1 error.

He was standing in the 6 position a lot and often received the ball as first receiver. My thinking yesterday was for him to play some 6 maybe he could be used for that benchy #17. He's too erratic. Gets caught of position. It's almost like he clocks off mentally. Maybe he has ADHD. Get him on the ritalin BA. The ^^^ missed tackles stats must only count if he attempts.

 

[Happy MEel]

He was standing in the 6 position a lot and often received the ball as first receiver. My thinking yesterday was for him to play some 6 maybe he could be used for that benchy #17. He's too erratic. Gets caught of position. It's almost like he clocks off mentally. Maybe he has ADHD. Get him on the ritalin BA. The ^^^ missed tackles stats must only count if he attempts.

Can you point us to any instances this year where he didnt attempt a tackle he should have?

 

[hineyrulz]

I totally agree, he was slow and very cumbersome. My thoughts were that he will not see 1st grade again this year. I am dumbfounded that he is listed in the reserves.

Why is anyone shocked, it’s not what’s best for the team it’s what’s best for team Arthur. The bald prick is an absolute joke, the nepotism Gnome strikes again!!

 

[Gazzamatta]

How was Carty rubbish yesterday? He made 14 runs for 112m, 1 try assist, 23 tackles with 0 missed and 0 ineffective (100% tackle efficiency) and 1 error.

He didnt look good yesterday stats aside. He did a few of those Hail Mary plays one of which let to a try but fu*k knows how. He seems to have gone backwards this year but if its a choice between him and Jake, Carty wins every day in my book. Maybe Cartys fall coincides with Jakes miraculous rise and Cartys not happy.

 

[hindy111]

It’s his recent performances in first grade that are alarming. How many solid games in reserve grade make up for that?

Will you hurry up and get to Canberra and do some work

 

[hindy111]

I am not getting involved in the JA debate. Just hope he goes well if plays

 

[hineyrulz]

Watching the game yesterday I said to myself, you know what we are missing out there Jakey Boy. Not!

 

[yy_cheng]

I've got a feeling that they don't expect to be able to resign both moses and Brown. Maybe can keep 1

 

[Avenger]

I am not getting involved in the JA debate. Just hope he goes well if plays

I feel sorry for the kid I really do because there are better options, unless of course Moses or Brown and under an injury cloud.

 

[Joshuatheeel]

So JA who is still only 19, returns from a serious operation and hasn’t played for a few weeks. Makes 16 runs for 136 m….has 1 LBA, 2 TA, but we still doubt his potential…yeah he his NRL selection is debatable but the kid has talent

 

[hindy111]

I feel sorry for the kid I really do because there are better options, unless of course Moses or Brown and under an injury cloud.

I mentioned this earlier. Squads moving forward would do well if can have a guy in system for 10yrs who is only ever a back up.
Jake maybe that guy. Throw him 150k a season to just know our system. He is 19 so by the time he is 21 he will fill out and understand what's needed. Might be the guy that isn't good enough to be in anyones top 17 (barring injuries) but good enough for this role.

Anyone who think he will fill out and be a forward I reckon are off heads. Matterson was always a powerfull runner of the ball. Jake isn't. I see him as a half and that's it. Most likely in the mould I just suggested

 

[crocodile]

Not much happens in my day to day life. When my phone rang I become excited. Untill I seen it had 14 digits and some Indian on the other end trying to sign me up to something.

I usually get the Indian telling me someone is trying to hack my computer. I love playing with these guys. Always try to get you to run Team Viewer.
Type T for Tango.
Now type E for Echo.
Hang on a minute, I can't remember how to spell Tango.
No, No, not Tango, just T.
But you said T for Tango, just tell me how to spell Tango.
And so on.

 

[emjaycee]

I feel sorry for the kid I really do because there are better options, unless of course Moses or Brown and under an injury cloud.

I dont think there actually are any options (better or worse) that are available at the moment mate.