The men and the madman - Mafia Game (Night 8)

[Jason Maher]

It would be handy if that f**kstick Drew would put the links to the night posts after night 3, of course.

 

[Jason Maher]

And of course, the fact I said that guaranteed that he had just done so.

 

[BunniesMan]

The first bolded part is quite obviously a hint at the fact JM always has protection.

The second is confirmation he is the scientist.




Mafia go for him again, and he protects himself again.

The bolded makes him town.



And finally, the scientist/JM protects our investigator.

Tell me more about why we should kill JM if you die, SGL.

Great minds think alike! I literally looked at every writeup just to make sure while you were simultaneously doing the same thing. JM is good.

Unless there is a hidden mafia that hasn't shown up at all, SGL just derped (much like JM did earler)

 

[Jason Maher]

Why would drew have to "make a deal" with you. Wouldn't you naturally want PP alive without being asked

You'd have to ask Drew why he played it that way.

 

[BunniesMan]

And of course, the fact I said that guaranteed that he had just done so.

:lol:

He hadn't until I asked him to. You're welcome.

And sorry for doubting ya earlier. I missed the early hint that is now painfully obvious. Without you DB dies before he can telling us his info which I worked out to mean UP is the last unknown bad guy.

Could have turned out extremely different if DB died. Lucky you showed up just in time to do your night action.

 

[BunniesMan]

You'd have to ask Drew why he played it that way.

Yeah it's all good now. Everything in my head has now clicked about you. At the time of writing that post you replied to I still hadn't gone back to recheck things.

 

[Scott Gourley's Lovechild]

I just can't trust JM, he's married to a ranga and has ranga kinds. Gotta watch those guys...

 

[Jason Maher]

Alright, summary time:

PP - Morgan Brown - Doctor - revive power
DB - Roger Fitzharding - Personal investigator - tracker
JM - ? (revealing my name would be telling tales out of school, since Drew hasn't put it in the write-ups) - Scientst - absorb/revive (1 use), protect (permanent)
Mis - Walter Stanley - Union Scum - vigilante
KtF - Vincent Mason - Town Drunk - post condition

whall - Clarence Moroney - Mafia Mastermind - JM layers of protection, redirect
UP - Bruno Armani - Getaway Driver - scum protector

That leaves BM, SGL, and SMBN. One is a Cabaret Dancer, one is Greg Carpenter - Snooker Champion - vigilante (I believe), one is ??? (I seem to recall something in a back and forth between SMBN and whall about SMBN being a priest?).

This is based on Drew's write-ups. I'm now reading back over what everyone else has written to nail down the last 3, if I can.

 

[Jason Maher]

Confession: I actually couldn't remember my character name anyway. I had multiple tabs open with the night write-ups and a couple of other things, and couldn't have been arsed opening another one to check my name. I'll still keep it up my sleeve, as it is not information Drew has made public.

 

[BunniesMan]

Alright, summary time:

PP - Morgan Brown - Doctor - revive power
DB - Roger Fitzharding - Personal investigator - tracker
JM - ? (revealing my name would be telling tales out of school, since Drew hasn't put it in the write-ups) - Scientst - absorb/revive (1 use), protect (permanent)
Mis - Walter Stanley - Union Scum - vigilante
KtF - Vincent Mason - Town Drunk - post condition

whall - Clarence Moroney - Mafia Mastermind - JM layers of protection, redirect
UP - Bruno Armani - Getaway Driver - scum protector

That leaves BM, SGL, and SMBN. One is a Cabaret Dancer, one is Greg Carpenter - Snooker Champion - vigilante (I believe), one is ??? (I seem to recall something in a back and forth between SMBN and whall about SMBN being a priest?).

This is based on Drew's write-ups. I'm now reading back over what everyone else has written to nail down the last 3, if I can.

Seeing as I've done the most to make people realise UP is Armani surely I can be in blue?

P.S. I'm the dancer.

 

[Jason Maher]

Bah! Of course PP has other powers - his inoculation of KtF, which I presume was a 1-use. Is the effect permanent PP? Also his blood testing, which is pointless now Apey is dead.

 

[Jason Maher]

BM, give me time. I only read Drew's night posts for that. Now I'm reading everything else.

 

[Jason Maher]

Here's a hunch: UP is a silent goon. He only votes, never speaks. Perhaps he has the silence power in addition to his protect power. Or perhaps there is a 5th goon. In which case my money would be on SMBN, who has been almost as quiet.

I note UP never responded at all to my earlier posts, and he was online at the time.

 

[Jason Maher]

Note also Drew is an Anglican (I think), so it would make sense for the Anglican Bishop to be good and the Catholic Priest to be bad. ;-)

 

[Parra Pride]

It's permanent, KTF can't die.

 

[Jason Maher]

Grrr... left HH out. Add him to the unknown list. Could be scum #5, if there is one.

 

[Jason Maher]

Alright, *updated* summary time:

Known townies:

PP - Morgan Brown - Doctor - revive power
DB - Roger Fitzharding - Personal investigator - tracker
JM - Augustus Clark - Scientst - absorb/revive (1 use), protect (permanent)
Mis - Walter Stanley - Union Scum - vigilante
KtF - Vincent Mason - Town Drunk - post condition

Pretty damned sure on these two:

BM - ? - Cabaret Dancer - ?
SGL - Greg Carpenter - Snooker Champion - vigilante

Known scumbags:

whall - Clarence Moroney - Mafia Mastermind - JM layers of protection, redirect
UP - Bruno Armani - Getaway Driver - scum protector

Unknown:

SMBN - ? - Catholic Priest - ?
HH - ???

I think we need to lynch UP tomorrow and try to clear up these two tonight. SMBN seems like town, but his claim could well be orchestrated with whall. HH I'm not really sure on.

Mis, I would be inclined to use your kill tonight. Let the Mafia redirect it if they want. Hopefully the write-up might give us a clue about the person you target that helps us.

DB - investigate one of the two unknowns.

 

[BunniesMan]

I was concerned about a possible 5th man but there has been absolutely nothing in the writeups that could point to another mafia role

 

[sensesmaybenumbed]

Confession: I actually couldn't remember my character name anyway. I had multiple tabs open with the night write-ups and a couple of other things, and couldn't have been arsed opening another one to check my name. I'll still keep it up my sleeve, as it is not information Drew has made public.

Consider your sins Absolved.

Now throw 3 hail Mary's.

 

[Misanthrope]

Alright, I'll use my kill tonight. I'll keep who I target quiet.