Teams vs. Tigers

[webShark]

Your criticism on David is as bad as Barba. Just confirms your blind bias. All good.

On Barba, I doubted he could ever rediscover his old form. Thought he was a gun who lost pace through injury. Has played better this year I admit. Good for the team.

On 'David', please spare us. Has he EVER played a key role in any first grade game. Tell us when. Stocking filler. Last year , we were supposed to have a strong NSW team and he did squat. But he has had his third successive great pre season. Now a bit quicker and a bit less fat.

As you say all good, unlike David Fifita. Tim Robinson was as good as him. I expect you watch NSW Cup games like me, so I am surprised to be called biased against David Fifita. Never dominated any Reggie game I saw.

I like both Prior and Taga who have had plenty of critics on here. For the record, I don't like the Fifita's you got me. But I do think Andrew , although flawed can play. David is a plodder. Hanging off his brother's coat tails.

 

[bluefox1968]

On Barba, I doubted he could ever rediscover his old form. Thought he was a gun who lost pace through injury. Has played better this year I admit. Good for the team.

On 'David', please spare us. Has he EVER played a key role in any first grade game. Tell us when. Stocking filler. Last year , we were supposed to have a strong NSW team and he did squat. But he has had his third successive great pre season. Now a bit quicker and a bit less fat.

As you say all good, unlike David Fifita. Tim Robinson was as good as him. I expect you watch NSW Cup games like me, so I am surprised to be called biased against David Fifita. Never dominated any Reggie game I saw.

I like both Prior and Taga who have had plenty of critics on here. For the record, I don't like the Fifita's you got me. But I do think Andrew , although flawed can play. David is a plodder. Hanging off his brother's coat tails.

I posted this on another thread, but I saw from very close quarters the Indigenous All-Stars game. He was every bit as good as his brother... Maybe he just had a good game, which can happen in those situations...

However, I'm not ready to totally write him off. I would put him as a fringe player. I don't think he demands a spot, but I don't think he's as ineffective as Robinson was...

 

[cb4]

His first 2 game this year were exactly what you want from an impact bench prop, however, he didn't break the line and score 4 tries so he was crap.
He has outperformed a lot of bench players this year on a raw numbers game alone, let alone line impact and meters made after contact.

 

[Big Bloke]

So are we going to beat this bogey team of ours? Come to think of it, we must be the team in the NRL with the most bogey teams.

Tigers always seem to score lots of points against us. Doesn't matter if it was at Shark Park or Campbelltown we're still going to find it tough.

 

[Jono Russell]

We did smash them last year 40-18

 

[2012....Sharks Year]

We did smash them last year 40-18

Did belt them but they were goners at the time....this year we're both 2 and 2....should be a cracker. On the retention side for me - Keepers Taga ,Boogs, (2 years) Gal/Lewie (1 year ) David Fifita (1 year...keep him keen) Heino- Super league. Prior (1 year if no better option arises)