The men and the madman - Mafia Game (Night 8)

[Scott Gourley's Lovechild]

Carpenter isn't mafia you noob. Only two mafia left, whall15 (the don) and Armani (unknown).

 

[BunniesMan]

Alright, it was SGL who made the suggestion, obviously thinking mickyj was Carpenter. Now we know, based on DB's info, that UP is very likely Carpenter. Do you still think the Carpenter character is scum SGL?

And I still want to hear something from UP. I note he made a vote with no comment once the train was well and truly rolling. Throwing your mate under the bus, UP? Why did you target Mis all those nights ago? Did you get your buddies to redirect your kill to Monk to make you look townie?

That's all he has done. All of his posts:

Yeah f**k Monk
vote Monk

vote pp

Been busy at work, having lunch now and just had a read through. Im going to trust Apey

vote BM

vote mickyj

 

[BunniesMan]

Carpenter isn't mafia you noob. Only two mafia left, whall15 (the don) and Armani (unknown).

Armani is UP

 

[Jason Maher]

Well, going by the write up in question, if it's not you then it's HowHigh.

The scientist is mentioned in 3 separate write-ups protecting someone. I also had a 1-use power absorb ability (target someone, get their power for the rets of the game), which I used on PP, gaining his revive power. Drew made a deal with me that if I used the revive power on PP to fix his mistake, he'd give me a permanent protect power. I revived PP, protected myself (multiple times), protected Mis, protected DB.

I targeted the recently deceased PP on night 1 because: A) Drew didn't say anything about not targeting a dead person (i.e. I was testing whether I could); B) PP was revealed to be a Doctor, and the standard Doctor power is protection, which I thought would be nice to have.

Which brings me to my question for you: how do you connect the protections (that aren't me) to HH?

 

[BunniesMan]

VERY SIMPLY:

DB says he saw UP target MJ

DB's character saw a getaway car.

The getaway car was driven by Armani, Armani protected the henchman (MJ).

Therefore, UP = Armani

 

[Jason Maher]

OK, what the Bunny says makes sense. We lynch UP tomorrow then.

 

[BunniesMan]

The scientist is mentioned in 3 separate write-ups protecting someone. I also had a 1-use power absorb ability (target someone, get their power for the rets of the game), which I used on PP, gaining his revive power. Drew made a deal with me that if I used the revive power on PP to fix his mistake, he'd give me a permanent protect power. I revived PP, protected myself (multiple times), protected Mis, protected DB.

I targeted the recently deceased PP on night 1 because: A) Drew didn't say anything about not targeting a dead person (i.e. I was testing whether I could); B) PP was revealed to be a Doctor, and the standard Doctor power is protection, which I thought would be nice to have.

Which brings me to my question for you: how do you connect the protections (that aren't me) to HH?

Why would drew have to "make a deal" with you. Wouldn't you naturally want PP alive without being asked

 

[KeepingTheFaith]

Done.

dru, yeu sur yeu done Dru? Apples still in live list.

 

[Scott Gourley's Lovechild]

Alright, I'll let you slide for now JM. But we need to find Armani

 

[BunniesMan]

Alright, I'll let you slide for now JM. But we need to find Armani

Seriously?

Why do you not think UP is Armani? What part of what I said is wrong?

 

[Drew-Sta]

Apey is off alive list. Going to bed now.

 

[Scott Gourley's Lovechild]

Seriously?

Why do you not think UP is Armani? What part of what I said is wrong?

I'm just curious to why JM has been labeling UP as Carpenter.

 

[BunniesMan]

What's scaring me is drew said the game was heading to a grandstand finish.

That's why I'm worried theres 3 left, not 2. If it's just UP and whall there's not much to go. If there's up and whall AND another unknown mafia then it's a lot tougher for us

 

[Scott Gourley's Lovechild]

Well, when I die tonight, go after JM quick smart.

 

[BunniesMan]

I'm just curious to why JM has been labeling UP as Carpenter.

JM doesn't know what he's talking about (no offense JM, you know I love ya). He didn't know who Moroney was.

As long as drew didnt f**k up the writeup, UP is clearly Armani.

What I'm worried about is a possible 5th mafia man. Is JM just derping today or is he the 5th...

 

[Parra Pride]

Well, when I die tonight, go after JM quick smart.

Are you serious? Please tell me you aren't.

 

[Parra Pride]

The Henchman moved with deliberate intent. He targeted a man who he knew might have protection, but took the risk anyway. He cornered the scientist and attempted to beat him to a bloody pulp with his hands. But the scientist was protected by his experiment which he had chose to shield himself with. He would not die tonight, although he was not unvulnerable…

The first bolded part is quite obviously a hint at the fact JM always has protection.

The second is confirmation he is the scientist.

Once again the Henchman determined to return to his previous target. And once again, the scientist utilised his own protective experiment for his own selfish use. Although, one might argue that in these two instances, his selfish usage was allowing his fellow town the chance to enjoy his protection later in the game.

The Henchman attempted brutal force again, but was unable to crack the scientists protective abilities.

Mafia go for him again, and he protects himself again.

The bolded makes him town.

Night 5 Results

With the madman gone, the town breathed a sigh of relief. But of course, the mafia were not going to let them get off that easily…

Clarence Moroney walked over to Walter Stanley. Although he was convincing in his discussion to change targets, Walter refused to use his power this night.

Moroney, frustrated by Stanley’s decision, instead stole the wharfy’s knife. Aiming at the PI, he moved to kill Roger Fitzharding who happened to be tracking a getaway car. The poor man had no real chance to defend himself… until THE f**kING SCIENTIST CAME OUT OF NOWHERE, ALMOST TOO LATE AND SAID ‘GET THAT SHIT OUT OF HERE! BETTER LATE THAN NEVER!’

Roger Fitzharding is ALIVE, he is town aligned Personal Investigator.

And finally, the scientist/JM protects our investigator.

Tell me more about why we should kill JM if you die, SGL.

 

[Jason Maher]

Yes, I haven't been paying attention to f**king character names. I forgot whall's. Sue me.

 

[BunniesMan]

Just reread every night writeup. No apparent sign of Mafioso #5. Surely they haven't kept him quiet all this time.

Odds are it's just UP and whall standing between us and the finish line

--

The Henchman moved with deliberate intent. He targeted a man who he knew might have protection, but took the risk anyway. He cornered the scientist and attempted to beat him to a bloody pulp with his hands. But the scientist was protected by his experiment which he had chose to shield himself with. He would not die tonight, although he was not unvulnerable?

JM is the scientist. The scientist has been very helpful.

 

[Jason Maher]

I didn't realise a second of my self-protects had saved me/been written up. Need to read these things more carefully.