What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

the fight at the leagues club..

DRAGONZ_RULE

Coach
Messages
16,180
I know it wasn't a dig, mate.
OK cool, got a little worried with your short response when you said "I was clearly wrong" and thought you might have been annoyed.





Anyway, reading some of people's accounts on here, it seems this runs a hell of a lot deeper than what Scipione has said ... there are three sides to every story, as there is with this one (the police version, the victims' version, and the truth) ... it will be somewhere in the middle.


But from what I have been able to glean, from piecing together articles, police statements, coroner's comments, victims' statements, and witnesses statements, it looks to have gone something like this -- and this is all just a hypothesis, meant in no way to incriminate or imply guilt on anyone's part:

1) Argument breaks out between deceased, family and other patrons. Could the family members have been arguing with each other? One news report I read on Monday inferred this possibility.

2) Leagues Club Security Guards and NSW Police rushed over.

3) Police told patrons to 'move on' .. whether this meant 'leave this area' or 'get out of the club and go home', I am unsure.

4) Patrons did not want to leave, said they were going nowhere.

5) Policemen pushed the Vasevski brothers. The Vasevski brothers pushed back (this was admitted by the younger brother on TV).

6) At this sign of retaliation, the police became aggressive. Likewise, the Vasevski brothers, became aggressive, with the deceased apparently picking up a glass / glass bottle and smashing it into a Leagues Club's security guard's face, around the eye socket.

7) Details then become very hazy, with many conflicting reports from all and sundry, but at the least the deceased was blinded with capsicum spray, and hit around the legs/chest area with police batons. Police say he wasn't tasered and wasn't hit in the head with the baton. Witnesses say deceased was tasered multiple times - could they be confusing the deceased with the youngest brother, who has said on TV that he was tasered three times? It would appear that the deceased was not hit with the baton to the head, as confirmed by the coroner's preliminary findings.

8) At some point during (7), the deceased's heart stops beating as he goes into cardiac arrest. Police desperately try to perform CPR on deceased.

9) A number of security guards and policeman are bloodied and dazed after the incident, standing around and appearing to be severely injured. One security guard's face looks a mess (perhaps this was the man who was 'glassed' by the deceased), and he ends up in a neck brace by the time the Leagues Club is closed.

10) Security/police tell patrons there is nothing to see, and to move on .. patrons who have witnessed the exchange ask to make formal statements to the police, but the police refuse to listen to them. Police are not talking to the patrons except to say that there is nothing going on, even though in plain sight behind glass doors, other policeman are performing CPR on the deceased man, who has blood coming out of his left ear and running down his neck -- this could suggest that the blood started coming out of his left ear when he was still in an upright position, as the blood has travelled down his neck (had he been lying down, the blood would go to the back of his neck)?? Would would cause blood to run out of a man's ears if he is still in a standing position but hasn't been hit in the head by a baton? Could electric currents do that??

11) The aftermath ... club is closed, patrons kicked out, ambulance arrives, filmed on TV cameras trying to perform CPR / defib on the deceased in the ambulance in the carpark.



Obviously all conjecture and just trying to piece bits and pieces together ... (7) is clearly the key point, and that's the one that appears to be least clear.

Thoughts?
 

saint-colesy

Juniors
Messages
2,110
I'm not 100% certain but i'm fairly sure i saw two security guards looking a mess in the foyer. I know for sure that 1 was but the other may of been a police officer or one of the brothers.

Either way, they both had blood everywhere and were suffering severe concussion.
 

HellenicArmy

Juniors
Messages
2
It seems like a complete over reaction by the police. Their actions have given this guy a death sentence, effectively taken 60 years off this guys life. A bit of a scuffle, turns into a fight and a guy ends up dead. No judge would ever sentence someone to death for that, so why do the police over react and impose their own death sentence?

Last time something like this happened in Greece, there were 12 days of riots. Here in Australia, no one gives a hoot. Although from the 2gb interview one witness said that a guy goes to the police, theirs 5000 of us and 100 of you. So it seems it must have been pretty tense at St George Leagues club.

What I want to know, is the Dragon Army going to remember this guy in any way, ie banners at games to mark respect for a fallen brother. Cos at the end of the day a St George Supporter is now deceased. For example, when Olympiakos fans stabbed Panathinaikos fan to death, the Panathiaikos fans had large banners with photos of the guy killed at games, as a mark of respect. Are St George fans planning to do the same?

Back to the incident. The guy killed from an ethnic race not well liked by us Greeks, however, he was still a human being and it could have been anyone that was killed that night. An innocent bystanter, a female etc, cos the club was packed, it could have been anyone.

When will the footage of the incident be released to the public? Only then will we be able to decide for ourselves who was at fault from the footage. From what I have read though, they police's version of events does not marry up at all with many witnesses versions of events. To me it sounds as if Bosevski was beaten to a pulp till his heart shut down. One strike with a batton can kill, but to be smashed ten times with it, terrible.

Here is a link to the 2gb radio interview from a witness who was there.

www .2gb.com/index2.php?option=com_newsmanager&task=view&id=7144&sms_ss=facebook&at_xt=4cabd5b2f19d48cd%2C0

Anyway, may the deceased victim RIP.

We will hear more. BTW When is Bosevski's funeral?
 

blake1979

Juniors
Messages
94
It seems like a complete over reaction by the police. Their actions have given this guy a death sentence, effectively taken 60 years off this guys life. A bit of a scuffle, turns into a fight and a guy ends up dead. No judge would ever sentence someone to death for that, so why do the police over react and impose their own death sentence?

Last time something like this happened in Greece, there were 12 days of riots. Here in Australia, no one gives a hoot. Although from the 2gb interview one witness said that a guy goes to the police, theirs 5000 of us and 100 of you. So it seems it must have been pretty tense at St George Leagues club.

What I want to know, is the Dragon Army going to remember this guy in any way, ie banners at games to mark respect for a fallen brother. Cos at the end of the day a St George Supporter is now deceased. For example, when Olympiakos fans stabbed Panathinaikos fan to death, the Panathiaikos fans had large banners with photos of the guy killed at games, as a mark of respect. Are St George fans planning to do the same?

Back to the incident. The guy killed from an ethnic race not well liked by us Greeks, however, he was still a human being and it could have been anyone that was killed that night. An innocent bystanter, a female etc, cos the club was packed, it could have been anyone.

When will the footage of the incident be released to the public? Only then will we be able to decide for ourselves who was at fault from the footage. From what I have read though, they police's version of events does not marry up at all with many witnesses versions of events. To me it sounds as if Bosevski was beaten to a pulp till his heart shut down. One strike with a batton can kill, but to be smashed ten times with it, terrible.

Here is a link to the 2gb radio interview from a witness who was there.

www .2gb.com/index2.php?option=com_newsmanager&task=view&id=7144&sms_ss=facebook&at_xt=4cabd5b2f19d48cd%2C0

Anyway, may the deceased victim RIP.

We will hear more. BTW When is Bosevski's funeral?

I agree it sounds terrible but in reality its not necessarily terrible , if you have to strike someone ten times with a baton to get them under control thats REASONABLE and NECESSARY if the bloke is on the ground and in cuffs and he still being struck thats UNREASONABLE .

It all depends on the circumstances on when he was struck
 

HellenicArmy

Juniors
Messages
2
Well when they release the footage of the incident and hopefully they do soon, then the public will be able to decide if it was reasonable and necessary.
 

blake1979

Juniors
Messages
94
Well when they release the footage of the incident and hopefully they do soon, then the public will be able to decide if it was reasonable and necessary.

I am unsure as to whether the footage will allowed to be released if its being used as evidence , not 100% sure though
 

Dragons_#1

Bench
Messages
4,292
I am unsure as to whether the footage will allowed to be released if its being used as evidence , not 100% sure though

The footage will not be released at all...

I'd love to know where Ur getting to read up on police versions?? Even other police officers don't have access to these!!
 

blake1979

Juniors
Messages
94
The footage will not be released at all...

I'd love to know where Ur getting to read up on police versions?? Even other police officers don't have access to these!!

I have not read any versions full stop , where did i say i did , i just replied to a comment regarding use of force. I was not actually referring to this particular incident but in general , sorry for the confusion..
 
Messages
4,407
The footage has been released, and it shows that the police didn't hit him in the head with a baton as claimed by some witnesses. It also shows that the deceased was not tasered (but he was sprayed), but his brother was tasered. Whether it's the full footage or just a snippet i have no idea, nor do i know if any parts of the footage are obstructed or inconclusive.

EDIT - Link:
http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-league/...agues-club-death-released-20101009-16d4d.html
 
Last edited:

boxa777

Coach
Messages
12,388
Wrong & Wrong

Tell me how did you know so definitively none of those things happened? Have you seen the footage today?

http://www.smh.com.au/nsw/footage-shows-batons-used-in-deadly-brawl-20101012-16hsr.html?autostart=1

I heard strong reports from people that I know but refrained from adding in because I wanted to see some actual proof. But it's people like you that take the automatic stance that the police would never cross the line that allow our society to be vulnerable to over-zealous cops.
 
Last edited:

YEHHHBOYYYD

Juniors
Messages
992
I got a call from Hurstville police station yesterday asking me if i had seen anything on the night. Probably coz i signed into the Taj in the morning for an early beer.
 

_Johnsy

Referee
Messages
28,272
Tell me how did you know so definitively none of those things happened? Have you seen the footage today?

http://www.smh.com.au/nsw/footage-shows-batons-used-in-deadly-brawl-20101012-16hsr.html?autostart=1

I heard strong reports from people that I know but refrained from adding in because I wanted to see some actual proof. But it's people like you that take the automatic stance that the police would never cross the line that allow our society to be vulnerable to over-zealous cops.

The coroner has confirmed that the deceased male was not struck with a baton in the head as some suggested. The deceased male was not tasered as some had suggested.

FFS I never stated that Police never do anything wrong, nor did I suggest that the Police did not cross "any line" or these Police were over zealous. Take a breath sunshine and actually read what I posted instead of jumping to conclusions.

So my post you referenced was right.
 
Last edited:

boxa777

Coach
Messages
12,388
The coroner has confirmed that the deceased male was not struck with a baton in the head as some suggested. The deceased male was not tasered as some had suggested.

FFS I never stated that Police never do anything wrong, nor did I suggest that the Police did not cross "any line" or these Police were over zealous. Take a breath sunshine and actually read what I posted instead of jumping to conclusions.

So my post you referenced was right.

Have you seen the footage?
 

Dave Q

Coach
Messages
11,065
I am generally sympathetic to the trials of everyday policing.

It can be a tough and difficult job. Police have my deepest respect.

But at the end of the day, they are a public service. Their available use of force and lethal force, is a heavy responsibility.

I support the use of tasers as an alternative to the glock and in special cases.

I expect some gentle leeway to be offered to police in certain instances.

I support the use of the baton as trained.

But in these circumstances, the footage indicates that some of the Police who attended the scene, well might be facing charges of a criminal nature themselves.

A young man is dead. It doesnt get anymore serious than this.

If Police committ criminal offences, then they should be held to account like everybody else.
 
Last edited:

league

Juniors
Messages
1,642
so bashing an already handcuffed and restrained man to death with a baton is considered reasonable and necessary????

these police must face justice, they're guilty of this tragic death I'm afraid.
 

Latest posts

Top