This is how I see it reading into SKs comments yesterday and what I'm seeing
Having a fair dinkum go
Matulino. I really thought he was very very good yesterday. Keeps this up he's a great pick up for Ivan.
Roache
Ayshford
RTS
Mannering
Having a go but not in form or delivering on potential yet
Fus
Afoa
Ken - what's happening to his hands again?
Lino - lacks acceleration and speed sadly
Tevaga - never doubt his effort
Bell - known as a bloke who tries hard to punch above his weight
Turned up late but trying now, amazed how bad their headspace is though
Kata
Questionable at best
Foran
Lisone although I thought he was quite good yesterday actually
Checked out/couldn't care less
Lillyman - there was some real sloppiness around the ruck, particularly the second try where he casually walks back to marker
Luke. Disgraceful first half in particular, we got a great roll on with his replacement
I don't get Issac Luke. One outstanding month per year. Starts the year slow every year. Gives up after Origin.
Aside from who to pick, if I were JD I'd be talking to Issac and his agent and give him two options. A, he leaves the leadership group because his example is poor and if this is the case he fights hard in preseason otherwise the #9 jersey is Nates, B, if he wants to keep acting like a Prima Donna he will keep driving his value down so his agent can try and find him a new home in 2018, we will gladly release him. Issac has gone from a fantastic Kiwi to being comfortably third best Kiwis hooker on the park yesterday. If I'm Kidwell, Levi and Roache are going to the WC, Luke is not.
Who to drop then... If Fus is out CNK comes in. Drop Foran, I saw enough yesterday to join the seeya Kieran brigade. Bring Ata in. Drop Issac to the bench, put Roache to hooker. Let either Bell or Tevaga to reserve grade, and bring in either Pat Sipley or Chris Satae. Screw bringing Tof in, he's made his bed to jump off the ship so why waste time giving him a first grade jumper.