I think the Couchmen - but in particular Toby - are going to be key leaders for us in 2026 and, if fit and firing, will lead the pack to a better season. I had been slightly pessimistic about our front row with the departure of Klemmer who I thought was clearly our best prop in 2025. But after some consideration I realised the main reason why Klemmer was our best prop: it's because Toby was moved to the backrow and then injured his shoulder. Prior to that, T Couchman was the dude.
The Couchmen just turned 22 a month or so ago. Based on numbers alone, the data suggests middle forwards are at the most productive (aka their peak) between the ages of 24-28, and not in their late 20's or early 30s as many people like to say. Despite being still well under that 24-28 age range, Toby's numbers were formidable for us...
* He was the busiest defender of all our forwards (excluding the hooker), averaging a huge 39.7 tackles a game, more than JDB with 33.52, and way more than the other props Klemmer (29.7) and Guler (26.5). The only prop in the entire NRL who averaged higher was Terrell May, with 42.63.
* With the ball in hand, Toby was a narrow 2nd among our middles for most average metres per game. 106.6, puts him behind JDB with 109.9, but he was well ahead of Klemmer (99.82), Sele (78.4), Lawrie (74.3) and Guler (67.5).
* Toby was our top middle forward for Post Contact Metres - averaging 43.15 per game. Jaydn Sua was the only forward better in this respect, with 46.94. Klemmer was close with 38.45, then its a long drop to JDB with 33.74 and way down to Guler with a pitiful 26.5
* In addition to this, he was also the leading offloader among our middle forwards with 1.23 a game - higher than JDB, Klemmer, Guler, and even Luch Leilua. Again, only Jaydn Sua had a higher number (1.94).
To me, the numbers confirm that, prior to injury, Toby was indeed our best prop. The main question heading into next year might be around his shoulder issues, but he had the reconstruction surgery in around July, so you'd expect the recovery to be fully complete by the start of pre-season training and he'd be ready to hit the ground running. I'm excited to see the form of a more seasoned Toby Couchman (and Ryan) in 2026. Particularly with his surprising offload numbers. Watching Joe Tapine in that Pacific Championships final offloading the Samoans to death basically has me feeling bullish about what a Couchman-Kerr combo (Josh Kerr 1.33 per game) can produce for us.